review galore

Head-to-head · Accounting Software

Sage Accounting vs SurePayroll

Pick Sage for accounting and business management; choose SurePayroll for payroll runs and tax filing.

Sage Accounting

6.3/10
VS

SurePayroll

7.0/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

It's a split decision.

A small team that needs bookkeeping and wider finance tools should choose Sage Accounting: its plans start at $20 monthly for one user, with a $50 unlimited-user plan. Choose SurePayroll if payroll is the job to solve. Its No Tax Filing plan starts at $20 plus $4 per employee monthly; Full Service starts at $29 plus $7 per employee, though alternate base prices are also listed. Neither product has a free plan, and they are not substitutes for each other.

01Side by side

Sage AccountingSurePayroll
Free planNo free plan; 30-day free trialNo free plan; no free trial listed
Cheapest paid planAccounting Start: $20 monthlyNo Tax Filing: $20 monthly base
Price per seatStart includes one user; $4 per extra user on Standard$4 or $7 per employee, plus base price
Team of fivePlus: $50 monthly, unlimited usersFull Service: $64–$74 monthly
Setup effortSetup time not publishedSetup time not published
Learning curveMore business-management areas to configurePayroll-focused scope
Small-team integrationsTime tracking and other add-ons listedAccounting software integration: $4.99 monthly
SupportSupport details not published with these pricesCustomer support included on No Tax Filing

Choose Sage Accounting if

  • Choose Sage Accounting if you need accounting tools, not payroll alone.
  • Choose Sage Accounting if one user can start at $20 monthly.
  • Choose Sage Accounting if five users need an unlimited-user plan.

Choose SurePayroll if

  • Choose SurePayroll if payroll is your main need.
  • Choose SurePayroll if you want taxes filed and deposited.
  • Choose SurePayroll if you pay W-2 employees or 1099 contractors.

02What each costs a small team

Neither product has a free plan. Sage lists a 30-day free trial; SurePayroll lists no trial. Sage Accounting Start costs $20 monthly for one user. Standard is $40 with two users included, and extra users are listed at $4 monthly. That makes three users $44; for five, Plus at $50 with unlimited users is the lower listed option.

SurePayroll’s No Tax Filing plan starts at $20 monthly plus $4 per employee. For five employees, that is $40 before any applicable fees. Full Service starts at $29 plus $7 per employee, or $64 for five. SurePayroll also lists alternate base prices of $29 and $39, respectively, making those five-person totals $49 and $74. Confirm the current base price before budgeting.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a setup time, so we would not budget by assuming either is ready in a set number of hours. Ask each vendor what onboarding, data entry, and support are included for your plan.

The day-to-day work differs. Sage’s described scope includes finance, purchasing, inventory, orders, and production, so a team using those areas will have more business processes to configure than a team using it only for basic accounting. SurePayroll centers on payroll: choose whether to handle tax filing yourself or pay for Full Service, then set up payroll scheduling and employee records. The pricing details list W-2 employees and 1099 contractors for Full Service. Sage’s broader scope may take more learning; SurePayroll’s narrower payroll focus may be easier to map to a small payroll routine.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Sage Accounting Start includes one user and unlimited sales invoices. Its wider product description covers financial management, purchasing, inventory, orders, customer service, and production, but the pricing details do not specify which of those capabilities are included in Start. Standard includes two users and can be configured for two to five; Plus includes unlimited users. Sage also lists paid add-ons such as inventory, multi-currency, and time tracking.

SurePayroll’s cheaper No Tax Filing plan includes unlimited payroll runs and customer support, but the employer handles tax filing and deposits. Full Service adds calculation, filing, and depositing of federal, state, and local payroll taxes, plus free two-day direct deposit. Both plans support W-2 employees and 1099 contractors per the listed Full Service details. SurePayroll also offers online reports, paystubs, and payroll history, and lists accounting software integration for $4.99 monthly. It is payroll software, not a replacement for Sage’s accounting scope.

Questions people ask

How much does Sage cost per month?

Sage Accounting Start is listed at $20 monthly for one user. Standard is $40 with two users included, and Plus is $50 with unlimited users. Monthly prices are listed; annual-billing prices are not published. Sage lists a 30-day free trial.

Is SurePayroll legit?

SurePayroll is online payroll software for small businesses and household employers. Its listed features include payroll runs, tax filing on Full Service, direct deposit, and online payroll records. Check that the plan, current price, and tax-filing coverage fit your business before signing up.

What is the contact number for Sage payroll support?

Sage’s pricing details do not list a payroll support number. Ask Sage for the right contact for your country and product; the Sage Accounting plan prices here do not establish which payroll support team applies.

Is Sage bigger than SAP?

That depends on what you mean by “bigger,” such as revenue, employees, or customers. Compare Sage’s and SAP’s latest published figures using the same measure and reporting period; product pricing alone cannot answer the company-size question.