review galore

Head-to-head · Payroll tools

OnPay vs Paylocity

OnPay publishes simple per-worker payroll pricing; Paylocity offers broader modules but requires a custom quote.

OnPay

6.5/10
VS

Paylocity

5.2/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick OnPay.

For a small team watching its budget, OnPay is the clearer pick: payroll starts at $49 monthly plus $6 per worker, and its site lists phone, chat, and email support. A five-person team would pay $79 monthly for payroll. Paylocity may suit a team that wants HR, payroll, finance, and IT together, but its price is quote-based and seat limits aren’t published. Ask for a full quote before comparing it with OnPay.

01Side by side

OnPayPaylocity
Free planNo free plan; one-month free trialNo free plan; trial terms unpublished
Cheapest paid plan$49 monthly + $6 per workerCustom quote; price unpublished
Price per seat$6 per worker, plus $49 baseNot published
Five-person team cost$79 monthly for payrollNot published; request a quote
Setup effortFree data migration; setup time unpublishedSetup steps and timing unpublished
Learning curveEase-of-use review score: 7Ease-of-use review score: 5
Small-team integrationsAccounting, 401(k), HR, and compliance toolsSpecific integrations not published
SupportLive HR help by phone, chat, emailExpert support; channels not published

Choose OnPay if

  • Choose OnPay if you need payroll pricing you can calculate upfront.
  • Choose OnPay if free data migration would help your switch.
  • Choose OnPay if you want listed phone, chat, and email support.

Choose Paylocity if

  • Choose Paylocity if you want HR, payroll, finance, and IT together.
  • Choose Paylocity if you’re prepared to request a custom quote.
  • Choose Paylocity if its broader module mix fits your organization.

02What each costs a small team

Neither vendor lists a free plan. OnPay offers a one-month free trial; Paylocity’s trial terms aren’t published. The OnPay pricing page lists Payroll Essentials at $49 per month plus $6 per worker, with monthly pricing and no annual rate listed.

For one worker, that comes to $55 monthly. Three workers cost $67; five cost $79. The per-worker charge is $6, though the base fee means the effective price per person is higher for a tiny team. Paylocity uses custom pricing, and the vendor doesn’t publish a starting price, seat limits, or overage costs. Ask for a written quote for your headcount and selected modules before comparing totals. OnPay’s listed HR and time-tracking add-ons cost extra.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a time-to-launch estimate, so don’t budget around an assumed setup timeline. OnPay says it provides free data migration for businesses switching providers. You’ll still need to organize the payroll details and pay schedules your team uses, then decide whether to add HR, benefits, or time tracking.

Paylocity’s platform spans HR, payroll, talent, and finance modules. Ask which modules your quote includes and what setup each requires; the vendor doesn’t publish setup steps or timing. For day-to-day use, OnPay lists payroll automation, employee onboarding, benefits administration, and mobile clock-ins as capabilities. Paylocity describes a mobile app and analytics alongside its broader platform. Review scores give OnPay a 7 for ease of use and Paylocity a 5, which favors OnPay for teams concerned about learning the system.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

OnPay’s listed Payroll Essentials plan covers unlimited pay runs and schedules, W-2s and 1099s, year-end filings, and federal, state, and local tax filings. It also lists payroll for any number of states. Those are the core payroll features a small team can price before adding other services.

HR and time tracking cost extra: the pricing page lists HR at $15 plus $2 per worker monthly, and HR plus time tracking at $21 plus $4 per worker. The bundled HR option is $71 plus $1 per worker. Benefits administration is listed as a free integration, but plan premiums cost extra.

Paylocity describes HR, payroll, talent, and finance modules, plus IT tools, a mobile app, and analytics. Its price and included limits depend on a custom quote; confirm which features are in your package rather than assuming every capability comes with the base price.

Questions people ask

Is OnPay cheaper than Paylocity?

OnPay is easier to price from the published figures: payroll is $49 monthly plus $6 per worker. That is $79 for five workers. Paylocity’s pricing is quote-based, and the vendor doesn’t publish a starting price, so get a quote for the same team size and modules before deciding.

Do OnPay or Paylocity have a free plan?

Neither vendor lists a free plan. OnPay lists a one-month free trial. Paylocity’s trial availability and terms aren’t published, so ask the vendor directly if you want to evaluate it before buying.

What does OnPay cost for five workers?

The OnPay pricing page lists payroll at $49 per month plus $6 per worker. For five workers, that totals $79 monthly, before optional add-ons or benefit premiums. The page lists monthly pricing and doesn’t publish an annual rate.

When should a small team choose Paylocity?

Paylocity may fit a team that wants HR, payroll, finance, and IT tools in one platform. Its pricing is custom, however, and seat limits and add-on costs aren’t published. Ask for a quote that spells out modules, included users, and any extra charges.