review galore

Head-to-head · Payroll tools

Heartland Payroll vs PrimePay

Heartland starts at $89/month for 1–5 employees; PrimePay Base starts at $55 plus $5 per employee.

Heartland Payroll

6.0/10
VS

PrimePay

6.0/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick PrimePay.

For a small team watching costs, PrimePay Base is the cheaper starting point: $60 monthly for one employee, or $70–$80 for three to five, with one state of tax filing. Heartland Payroll Essentials starts at $89 monthly for 1–5 employees. Choose Heartland if you want its broader payroll and HR toolset, but confirm what Essentials includes. Neither vendor offers a free plan, and both leave setup effort unclear, so ask about onboarding before signing.

01Side by side

Heartland PayrollPrimePay
Free planNo free planNo free plan
Cheapest paid planEssentials: starts at $89/monthBase: $55/month + $5/employee
Price per seatPer-seat rate not published$5/employee, plus $55 base
Cost for fiveStarts at $89/month for 1–5$80/month, with one state
Setup effortSetup time not publishedSetup time not published
Learning curveNot published; ask about onboardingNot published; ask about onboarding
Small-team integrationsSpecific integrations not publishedPre-built integrations on Custom
SupportPlan-specific support not publishedPhone and chat in Base

Choose Heartland Payroll if

  • Choose Heartland Payroll if you want payroll and HR tools together.
  • Choose Heartland Payroll if its Essentials quote fits your budget.
  • Choose Heartland Payroll if you need its listed hiring and time tools.

Choose PrimePay if

  • Choose PrimePay if lower starting costs matter most.
  • Choose PrimePay if phone and chat support in Base suit your team.
  • Choose PrimePay if you need one state of tax filing in Base.

02What each costs a small team

Neither vendor offers a free plan. Heartland Payroll Essentials starts at $89 per month for businesses with 1–5 employees. The pricing page does not list a separate one-person price, so one employee and a five-person team both start from that $89 figure; confirm the quote and included features with Heartland.

PrimePay Base costs $55 per month plus $5 per employee. That works out to $60 for one person, $70 for three, and $80 for five, assuming one state of tax filing. Base includes one state; additional states cost $7.50 each, up to four states. PrimePay lists Pro at $85 per month plus $6 per employee, but a small team may not need its extra time and HR features. Neither vendor lists annual billing prices.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a setup time or a step-by-step onboarding estimate. That makes it hard to know how much work a small team will need to handle before its first payroll. Before choosing, ask each vendor who helps with setup, what information you need to provide, and whether payroll migration or training costs extra.

The day-to-day tasks differ by plan and platform. Heartland describes payroll, tax administration, time and attendance, hiring, onboarding, HR resources, and employee self-service. Its Essentials listing does not spell out which of those tools are included, so get the plan contents in writing. PrimePay Base lists unlimited payroll runs, one state of tax filing, two-day direct deposit, and phone and chat support. Time and attendance and on-demand HR expert support are listed in Pro, not Base. Ask for a walkthrough of the tasks your team will handle most often.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

PrimePay Base gives a small team unlimited payroll runs, federal and single-state tax filing, two-day direct deposit, paycards, and phone and chat support. The $55 monthly base price also adds $5 per employee. Multi-state tax filing, time and attendance, and on-demand HR expert support are listed in Pro, which costs $85 per month plus $6 per employee. Additional states on Base cost $7.50 each, up to four states.

Heartland describes a wider set of platform tools: payroll, tax administration, time tracking, employee self-service, hiring and onboarding, and HR resources. But its Essentials plan lists only the 1–5 employee range and starting price; other inclusions are not published. Don't assume every listed platform feature is part of the $89 starting plan. Ask Heartland to confirm whether Essentials includes the specific tools you need, and get any add-on pricing, including Heartland Time, in writing.

Questions people ask

How much does Heartland charge for payroll?

Heartland Payroll Essentials starts at $89 per month for businesses with 1–5 employees. Advanced and Complete require custom pricing, and annual pricing is not published. Ask Heartland for a quote that spells out which features and services are included.

What happened to Heartland Payments?

Heartland Payroll is described as a payroll and HR platform. The available company details do not explain any changes to Heartland Payments or its relationship to Heartland Payroll. If you mean a specific payment product or account, check with the vendor directly.

Who are ADP's main payroll competitors?

This comparison covers Heartland Payroll and PrimePay, both payroll and HR platforms for businesses. It does not establish a full ranking of ADP competitors. Compare payroll pricing, tax filing, support, and the features included in the plan you would actually buy.

Is Heartland payment services legit?

The available details describe Heartland Payroll's services and pricing, but do not verify Heartland payment services or establish the status of a particular account. Confirm the exact product and company through official vendor channels before sharing financial or account information.