We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Pick Paychex if your small team needs payroll tax filing, year-end forms, HR guidance, or benefits alongside time and attendance. Pick Toggl Track if the problem is tracking project hours and reporting without buying a payroll suite: its free plan covers individual tracking, and Starter adds team reports from $9 per seat monthly with annual billing. Paychex may fit better as an HR and payroll system, but its quote-only pricing makes a five-person budget harder to check.
01Side by side
| Paychex | Toggl Track | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan listed | Free individual time tracking |
| Cheapest paid plan | Basic; quote required | Starter, from $9 per user monthly |
| Price per seat | Not published; request a quote | $9 annual billing; $12 monthly |
| Cost for a team of 5 | Not published; request a quote | $45 annual billing; $60 monthly |
| Setup effort | Ask what payroll onboarding includes | Starter setup time not listed |
| Learning curve | Payroll and HR workflows | Timers, tasks, and reports |
| Small-team integrations | Ask which integrations your quote includes | Google and Outlook calendars on Free |
| Support | More than 7,600 support and HR professionals | Dedicated customer success on Enterprise |
Paychex Choose Paychex if
- Choose Paychex if payroll tax filing and year-end forms matter.
- Choose Paychex if HR guidance and benefits belong in one platform.
- Choose Paychex if you want time and attendance alongside payroll.
Toggl Track Choose Toggl Track if
- Choose Toggl Track if you need project time tracking, not payroll.
- Choose Toggl Track if a free individual plan is enough to start.
- Choose Toggl Track if you want published per-seat team pricing.
02What each costs a small team
Paychex has no free plan; its pricing page lists quote-based Basic, Foundations, Advanced, Complete, HR Pro, and HR PEO options, with no monthly or annual rates. For one person or five, we can’t calculate a Paychex total from published pricing. Ask for a quote that spells out base fees, per-employee charges, payroll frequency, and any time-and-attendance add-on; that add-on’s price is not published.
Toggl Track’s Free plan costs $0 and is described for individuals. Teams looking for paid team features start at Starter: $9 per user/month billed annually or $12 billed monthly. That makes one seat $9 or $12 monthly, and five seats $45 or $60 monthly, before any add-ons. Capacity Management adds $5 per user/month annually or $6 monthly; Time Off Management is $2 per user/month, with no separate annual price listed.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Paychex combines payroll, HR, compliance, benefits, and advisory support, so setup may involve choices about payroll, tax filing, employee pay options, and which HR services to include. The vendor does not publish a standard setup timeline in its pricing details; ask what onboarding covers and whether it costs extra. Its homepage lists more than 7,600 customer support and HR professionals.
Toggl’s Free plan includes manual and real-time timers, tasks, boards, task estimates, and Google and Outlook calendar integrations. A team adopting Starter also needs to set up billable rates, tags, milestones, and team reports if those features matter. The pricing page does not state a setup time for Starter. We’d decide who owns tags and estimates before inviting the team. Personalized onboarding is listed for Enterprise, not Starter.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Paychex’s Basic plan includes unlimited payroll processing, employee pay options, W-2 and 1099 year-end processing, and payroll tax filing. Paychex also offers time-and-attendance tools, but Time & Attendance is listed as an add-on with no published price. Ask whether it is included in your quote and how it works with payroll. HR Pro and HR PEO are separate options for businesses seeking HR guidance or outsourced HR and benefits.
Toggl Track Free covers individual timers, tasks, boards, estimates, calendar integrations, and personal-level reports. Starter adds billable rates, team productivity and revenue reports, timelines, tags, milestones, PTO, public holidays, flexible hours, and team reports. That’s a usable starting point for project-hour tracking, but labor-cost and profitability reports, timesheet approvals, and Jira and Asana integrations are listed under Premium. Capacity Management is a paid add-on.
Questions people ask
Does Paychex Flex track your location?
Paychex lists time-and-attendance tools to track work hours, but location tracking is not specified in the listed features. Ask Paychex whether a specific Flex package supports location tracking, what settings control it, and whether it carries an additional charge.
What is the best system for employee time tracking?
It depends on what you need time data to do. Toggl Track focuses on timers, project reports, and comparing estimated with actual time. Paychex offers time-and-attendance tools as part of a broader payroll and HR platform. Check whether the tool fits your team’s payroll workflow and budget.
Is Toggl Track free?
Yes. Toggl Track lists a free-forever plan with manual and real-time timers, tasks, boards, estimates, Google and Outlook calendar integrations, and personal-level reports. The plan is described for individuals; teams wanting Starter features pay $9 per user monthly with annual billing or $12 with monthly billing.
Which is better, Toggl Track or Clockify?
The better choice depends on current team limits, reporting needs, integrations, and per-seat cost. Toggl Track lists a free individual plan and paid team plans from $9 per user monthly with annual billing. Compare those details with Clockify’s current plans before choosing; we can’t name a winner on price alone.