review galore

Simpler and cheaper options · 7 options

Square alternatives

Free plans and low starting prices can help, but payment fees, hardware and fit still matter.

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

A small team may not need to leave Square: its free plan covers core selling tools. But paid features, processing and hardware add-ons can change the bill, and some sellers want a different payment setup. We’ve picked seven alternatives for specific needs, from online checkout to group collections and crypto payments. Compare the free plan, starting price and any hardware or processing costs, then ask each vendor what setup and pricing look like for your team.

01Why people leave Square

Add-on costs can add up

Square’s free plan covers core selling tools, but budget for paid features, processing and hardware add-ons.

Account access feels risky

One Reddit seller reported a sudden account closure and delayed access to funds; commenters also described long waits for human support.

Your payment needs differ

A team focused on donations, installments or crypto checkout may prefer a tool built around that specific payment use.

02The alternatives, ranked by fit

  1. Online checkout

    PayPal

    PayPal fits a small shop that mainly needs online checkout or PayPal and Venmo payments. A free plan is listed, with plans from $5. A per-seat total isn’t published, and payment fees can vary. Before switching, ask what setup your existing checkout needs and which fees apply to your transactions.

    Trade-off: Fees vary, and users report account problems.

    6.8/10
    from
    $5/mo
    free plan
  2. Retail and restaurants

    Clover

    Clover is a closer match if your team needs POS coverage for a retail shop, restaurant or service business. A free plan is listed, with plans from $29.95. The cost for a few seats isn’t published. Ask for the full device, processing and hardware costs, plus what setup each device requires.

    Trade-off: Device, processing and hardware costs need checking.

    6.8/10
    from
    $29.95/mo
    free plan
  3. Group collections

    Cheddar Up

    Cheddar Up is aimed at volunteer groups, clubs and teams collecting dues or running fundraisers and events. It pairs payments with forms, and a free plan is listed; plans start from $15. Per-seat pricing and setup effort aren’t published. Check transaction fees and ask what your group needs to configure before sending a payment link.

    Trade-off: Check transaction fees before collecting payments.

    6.5/10
    from
    $15/mo
    free plan
  4. Churches and nonprofits

    Vanco

    Vanco suits churches starting online giving, nonprofits taking recurring donations and teams that also need in-person payments. A $0 starting plan is listed, with plans from $54. A total for a few seats isn’t published. Ask which processing fees and extras apply, and what setup is needed for recurring and in-person payments.

    Trade-off: Processing fees and extras shape the real cost.

    6.8/10
    from
    $54/mo
    free plan
  5. Existing merchant accounts

    Authorize.Net

    Authorize.Net may fit a team that already has a merchant account and needs payment coverage across channels or U.S. eCheck payments. Plans start from $25, and a free plan isn’t listed. Per-seat pricing and setup effort aren’t published. Ask whether your merchant account works with it and what transaction fees will add.

    Trade-off: Paid-first pricing plus transaction fees.

    6.2/10
    from
    $25/mo
  6. Multi-channel payments

    Windcave

    Windcave is worth comparing if your business needs payments across channels, global acquiring or a range of payment methods. Pricing starts at an unpublished amount and is quote-based, so a few-seat cost isn’t clear upfront. Ask for a written quote and details on setup, supported payment methods and any extra costs.

    Trade-off: Quote-based pricing makes small-team costs hard to judge.

    5.8/10
    from
    Custom
  7. Crypto checkout

    Heleket

    Heleket is for businesses whose customers pay in crypto and teams that want website or Telegram checkout. Its listed starting price is $0, with no monthly software fee in the product summary. A per-seat total and setup effort aren’t published. Ask about variable fees and check whether crypto payments suit your customers.

    Trade-off: Variable fees and trust concerns merit review.

    5.5/10
    from
    Free
    free plan

03Side by side

ToolScoreFromFree planBest for
Square (current)7.2FreeYesSmall in-person sellers
PayPal6.8$5/moYesSmall shops accepting online payments
Clover6.8$29.95/moYesSmall retail shops
Cheddar Up6.5$15/moYesVolunteer groups collecting dues
Vanco6.8$54/moYesChurches starting online giving
Authorize.Net6.2$25/moNoBusinesses already using a merchant account
Windcave5.8CustomNoMerchants accepting payments across channels
Heleket5.5FreeYesBusinesses adding crypto checkout

Questions people ask

Are there cheaper alternatives to Square?

There are options with listed free plans or low starting prices, including PayPal, Cheddar Up and Heleket. That doesn’t guarantee a lower total bill: transaction fees, hardware and add-ons can matter. Compare the costs for your payment types and ask each vendor for a total based on your team’s needs.

What is the downside of using Square?

Square Free covers core selling tools, but paid features, payment processing and hardware add-ons can raise costs. One Reddit seller reported a sudden account closure and delayed access to funds; other commenters described difficulty reaching a person. Those reports are individual experiences, not proof that every seller will have the same problem.

Is Square or Wix better? Is Square still free?

Square’s free plan covers core selling tools, so it can work for a team starting with POS. The better fit depends on what you need to sell and which costs matter to you. We can’t rank Wix against Square here; compare current pricing, payment features and setup needs. Square is still listed with a free plan.