We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
A small team that mainly wants to publish writing and build a mailing list should start with Substack: its platform costs $0 monthly, and the free plan includes unlimited subscribers, posts, and sending. Pick Podbean for podcast hosting, recording, analytics, and monetization tools. Its audio plan starts at $12 per month with annual billing, but a team needing listed member access would look at Network, at $79 per month billed annually. Substack costs more if you charge subscribers.
01Side by side
| Podbean | Substack | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Free plan exists; limits not published | Unlimited subscribers, posts, sends, newsletters, podcasts, video |
| Cheapest paid plan | $12/mo annually; audio-only | $0 monthly platform fee |
| Price per seat | $15.80 each for five on annual Network | $0 platform fee; seat costs not published |
| Cost for a team of 5 | $79/mo annually for Network | $0 platform fee; seat costs not published |
| Setup effort | Podcast hosting and publishing to configure | Publishing and mailing list to configure |
| Learning curve | Ease-of-use review score: 6 | Ease-of-use review score: 8 |
| Integrations a small team needs | Apple Podcasts Subscriptions integration | Stripe card processing for paid subscriptions |
| Support | Support review score: 5 | Support review score: 5.5 |
Podbean Choose Podbean if
- Choose Podbean if podcast hosting is the main job.
- Choose Podbean if you need recording and audio tools.
- Choose Podbean if you want listed team access for a podcast network.
Substack Choose Substack if
- Choose Substack if you want free publishing and a mailing list.
- Choose Substack if you plan to earn from paid subscriptions.
- Choose Substack if you publish writing, podcasts, or video without a monthly platform fee.
02What each costs a small team
Substack costs $0 monthly for its platform. Its free plan lists unlimited subscribers, posts, and sending, plus free newsletters, podcasts, and video. A custom domain is $50 one time. If you charge subscribers, Substack takes 10% of subscription revenue; Stripe processing fees also apply.
Podbean’s cheapest listed paid plan, Unlimited Audio, is $12 per month with annual billing or $17 month to month. It includes one audio podcast. For one person, that is the clearest starting price. For a team of three to five needing listed member access, Network is $79 monthly with annual billing or $99 month to month and includes 50 team members. That works out to $15.80 per person for five on annual billing. Substack lists no seat costs, so confirm team access before relying on it. Podbean’s free-plan limits are not published.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a time-to-setup estimate, so we would not plan around a promised same-day launch. Podbean’s scope includes hosting, recording, publishing, promotion, analytics, and monetization. A small team should decide who owns the show and publishing tasks, and check which plan fits its audio, video, and team needs. The listed Unlimited Audio plan is audio-only; Network lists team members and multiple-show capacity.
Substack’s core work is publishing, building a mailing list, and optionally setting up paid subscriptions. That narrower scope suggests less podcast-specific configuration, though it still takes work to prepare content and decide whether to charge. The review scores favor Substack for ease of use (8 versus 6 for Podbean). Treat that as a directional comparison, not a setup-time guarantee. Ask Podbean which free-plan limits apply before committing.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Substack’s free platform covers unlimited subscribers, posts, and sending, as well as newsletters, podcasts, and video. It also lists mailing-list and intellectual-property ownership, editorial control, and reader discussions. That is a broad starting point for a small publication, but earning through paid subscriptions brings a 10% platform share plus Stripe processing fees.
Podbean lists a free plan, but the plan’s limits are not published. Its lowest-priced paid tier, Unlimited Audio, includes an audio-only podcast, 1GB of monthly uploads, unlimited storage, unmetered bandwidth, and 600 AI credits monthly. Podbean’s platform features include recording, editing, analytics, AI content tools, and monetization options; the pricing lists do not clarify every feature’s tier availability, so check before buying. Video publishing starts on Unlimited Plus, listed at $29 monthly with annual billing. Teams needing listed access can consider Network, which includes 50 team members.
Questions people ask
Why is everyone leaving Substack?
We would not assume everyone is leaving. Substack offers free publishing, an owned mailing list, and paid subscriptions, but it takes 10% of subscription revenue and Stripe processing fees also apply. A publisher weighing alternatives should compare those costs and features against the control and audience model they need.
Is there a better option than Substack?
It depends on the work. Podbean is a better fit when podcast hosting, recording, analytics, and monetization tools are the priority. Substack is a strong fit for free publishing and mailing-list growth. Compare the costs too: Podbean’s audio plan starts at $12 monthly with annual billing, while Substack charges a share when you earn from subscriptions.
Is Podbean trustworthy?
Podbean lists IAB-certified analytics and podcast monetization tools. Its Enterprise plan lists SOC 2 certified security, but that is a high-tier offer, not a claim about every plan. We’d check the security and support terms for the plan you need, especially if you handle private podcasts or sensitive business content.
Is Substack still relevant in 2026?
For publishers who want newsletters, podcasts, video, discussions, and paid subscriptions in one platform, Substack remains relevant. Its free plan lists unlimited subscribers, posts, and sending. The trade-off is its 10% share of subscription revenue plus Stripe processing fees, so compare the fee structure with your expected income.