We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick Gusto.
For a small team that needs to run payroll, Gusto is the clearer fit: its Simple plan starts at $49 per month plus $6 per person. WorkBright is for teams focused on I-9s, E-Verify, and audit-ready employment records. Its platform price isn’t published, so ask for a quote before comparing budgets. WorkBright+ costs $25 per I-9 record, but that service isn’t the same as a priced platform subscription.
01Side by side
| Gusto | WorkBright | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan | No free plan |
| Cheapest paid option | Simple: $49/month plus $6/person | Platform price requires a quote |
| Per-seat price | $6/person/month, plus base fee | Not published |
| Cost for five | $79/month on Simple | Platform cost not published |
| Setup effort | Setup time not published | Setup time not published |
| Learning curve | Review ease-of-use score: 7/10 | Review ease-of-use score: 6/10 |
| Small-team connections | Time tracking syncs with payroll | E-Verify case management |
| Support | Premium Account Support on Premium | Plan support details not published |
Gusto Choose Gusto if
- Choose Gusto if payroll and tax filings are the priority.
- Choose Gusto if you want a published price per person.
- Choose Gusto if you need payroll, benefits, or time tools.
WorkBright Choose WorkBright if
- Choose WorkBright if I-9 workflows are your main need.
- Choose WorkBright if your team needs automated E-Verify case management.
- Choose WorkBright if you want I-9 management priced per record.
02What each costs a small team
Neither product has a free plan. The Gusto pricing page lists Simple at $49 per month plus $6 per person, with month-to-month billing. That works out to $55 for one person, $67 for three, and $79 for five. The plan includes unlimited payrolls, tax filings and payments, basic PTO policies, and holiday pay.
WorkBright doesn’t publish a monthly or annual price for its compliance platform, so you’ll need a quote to budget for one person or a team of three to five. WorkBright+ is a separate service priced at $25 per I-9 record. If each person generates one billed record, that’s $25 for one, $75 for three, or $125 for five. Ask whether your quote includes WorkBright+ or platform access.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate, so we wouldn’t budget by assuming either is ready in a day. Gusto’s day-to-day work centers on payroll, tax filings, and—depending on the tools your team uses—time tracking, benefits, hiring, or contractor payments. Gusto says time tracking can sync hours with payroll. A small team will need to decide which of those workflows it actually wants to configure.
WorkBright’s focus is narrower: I-9 workflows, E-Verify cases, hiring forms, and employment records. Teams will need to set up forms and reminders for their roles, locations, or departments. Review scores rate ease of use at 7/10 for Gusto and 6/10 for WorkBright, but those scores don’t tell you how long your setup will take. Ask both vendors about onboarding steps and support for your chosen plan.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Gusto’s Simple plan is aimed at small teams running payroll in one state. Its listed inclusions are unlimited payrolls, tax filings and payments, basic PTO policies, and holiday pay. Gusto also offers hiring and onboarding, benefits, time tracking, contractor payments, and HR compliance tools, but the Simple plan listing doesn’t say those are all included. Check the plan details before counting them in your budget. Multi-state payroll and time tracking are listed under Plus, which starts at $80 per month plus $12 per person.
WorkBright’s compliance platform lists I-9 verification, automated E-Verify, and 150+ automated compliance checks. Its broader feature set includes hiring paperwork, forms, and notices. WorkBright+ adds I-9 and E-Verify case management for $25 per record, with automatic reverification deadline tracking and Supplement B for each reverification and rehire. The platform price isn’t published, so confirm which features and services your quote covers.
Questions people ask
Is WorkBright a legitimate company?
WorkBright presents itself as an HR compliance platform for I-9 verification, E-Verify, hiring paperwork, and employment records. Before signing, verify the contract terms, service scope, and data-handling details with the vendor. Ask for customer references from organizations with a workforce and compliance needs like yours.
What are the common complaints about Gusto?
Review feedback flags uneven support, and Gusto’s support score is 4/10 in the review summary. The platform covers payroll and HR needs, but small teams should confirm what support comes with their plan. Premium lists Premium Account Support; don’t assume that level is included with Simple.
How much does WorkBright cost?
WorkBright doesn’t publish a monthly or annual price for its compliance platform, so ask the vendor for a quote. WorkBright+ costs $25 per I-9 record. That per-record service price is not a published subscription price for the platform.
Which companies are known to use WorkBright?
For current, verified customer examples, ask WorkBright for references in your industry and at a similar workforce size. A reference can help you check how the I-9 workflows and E-Verify case management fit a team with needs like yours.