review galore

Head-to-head · Payroll tools

Gusto vs Roll by ADP

For a small one-state team, Gusto costs less. Roll by ADP stands out for 50-state payroll and listed 24/7 live chat.

Gusto

6.8/10
VS

Roll by ADP

6.0/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick Gusto.

For a small team watching monthly costs, Gusto is the better starting point: Simple is $49 per month plus $6 per person, and includes payroll tax filings and basic PTO. Roll by ADP costs $59 plus $7 per worker, but lists payroll in all 50 states and 24/7 live chat. Neither has a permanent free plan. Choose based on your payroll footprint and support needs, and confirm Roll’s per-worker billing interval and introductory-offer terms before budgeting.

01Side by side

GustoRoll by ADP
Free planNo free plan listedNo free plan; three months free offer
Cheapest paid planSimple: $49 monthly baseRoll: $59 monthly base
Price per seat$6 per person monthly$7 per worker; interval unstated
Five-person monthly cost$79 at listed rates$94 at listed rates
Setup effortSetup time not publishedSetup time not published
Learning curveLearning time not publishedChat-based payroll interface
Small-team integrationsConfirm compatibility with your appsConfirm compatibility with your apps
SupportPremium account support on Premium24/7 unlimited live chat listed

Choose Gusto if

  • Choose Gusto if one-state payroll at a lower monthly price matters.
  • Choose Gusto if you want HR and benefits options beyond payroll.
  • Choose Gusto if basic PTO policies and holiday pay fit your needs.

Choose Roll by ADP if

  • Choose Roll by ADP if you need payroll in all 50 states.
  • Choose Roll by ADP if chat-based payroll suits your team.
  • Choose Roll by ADP if listed 24/7 live chat is a priority.

02What each costs a small team

Neither product has a permanent free plan. Roll lists a three-month-free offer, but confirm the terms behind the asterisk before budgeting; Gusto doesn’t publish a free trial. Gusto Simple is $49 monthly plus $6 per person, for one-state payroll. That works out to $55 for one person, $67 for three, and $79 for five. Roll lists $59 monthly plus $7 per worker: $66 for one, $80 for three, and $94 for five at the listed rates. Roll doesn’t state the billing interval for its per-worker charge, so confirm that detail. These totals exclude benefits and add-ons. Gusto Plus costs $80 monthly plus $12 per person and is the tier to consider for multi-state payroll; Roll lists payroll in all 50 states. For a tiny one-state team, Gusto costs less.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate, so we wouldn’t plan around a specific number of hours or days. Before choosing, ask each vendor what information and steps are needed to configure your payroll and tax filings. Gusto also offers hiring and onboarding tools, time tracking, and benefits, but the Simple plan’s listed inclusions are narrower: payroll, tax filings, basic PTO policies, and holiday pay. Roll focuses on payroll through a chat-style interface, with automated tax filing and deposits. Its GenAI assistant offers suggestions at no extra charge, according to the product details. Gusto’s learning curve isn’t published; Roll’s conversational controls may appeal to a team that prefers chat, but that alone doesn’t establish how quickly employees will learn it.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Gusto Simple includes unlimited payrolls, tax filings and payments, basic PTO policies, and holiday pay. It’s aimed at small teams running payroll in one state. Don’t assume that the wider Gusto feature set is all included: time tracking and multi-state payroll are listed with Plus, while Premium adds HR guidance and premium account support. Benefits such as health insurance and 401(k) are available through Gusto, but their costs vary or are separate. Roll’s single listed plan includes unlimited payroll, payroll in all 50 states, unlimited live chat support, and same-day and next-day direct deposit availability. The plan also lists a three-month-free offer. Its GenAI assistant and chat-based payroll are product features, while automated tax filing and deposits are handled by the service. If payroll is your only need, both cover the basics; Gusto lists more plan tiers for adding HR tools as your team grows.

Questions people ask

Is Gusto payroll good?

Gusto is worth considering if you want payroll with tax filings plus options for HR, hiring, time tracking, and benefits. Its Simple plan costs $49 monthly plus $6 per person and covers one-state payroll. Our review rates its features well, while flagging value and support as areas to weigh.

How do I terminate my Gusto account?

Gusto’s account-termination steps and timing aren’t published in the pricing details. Contact Gusto support before canceling and ask about your final payroll, tax filings, employee records, and any account-closeout requirements. Confirm when service and billing stop before you proceed.

Can I learn ADP on my own?

Roll by ADP uses a chat-style payroll interface, which may feel approachable if you prefer conversational controls. ADP doesn’t publish a learning-time estimate in the plan details, so ask what self-serve training or onboarding is available before signing up.

Is ADP a good payroll provider?

Roll by ADP may suit a small business that wants automated payroll taxes, payroll in all 50 states, and listed 24/7 live chat. It starts at $59 monthly plus $7 per worker. Compare its offer terms and confirm the per-worker billing interval before deciding.