We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A small shop may not need Fivestars if a simpler loyalty setup or occasional rewards can bring customers back. The key is matching the tool to the job: some picks below focus on repeat visits, while others handle gifts or bulk rewards instead. Walletly starts at $15, Square Loyalty at $60 and Kangaroo Rewards at $79. For any option, ask about setup, seat limits and the full price before signing.
01Why people leave Fivestars
The price may be hard to justify
One Reddit commenter reported paying $200 a month for Fivestars’ full feature set; that can be a lot for a small shop.
Contract concerns
A different commenter complained about an expensive contract and said the sales promises did not match their experience.
Features may not fit your business
One commenter said Fivestars could not send SMS for their vape stores. Confirm your use case and messaging rules before committing.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Lower-cost loyalty
WalletlyWalletly
Walletly is worth a look if you want wallet-based loyalty and online and in-store campaigns without Fivestars’ reported $200 monthly price. It starts at $15 and has no free plan. Seat details are unclear, so ask what a few staff accounts cost and what setup requires before choosing it.
Trade-off: No free plan, and seat details are unclear.
6.0/10from
$15/mo - Square sellers
Square LoyaltySquare LoyaltySquare Loyalty fits a one-location business already using Square that wants rewards tied to repeat visits. It starts at $60 and is positioned for businesses under 500 visits. That is a clearer starting point than custom pricing, but ask what setup involves and whether your visit volume fits.
Trade-off: The $60 starting price needs to earn its keep.
6.2/10from
$60/mo - Single-store loyalty
Kangaroo RewardsKangaroo RewardsKangaroo Rewards is aimed at single-store businesses starting loyalty, including teams connecting in-store and online sales or automating customer campaigns. Its monthly entry point is $79, with no free plan. Before signing, ask about onboarding effort, staff access and the total cost for your store.
Trade-off: No free plan; the monthly entry point is $79.
6.4/10from
$79/mo - Occasional customer gifts
GoodyGoodyGoody makes more sense if your goal is sending thank-you gifts rather than running visit-based loyalty. Its Starter plan costs nothing for eligible shipping regions, and the listed starting price is $20. Check whether your recipients are in eligible regions, then ask what setup and team access involve.
Trade-off: It is for gifting, not a visit-based loyalty program.
7.2/10from
$20/mofree plan - Bulk reward sending
TremendousTremendousTremendous suits teams that need to send rewards in bulk, track them or reach recipients internationally. It has a free plan, though a starting price for a few staff seats is not listed. Ask about reward costs, team access and setup; this is a rewards tool, not a local loyalty program.
Trade-off: It does not replace local repeat-visit campaigns.
7.8/10from
Freefree plan - Custom loyalty programs
ClutchClutchClutch is for businesses that want a tailored loyalty program, retention campaigns or several loyalty modules. Its pricing is custom, so a small team should request a quote for its exact needs before spending time on setup. Ask what onboarding includes and whether you can start with only the modules you need.
Trade-off: Custom pricing makes the budget harder to judge.
5.5/10from
Custom
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5.5 | Custom | No | Local shops building repeat visits | |
| Walletly Walletly | 6.0 | $15/mo | No | Businesses running wallet-based loyalty |
| 6.2 | $60/mo | No | Square sellers seeking repeat visits | |
| 6.4 | $79/mo | No | Single-store businesses starting loyalty | |
| 7.2 | $20/mo | Yes | Small teams sending business gifts | |
| 7.8 | Free | Yes | Teams sending rewards in bulk | |
| 5.5 | Custom | No | Businesses building tailored loyalty programs |
Questions people ask
What is the cheapest Fivestars alternative?
Goody has a free Starter plan for eligible shipping regions, but it focuses on gifting rather than local loyalty. Among the listed loyalty options, Walletly starts at $15, with no free plan and unclear seat details. Ask vendors for the full cost for your team and use case.
How much does Fivestars cost?
One commenter on r/smallbusiness reported paying $200 per month for Fivestars with all the features. That is a user report, not a confirmed quote for every business. Ask Fivestars for written pricing, contract length and any fees tied to your store and messaging needs.
Which alternative is best for a local shop?
For a shop already using Square, Square Loyalty is positioned for one-location businesses under 500 visits and starts at $60. Kangaroo Rewards is another single-store option, starting at $79 per month. Compare setup, staff access and the total price before deciding.
