review galore

Head-to-head · HR software

Nowsta vs When I Work

When I Work is the lower-cost scheduling pick. Nowsta covers a broader hourly-workforce operation, but its entry price is a much bigger commitment.

Nowsta

6.0/10
VS

When I Work

6.2/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick When I Work.

For a small team that mainly needs scheduling and messaging, choose When I Work: Essentials is $2.50 per user monthly, with a 14-day trial. For five people, that is $12.50 monthly before any add-on. Choose Nowsta if you need a broader workforce platform for sourcing, onboarding, compliance, and payroll connections—and can justify a $1,500 annual starting price. Nowsta’s listed rates are flat annual prices, but confirm Basic’s seat allowance and included features before budgeting.

01Side by side

NowstaWhen I Work
Free planNo free plan; trial not listedNo free plan; 14-day trial
Cheapest paid planBasic: $1,500 annuallyEssentials: $2.50 per user monthly
Price per seatNot published; listed as flat annual pricing$2.50 monthly for Essentials
Cost for a team of 5$1,500 yearly, if Basic covers five$12.50 monthly for Essentials
Setup effortSetup time not publishedSetup time not published
Learning curveNot publishedNot published
Integrations a small team needsPayroll and accounting connectionsAPI access starts at Premium
SupportReview score: 5/10Review score: 4/10

Choose Nowsta if

  • Choose Nowsta if sourcing and onboarding workers are part of the job.
  • Choose Nowsta if you need compliance tools and payroll connections.
  • Choose Nowsta if a $1,500 annual starting price fits your budget.

Choose When I Work if

  • Choose When I Work if affordable scheduling is your main need.
  • Choose When I Work if you want a 14-day trial before paying.
  • Choose When I Work if per-user monthly pricing fits a small team.

02What each costs a small team

Neither product has a free plan. When I Work offers a 14-day trial; a free trial for Nowsta is not listed. Nowsta’s official pricing page does not publish rates, but directory listings show Basic at $1,500 per year, Advanced at $2,500, and Pro at $3,500. These are listed as flat annual prices, not per-seat rates. For one person or a team of three to five, Basic is the $1,500 yearly starting point only if its seat allowance fits; ask Nowsta to confirm that and the monthly billing price.

When I Work Essentials costs $2.50 per user monthly: $2.50 for one person, $7.50 for three, or $12.50 for five. Pro is $5 per user monthly. Annual rates are not published, and the Time Tracking & Attendance add-on has no published price, so check its cost if you need it.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate or a measured learning curve, so we can’t give a reliable number of hours or days. The configuration work will depend on your workflow and the features you plan to use.

With Nowsta, a small team may need to set up worker profiles, schedules, onboarding, compliance steps, and payroll or accounting connections. Confirm which of those are included in Basic before building a rollout plan; plan inclusions are not listed with the directory rates. When I Work’s Essentials plan lists schedule templates, multi-week and multi-location scheduling, auto scheduling, and team messaging. You’ll still need to configure schedules and decide how the team will use messages and open shifts. Its time-tracking add-on is priced separately, so check that cost and setup process if attendance tracking is part of your plan.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

When I Work spells out Essentials features: unlimited users, auto scheduling, multi-week and multi-location scheduling, schedule templates, and team messaging. The product also describes shift offers, reminders, time-off requests, and shift swaps. But Time Tracking & Attendance is a paid add-on with no published price, so don’t assume GPS clock-ins, break tracking, or attendance tools are included in Essentials. Pro adds scheduling rules, role permissions, custom reporting, and time-zone switching for $5 per user monthly.

Nowsta describes a wider workforce toolkit: scheduling, shift swaps and claims, time and attendance, sourcing, an applicant tracking system, onboarding, compliance, payroll connections, staff profiles, and labor insights. The directory listing does not say which features Basic includes. Ask Nowsta to confirm the exact Basic package, seat allowance, and whether payroll or accounting connections carry extra charges before comparing it with When I Work. Its broader feature set may suit more complex hourly operations, but the published starting price is substantially higher.

Questions people ask

How does Nowsta work?

Nowsta is a workforce platform for hourly and contingent teams. It brings together tools for sourcing and hiring, onboarding, scheduling, time and attendance, compliance, and payroll connections. The product also describes worker profiles and labor insights. Ask which of these are included in the Basic plan, since plan inclusions are not listed with its directory pricing.

Is the When I Work app free?

When I Work does not list a free plan. Its pricing lists a 14-day trial, then Essentials at $2.50 per user monthly. Time Tracking & Attendance is a separate add-on, and its price is not published. Check the add-on cost if you need clock-ins, attendance, or break tracking.

How much does Nowsta cost?

Nowsta’s official pricing page does not publish rates. Directory listings show Basic at $1,500 per year, Advanced at $2,500, and Pro at $3,500. Monthly prices are not published, and the rates are listed as flat annual amounts rather than per-user prices. Confirm seat limits and plan inclusions with Nowsta.

Which is better for a small hourly team?

When I Work is the easier budget fit if you mainly need schedules and team messaging: five Essentials seats cost $12.50 monthly. Nowsta is worth considering if sourcing, onboarding, compliance, and payroll connections matter enough to justify its $1,500 annual starting price. Check plan details before committing to either.