review galore

Head-to-head · ITSM software

Opsgenie vs PagerDuty

Opsgenie costs less for basic alerting; PagerDuty’s free plan covers a basic on-call setup. Plan around Opsgenie’s Jira Service Management migration.

Opsgenie

5.8/10
VS

PagerDuty

7.0/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick Opsgenie.

For a budget-conscious team that needs basic alerting, Opsgenie is the lower-cost pick: its free plan allows five users and unlimited alerts, and Essentials starts at $9.45 per user monthly with annual billing. But Atlassian is migrating Opsgenie to Jira Service Management, so factor that change into your decision. PagerDuty suits teams that want a free, defined on-call setup—five users, one schedule and one escalation policy—and are prepared to pay more for Professional as needs grow.

01Side by side

OpsgeniePagerDuty
Free planFive users, unlimited alerts; one routing ruleFive users, one schedule, one escalation policy
Cheapest paid planEssentials: $9.45/user monthly, billed annuallyProfessional: $21/user monthly, billed annually
Price per seat$9.45 annual billing; $11.55 monthly billing$21 annual billing; $25 monthly billing
Cost for a team of 5$47.25/month annual billing; $57.75 month-to-month$105/month annual billing; $125 month-to-month
Setup effortMigration office hours include demos and live questionsSetup-time estimate not published
Learning curveNot published; migration to Jira Service Management aheadNot published
Small-team integrationsVendor does not publish a small-team integration listVendor does not publish a small-team integration list
SupportMonthly migration office hours with live questionsSupport details not published in plan listing

Choose Opsgenie if

  • Choose Opsgenie if free alerting for up to five people is enough.
  • Choose Opsgenie if a lower per-user paid plan fits your budget.
  • Choose Opsgenie if you can plan for the Jira Service Management migration.

Choose PagerDuty if

  • Choose PagerDuty if you need a free on-call schedule and escalation policy.
  • Choose PagerDuty if incident response features justify higher per-user costs.
  • Choose PagerDuty if its platform plans fit your growth plans and budget.

02What each costs a small team

Both have free plans for up to five users. Opsgenie Free includes unlimited alerts, 100 SMS notifications account-wide and one routing rule. PagerDuty Free includes one on-call schedule, one escalation policy and 100 SMS or phone notifications per month.

For one person, Opsgenie Essentials costs $9.45 monthly with annual billing or $11.55 month-to-month. PagerDuty Professional costs $21 or $25 per user, respectively. At three seats, that works out to $28.35 or $34.65 for Opsgenie, versus $63 or $75 for PagerDuty. At five seats, it is $47.25 or $57.75 versus $105 or $125. PagerDuty’s Starter is another option at a $2,800 annual platform fee, with five seats plus five bonus seats. The listed prices make Essentials the lower-cost paid choice for a small team.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a standard setup-time estimate. Opsgenie’s homepage centers on migration to Jira Service Management; Atlassian says the migration can happen with no downtime. It also offers monthly office hours with migration demos and live questions. For an Opsgenie team, that migration is an extra planning item, not just an alerting setup.

Before choosing either product, a small team should work out who receives alerts and how on-call coverage and escalation should work. Opsgenie’s plans list routing rules; PagerDuty’s free plan includes a schedule and escalation policy. Those are concrete items to compare, but neither vendor publishes a learning-curve estimate. Ask each vendor what setup help is included for your plan, and ask Atlassian how the migration affects your particular configuration.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Opsgenie Free is generous on alert volume: it includes unlimited alerts for up to five users, but only one routing rule, 100 SMS notifications account-wide and three months of data retention. Essentials adds 100 incidents per month account-wide, up to five postmortems monthly and six months of retention. It still has one routing rule maximum; extra SMS or voice notifications cost extra.

PagerDuty Free is more specifically an on-call starter: five users, one schedule, one escalation policy and 100 SMS or phone notifications monthly. Professional adds an enhanced chat experience and post-incident reviews, with up to five users per escalation level. PagerDuty lists AIOps, PagerDuty Advance, Runbook Automation, Status Pages and Live Call Routing as separate add-ons for Professional. Its Starter platform plan costs $2,800 annually and lists Signal Intelligence Events, AI Actions and ten seats including bonus seats. Compare the included capacity you will actually use before paying for those broader plans.

Questions people ask

Is Opsgenie cheaper than PagerDuty?

Yes, at the listed per-user paid prices. Opsgenie Essentials is $9.45 per user monthly with annual billing, compared with PagerDuty Professional at $21. Both offer a free plan for up to five users, but their included alerting and on-call limits differ.

What does PagerDuty cost for five people?

PagerDuty Professional works out to $105 monthly for five users with annual billing, or $125 month-to-month, based on its listed per-user rates. Its free plan also covers five users, but limits the team to one on-call schedule and one escalation policy.

Is Opsgenie being migrated to Jira Service Management?

Yes. Opsgenie’s homepage focuses on migration to Jira Service Management. Atlassian says the migration can happen with no downtime and offers monthly office hours with demos and live questions. Teams should ask how the migration applies to their own setup.

Which tool is better for a small team?

Opsgenie is the stronger budget pick for basic alerting, with a free plan for five users and a lower-priced paid tier. PagerDuty is a better fit if its included on-call schedule, escalation policy and incident-response options matter more than the higher Professional price.