We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
For a small team focused on benefits enrollment, ACA reporting, and payroll connections, Employee Navigator is worth considering through your broker. Choose Paycom if you want payroll and HR on one database, employee self-service, and a dedicated service team. Neither vendor publishes prices or offers a free plan, so we can’t name a cheapest option or calculate a team-of-five bill. Get quotes that spell out modules, support, setup, and add-on fees.
01Side by side
| Employee Navigator | Paycom | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan | No free plan |
| Cheapest paid plan | Enhanced; price not published | Core setup; custom quote |
| Price per seat | Not published | Not published |
| Cost for a team of 5 | Not published | Not published |
| Setup effort | Timeline not published | Dedicated implementation team |
| Learning curve | Not published | Not published |
| Integrations for small teams | Homepage claims 600+ integrations | Integration count not published |
| Support | Phone and email may cost extra | Dedicated ongoing support team |
Employee Navigator Choose Employee Navigator if
- Choose Employee Navigator if your broker recommends its benefits platform.
- Choose Employee Navigator if you need ACA reporting and carrier integrations.
- Choose Employee Navigator if onboarding and time-off tracking matter.
Paycom Choose Paycom if
- Choose Paycom if you want payroll and HR on one database.
- Choose Paycom if employees should manage their own HR and payroll information.
- Choose Paycom if a dedicated implementation and support team is important.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor lists a free plan, and neither publishes a starting price. Employee Navigator’s entry plan is Enhanced, aimed at brokers needing benefits administration; pricing is quote-only. Paycom offers a custom quote starting from a Core setup, with cost shaped by workforce size and selected modules. For one person, neither vendor publishes a per-seat figure. For a team of three to five, there is no reliable total to calculate: Employee Navigator does not publish plan prices or monthly and annual terms, and Paycom does not publish module rates or billing terms. Employee Navigator lists 834 EDI at $0.45 PEPM on Enhanced Plus and Elite, free on Platinum, and unavailable on Enhanced. Additional reporting and support fees may apply, but amounts aren’t published. Ask both vendors for written quotes covering five employees, required modules, setup, and add-ons.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline, so ask how long implementation typically takes for a team your size. Paycom says clients receive a dedicated team for implementation, payroll processing, and ongoing support. Employee Navigator offers benefits administration, HR tools, onboarding, and time-off tracking, but its plan details don’t state an implementation timeline or the amount of work the employer must do. Before choosing, ask who loads employee and benefits data, who checks payroll or enrollment records, and what support is included in the quoted price. Paycom’s single database is designed to update employee information throughout its software. Employee Navigator connects employers, brokers, and partners. In both cases, confirm which systems and data your team must configure.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Employee Navigator’s Enhanced plan includes online enrollment, carrier, payroll, and TPA integrations, ACA reporting, and AI Plan Builds. Enhanced Plus adds 834 EDI files and third-party apps; Elite adds an enrollment assistance tool, new-hire onboarding, and PTO and vacation tracking. Platinum adds priority phone support and makes 834 EDI free. These are broker-oriented plans, so ask your broker which tier fits your company and what fees apply. Paycom’s quote starts from a Core setup, but the vendor does not publish its price or a fixed entry-level feature list. Its listed capabilities include payroll automation with Beti, employee self-service, a single employee-data database, time-off decisions, and IWant AI data access. Payroll, Talent Acquisition, Time and Labor Management, Talent Management, and HR Management are listed as modules; ask which are included in your quote.
Questions people ask
Does Paycom offer health insurance?
Paycom’s offering centers on HR and payroll, but the available details don’t establish whether it sells or underwrites health insurance. If you mean whether it can work with a particular employee health plan, ask Paycom and your benefits broker which carrier connections and administration services are included.
What are people saying about Employee Navigator?
Our review rates Employee Navigator 6.5 out of 10, with its strongest score for features and weaker marks for value. The practical takeaway: consider it through your broker, but get a written quote before budgeting, including any reporting and support fees.
Is Paycom an HRIS system?
Paycom is HR and payroll software, with employee self-service, HR tools, and a single database for employee information. Those features fit what many teams look for in an HR information system. Ask for a module-by-module list to confirm what your quote includes.
How secure is Paycom?
Ask Paycom for current security documentation before storing employee records or payroll details. We recommend confirming its data-protection controls, access management, incident-response process, and terms for handling employee information, then checking that your team’s security requirements are covered in writing.