We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick Square Loyalty.
Choose Square Loyalty if you already use Square or want a published price: it starts at $60 per location monthly for up to 500 loyalty visits. Choose Fivestars if its automated messaging, customer database, and acquisition offers suit your needs, but ask for a quote first; the vendor does not publish pricing. Neither lists a free plan. For a small team, Square is easier to budget for, while Fivestars is harder to compare before a sales conversation.
01Side by side
| Fivestars | Square Loyalty | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan | No free plan |
| Cheapest paid plan | Price not published | $60/location/month, up to 500 visits |
| Price per seat | Not published | Location-based, not seat-based |
| Cost for a team of 5 | Not published | $60/month at one location |
| Setup effort | Setup time not published | Setup time not published |
| Learning curve | Ease score: 5/10 | Ease score: 7/10 |
| Integrations a small team needs | Not specified | Hundreds of app partners |
| Support | Review score: 5/10 | Review score: 5/10 |
Fivestars Choose Fivestars if
- Choose Fivestars if automated customer messaging is a priority.
- Choose Fivestars if you want a customer database tied to transactions.
- Choose Fivestars if customer acquisition offers and rewards fit your plan.
Square Loyalty Choose Square Loyalty if
- Choose Square Loyalty if you already use Square's point of sale.
- Choose Square Loyalty if you want a published starting price.
- Choose Square Loyalty if app connections and team tools matter.
02What each costs a small team
Neither product lists a free plan, so a small team should budget for paid access rather than expect a free tier. Fivestars' pricing page does not publish plans or a starting price. Ask the vendor for a quote and confirm whether billing is per location, seat, or usage.
Square lists $60 per location per month for 0–500 loyalty visits. The count is per location and includes enrollment, earning points, or redeeming rewards. For one person at one location, that is $60 monthly. A three-to-five-person team at that same location is also priced at $60 per month under the published location-based tier; it is not a per-seat quote. Annual billing and the price for more visits are not published, so ask Square how usage changes the bill.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a time-to-launch estimate, so we would not plan around a promised setup window. Before signing, ask what information, staff training, and point-of-sale changes are needed to start earning and redeeming rewards.
Fivestars describes a customer database tied to transactions, loyalty rewards, automated messages, and performance insights. A small team should clarify who will maintain customer records and messages, and how much can be automated. Square describes loyalty alongside marketing campaigns and its point-of-sale platform. Its listed visit count includes enrollment, earning points, or redeeming rewards, so teams should understand how those actions affect their monthly allowance. Review scores rate ease of use 5/10 for Fivestars and 7/10 for Square, but they are not setup-time estimates.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Fivestars describes automated and AI-enhanced messages, a transaction-linked customer database, loyalty rewards, offers to potential customers nearby, performance insights, and review requests with rewards. Its pricing page does not publish plans or say which features are included at a particular price, so ask for a feature-by-feature quote before comparing it with Square.
Square's published $60 tier covers 0–500 loyalty visits per location per month. Square counts enrollment, earning points, and redeeming rewards as visits. The homepage also describes marketing campaigns alongside loyalty, plus in-person and online sales through its point-of-sale platform, app connections, and team administration tools. The pricing details do not say which of those broader Square tools are included in the loyalty price. Confirm the plan boundaries and reward mechanics before relying on them for a small team's budget.
Questions people ask
What is the Square loyalty program?
Square describes it as a loyalty program for welcoming new customers and encouraging repeat visits. Businesses can pair it with marketing campaigns. Its published pricing counts loyalty visits per location, including enrollment, earning points, and redeeming rewards.
How much are 10,000 loyalty points worth?
Square's homepage does not describe specific reward mechanics or set a cash value for points. The $60 monthly price covers a visit allowance, not the value of points. Ask the business running the program how its rewards convert points into discounts or benefits.
What are the 10 most common types of loyalty programs?
There is no single list established by these products. The descriptions mention loyalty rewards, earning points, and visit-based counting. If you are choosing a program, ask each vendor which reward structures it supports and how customers earn and redeem rewards.
What are the downsides of running a loyalty program?
For Square, the published starting tier costs $60 per location monthly and counts enrollment, earning points, and redemptions toward its visit allowance. Both vendors' descriptions leave reward mechanics to clarify, so ask about costs, rules, and how rewards affect your margins before launch.