review galore

Head-to-head · Observability tools

PagerDuty vs xMatters

Compare free plans, five-seat costs, setup needs, and incident-response features before choosing.

PagerDuty

7.0/10
VS

xMatters

6.0/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick PagerDuty.

For a small team watching every subscription, PagerDuty is the safer pick: its free plan lists five users, and its Professional plan has published per-user pricing. A five-person team pays $105 per month with annual billing or $125 month to month. xMatters offers incident management and no-code workflows, but its free-plan limits and paid prices aren't published. Choose xMatters if those workflows suit your needs and you can get a clear quote first.

01Side by side

PagerDutyxMatters
Free planFive users, one schedule, one policy, 100 notificationsFree plan listed; limits not published
Cheapest paid planProfessional: $21 annual-billing rate per user monthlyStarter listed; price not published
Price per seat$21 monthly with annual billing; $25 month to monthNot published; paid SMS and voice billed per user
Cost for a team of 5$105 monthly annual-billing rate; $125 month to monthNot published; ask for a five-user quote
Setup effortTime not published; configure schedules and escalation policiesTime not published; configure workflows and on-call
Learning curveEase-of-use review score: 6/10Ease-of-use review score: 6/10
Small-team integrationsConfirm monitoring, chat, and ticketing connectorsConfirm monitoring, chat, and ticketing connectors
SupportSupport review score: 5/10Support review score: 5/10

Choose PagerDuty if

  • Choose PagerDuty if you need a usable free on-call setup.
  • Choose PagerDuty if you want a clear per-user price.
  • Choose PagerDuty if five users fit its free-plan limits.

Choose xMatters if

  • Choose xMatters if no-code response workflows are central.
  • Choose xMatters if AI-guided response fits your incident process.
  • Choose xMatters if the vendor gives you acceptable limits and pricing.

02What each costs a small team

PagerDuty's free plan lists five users, one on-call schedule, one escalation policy, and 100 SMS or phone notifications a month. Its Professional plan costs $25 per user monthly, or $21 per user monthly with annual billing. One person costs $21 or $25 a month; three people cost $63 or $75; five cost $105 or $125. PagerDuty also lists Starter at a $2,800 annual platform fee, with five seats plus five bonus seats, so compare it carefully with Professional for a small team.

xMatters lists Free, Starter, Base, and Advanced plans, but the vendor doesn't publish their prices or free-plan limits. Paid SMS and phone notifications are billed per full user per month, with prices also unpublished. Ask for a quote covering your team size and notification use before comparing totals.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a time-to-setup estimate, so plan around the work your team needs to configure rather than a promised number of hours. PagerDuty's free plan includes an on-call schedule and escalation policy; a team still needs to decide who responds, how alerts escalate, and which incidents trigger a page. xMatters offers on-call management and no-code workflows, so map out the people, alert context, and actions those workflows should handle.

For either product, confirm that it connects to your monitoring, chat, and ticketing tools before committing. Both reviews score ease of use 6/10, so the available ratings don't break a tie. Ask each vendor for a walkthrough of your team's routine incident, plus a clear list of what requires configuration or a paid tier.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

PagerDuty's free tier covers a basic on-call setup: five users, one schedule, one escalation policy, and 100 monthly SMS or phone notifications. Professional adds an enhanced chat experience and post-incident reviews, and supports up to five users per escalation level. The pricing page lists AIOps, PagerDuty Advance, Runbook Automation, Status Pages, and Live Call Routing as separate add-ons for Professional, so don't assume those capabilities are included in the per-user price.

xMatters describes AI-guided incident response, signal enrichment, on-call management, and no-code workflows. Its product also supports actionable alerts and post-incident analytics. But the vendor doesn't publish which of those features are in each plan, or the limits on Free. Paid SMS and voice notifications carry an extra per-user charge, with the price unpublished. Ask for a plan-by-plan feature list before choosing based on those capabilities.

Questions people ask

Does PagerDuty have a free plan for a small team?

Yes. PagerDuty lists a free plan for five users with one on-call schedule, one escalation policy, and 100 SMS or phone notifications per month. That can cover a basic on-call setup, but check whether the notification allowance and single schedule fit your team's response needs.

What is PagerDuty's cheapest paid plan?

PagerDuty Professional is listed at $25 per user per month, or $21 per user per month with annual billing. A five-person team therefore pays $125 month to month or $105 per month at the annual-billing rate. PagerDuty also lists a Starter platform fee of $2,800 per year.

How much does xMatters cost for five users?

The vendor doesn't publish enough pricing to calculate a five-user total. It lists Free, Starter, Base, and Advanced plans, and says paid SMS and phone notifications are billed per full user per month, but doesn't state those prices. Ask for a quote that includes seats and notification charges.

Which is better for incident-response automation?

Both describe incident-response automation. PagerDuty lists operations automation and AI-assisted triage, while xMatters highlights no-code workflows that can communicate, escalate, and launch remediation actions. Compare the specific workflows and plan limits you need with each vendor; xMatters doesn't publish feature availability by tier.