review galore

Review · Payroll tools

PrimePay review

A payroll-and-HR option for small teams that can pay a monthly base fee and want help beyond running payroll.

6.0/10Review Galore score

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

The bottom line

Useful payroll and HR coverage, but no free plan and limited setup detail make a sales conversation essential.

PrimePay, now CoAd Pay, combines payroll processing with tax filing and optional HR help. Its Base plan starts at $55 per month plus $5 per employee, with no free plan listed.

We’d consider it for a small business that wants payroll and support in one service. Before signing, get a firm quote for any added states, integrations, and services you need.

Good fit if

  • Small teams needing payroll
  • Businesses wanting HR help
  • Employers with multi-state payroll

Skip it if

  • Teams needing free payroll software
  • Buyers wanting published annual pricing
  • Businesses requiring known integration costs
PrimePay homepage
PrimePay homepage, captured Nov 6, 2026

ScoresHow it rates

  • Features7
  • Ease of use5
  • Value for money6
  • Support6
  • User sentiment4

What works

  • Base includes unlimited payroll runs
  • Federal and single-state tax filing included
  • Two-day direct deposit and paycards
  • Pro adds time and attendance
  • PEO includes benefits administration

What doesn't

  • No free plan is listed
  • No free trial is listed
  • Custom and PEO prices require a quote
  • Additional state charges can add up
  • A Reddit user reported serious support delays

01Who PrimePay is for

PrimePay is aimed at businesses that want payroll processing alongside tax filing and HR services. Its Base plan is for employers managing payroll themselves; Pro adds time and attendance and access to an HR expert. Businesses that want to outsource more HR work can ask about its Full Service PEO option, which lists benefits administration and a named HR advisor.

For a team of 1–10, the fit depends less on headcount than on the kind of help you need and your budget for a monthly base fee plus per-employee charges. Base starts at $55 per month plus $5 per employee, so the bill grows with every seat. A very small employer that only needs basic payroll may find that structure less attractive than a tool without a base fee. PrimePay is now CoAd Pay, so confirm the current product and contract name when requesting a quote.

02PrimePay free plan and trial

PrimePay does not list a free plan or a free trial. That means there is no no-cost way to run payroll in the product before committing, based on the listed pricing. Ask the vendor whether it offers a product walkthrough or another way to review the workflow before purchase; a trial is not published.

The cheapest listed option is DIY (Base), at $55 per month plus $5 per employee, billed monthly. It includes unlimited payroll runs, one state of tax filing, two-day direct deposit, and phone and chat support. Federal and single-state payroll tax filing are included in Base. If you need multi-state filing, time and attendance, or HR expert support, compare the Pro plan before deciding. Its listed price is $85 per month plus $6 per employee.

03What a small team pays for PrimePay

The pricing page lists Base at $55 per month plus $5 per employee and Pro at $85 per month plus $6 per employee. On Base, one person works out to $60 monthly, three people to $70, and five to $80. Pro comes to $91 for one person, $103 for three, and $115 for five. These totals use the listed monthly base fee and per-employee charge; the page does not list annual billing, so there is no published annual-price comparison.

Base includes one state of tax filing. The listed add-on for additional states is $7.50 each, up to four states. That can raise the bill for a small employer operating across state lines. The page also lists next-day direct deposit, W-2s, managed payroll, applicant tracking, and cyber insurance as add-ons without published prices. Custom and Full Service (PEO) require custom pricing, so ask for a written quote that covers the exact services and employee count you expect.

04Getting started with PrimePay

The setup effort and learning curve are not published, so we would ask PrimePay to walk through the onboarding steps before buying. In particular, confirm who enters employee and tax details, how prior payroll data is handled, and what support is available during the first pay run. Phone and chat support are listed in Base, while Pro includes HR expert support.

For day one, make a list of the payroll, timekeeping, benefits, and accounting systems your team already uses and ask which connections are included. Custom lists pre-built integrations, but the pricing page does not identify them or publish their costs. One Reddit discussion described a buyer struggling to connect PrimePay with ADP, including uncertainty around API access and fees. That is one user's account, not a guarantee of a current integration problem, but it is a good reason to get integration scope and pricing in writing.

05When small teams outgrow PrimePay

A growing team may need to move beyond Base when it adds states, wants time and attendance, or needs HR expert support. Pro adds multi-state payroll tax filing and time and attendance, but raises both the monthly base fee and the per-employee charge. Extra states are listed at $7.50 each, up to four states, so ask how the plan works if your footprint grows beyond that limit.

More complex needs may lead to Custom, which lists a dedicated account manager, pre-built integrations, and bespoke reporting, or Full Service PEO for outsourced payroll and benefits administration. Both require custom pricing. Reddit feedback is mixed: one commenter described PrimePay as accommodating, while another customer reported being unable to reach support during a payroll problem. A separate buyer also described uncertainty about an ADP connection. As headcount and payroll complexity rise, compare a written PrimePay quote against the service levels, integrations, and support terms your team requires.

From the threadsWhat users say

The Reddit comments are mixed and limited: some describe PrimePay as personable and accommodating, while one customer reports a frustrating payroll-support problem. We would treat those accounts as signals to check service expectations and integration terms, not as a complete picture of customer experience.

Personable service
They were a lot more personable in completing the RFP as well
r/humanresources · view thread
Small-business focus
They focus on small business market primarily mostly in the East Coast
r/humanresources · view thread
Integration uncertainty
that's what's holding us back right now-- it could be huge additional fees, we just don't know
r/humanresources · view thread
Support frustration
I have been trying to contact them for almost 7 hours
r/humanresources · view thread

Questions people ask

Did PrimePay change its name?

Yes. PrimePay is now CoAd Pay, described as a connected payroll and HR platform for businesses. If you are comparing older PrimePay references with a current offer, confirm the contracting entity, product name, and support contact with the vendor before signing.

Does PrimePay have a free plan or trial?

PrimePay does not list a free plan or a free trial. The least expensive listed option is DIY (Base), at $55 per month plus $5 per employee, billed monthly. Ask the vendor whether it offers a walkthrough or another way to review the product before you commit.

What does PrimePay Base include?

The listed Base plan includes unlimited payroll runs, one state of tax filing, two-day direct deposit, and phone and chat support. It costs $55 per month plus $5 per employee. Additional state filing is listed separately at $7.50 per state, up to four states.

Does PrimePay support multiple-state payroll?

Yes. Pro includes multi-state payroll tax filing. Base includes one state, and the listed add-on for additional states is $7.50 each, up to four states. Ask PrimePay to confirm how your required states affect the quote, especially if you expect to add locations.

How much does PrimePay cost for five employees?

Using the listed monthly prices, Base costs $80 per month for five employees: a $55 monthly fee plus $5 per employee. Pro costs $115 per month for five: $85 plus $6 per employee. These figures exclude add-ons, and annual billing is not listed.

Sources

  1. PrimePay homepage
  2. PrimePay pricing page
  3. Reddit: Anyone have experience with DATIS or PrimePay HRIS?