We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick Square.
For a small team watching every subscription, Square is the easier place to start: its Free plan costs $0 per month and covers core selling tools. Shift4 makes more sense for a table-service restaurant that wants its listed $29.99 monthly bundle and is prepared to price processing and extra devices. Square’s paid-plan prices are not published, and Shift4’s total depends on add-ons and payment volume, so get a full quote before you commit.
01Side by side
| Shift4 | Square | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan listed | Square Free costs $0 monthly |
| Cheapest listed plan | $29.99 monthly for table service | $0 monthly for Square Free |
| Price per seat | Not published | Not published |
| Cost for five people | Base $29.99; device costs extra | $0 plan fee; processing applies |
| Setup effort | Setup time not published | Setup time not published |
| Learning curve | Review ease score: 4/10 | Review ease score: 7/10 |
| Integrations | Third-party marketplace pricing not published | Connects with hundreds of apps |
| Support | Support details not published | Premium lists 24/7 priority phone support |
Shift4 Choose Shift4 if
- Choose Shift4 if you run a table-service restaurant.
- Choose Shift4 if you want its restaurant bundle and device options.
- Choose Shift4 if you will request a full processing and add-on quote.
Square Choose Square if
- Choose Square if you want a $0 monthly starting plan.
- Choose Square if you need an online site and core selling tools.
- Choose Square if app connections and clear entry pricing matter.
02What each costs a small team
Square Free is $0 per month and includes core selling tools. For one person or five, the listed plan fee stays $0; payment processing still affects the bill, and the pricing page does not give a processing rate here. Square Plus and Premium rates are not published, while Pro uses custom pricing.
Shift4 lists its Dine Table-Service Bundle at $29.99 per month. That is the listed base for a one-person operation or a five-person team; pricing per seat is not published. Standard card processing is listed at 2.75% plus $0.15 per transaction. Handhelds, tablets, kiosks, customer-facing displays and kitchen display systems are each listed at $29.99 per month, so ask which devices your team needs. Annual pricing is not published. Square is cheaper to start; neither vendor gives a complete five-person total without transaction volume and hardware choices.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate, so we would not plan around a promised same-day launch. Before choosing, map the jobs your team needs the system to handle: taking payments, keeping an item library, managing staff, and selling online or at the counter.
Square Free lists a POS app, online site, item library, invoicing and booking. A small team will need to decide how to organize its items and who handles day-to-day tasks; setup time is not published. Shift4’s listed restaurant bundle comes with options such as a website builder, reservations and waitlist, marketing and loyalty, and QR codes advertised from $0. Extra hardware is priced separately. Review scores give Square the edge on ease of use, but they do not replace a walkthrough. Ask each vendor about importing existing data, staff training, and what support is included at your chosen price.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Square Free covers the basics a small seller may need before paying for a higher tier: a POS app for payments, an online site, an item library, invoicing and booking, plus checking and savings accounts. Square also lists connections with hundreds of apps. Its paid Plus plan adds advanced POS features, lower processing fees, loyalty rewards, email campaigns, some free texts, and staff scheduling; the monthly price is not published.
Shift4’s $29.99 monthly Dine Table-Service Bundle is aimed at table-service restaurants. The listed package includes marketing and loyalty, reservations and waitlist, QR code tools, and a website builder, each advertised from $0. Shift4 also offers POS, mobile and contactless payments, online payments, and venue commerce. Handhelds, tablets, kiosks, customer-facing displays, and kitchen display systems are separately listed at $29.99 per month each. If your team needs those devices, the base bundle is not the whole budget.
Questions people ask
Is Shift4 or Square cheaper for a small team?
Square is cheaper to start: its Free plan is listed at $0 per month. Shift4 lists a $29.99 monthly table-service bundle, plus processing and optional device costs. Square processing fees and paid-plan prices should be confirmed with the vendor before comparing full monthly totals.
Does Shift4 have a free plan?
Shift4 does not list a free plan in the pricing details here. Its Dine Table-Service Bundle is listed at $29.99 per month. Some included tools, such as marketing and loyalty, are advertised from $0, but that does not make the bundle itself free.
How much does Square cost for five staff?
Square Free has a $0 monthly plan fee, whether you have one person or five. A full operating cost is not available from the plan price alone: processing applies, and Square does not publish Plus or Premium monthly rates. Ask Square how your staff needs affect the quote.
Which is better for a restaurant?
Shift4 is worth considering for table-service restaurants: it lists a restaurant bundle with reservations, waitlist, QR code, and website tools. Square Free offers core POS and selling tools, while Square Plus adds restaurant-relevant advanced POS features and loyalty. Compare the total with hardware and processing included.