We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Small teams that routinely process on-location photos should choose Topaz Photo AI: its $39 monthly plan includes unlimited local and cloud image rendering and tools for denoising, sharpening, upscaling, face recovery, dust and scratch removal, and lighting. Choose Magic Eraser for occasional cleanup or AI headshots when a lower entry cost matters. Its free plan has limits, and Magic Eraser editing requires a purchased photo pack. At listed rates, five separate subscriptions would cost $195/month for Topaz or $74.95/month for Magic PRO, before photo packs.
01Side by side
| Topaz Photo AI | Magic Eraser | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan listed | 40 AI generations; watermarked, limited-resolution downloads |
| Cheapest paid plan | $39/month for Topaz Photo | PRO: $14.99 monthly or $4.99 annualized |
| Price per seat | Seat terms unpublished; listed plan costs $39/month | Seat terms unpublished; PRO starts at $4.99 annualized |
| Cost for five | $195/month assuming five separate subscriptions | $74.95/month plus photo packs, same assumption |
| Setup effort | Local or cloud rendering; setup time unpublished | Browser and mobile apps; setup time unpublished |
| Learning curve | Review ease score: 6/10 | Review ease score: 7/10 |
| Integrations | Integrations not published | Integrations not published |
| Support | Review support score: 7/10 | Review support score: 5/10 |
Topaz Photo AI Choose Topaz Photo AI if
- You routinely denoise, sharpen, upscale, or restore photos.
- You need unlimited local and cloud image rendering.
- Your organization has under $1 million in annual revenue.
Magic Eraser Choose Magic Eraser if
- You want to try basic AI image tools for free.
- You mainly need quick cleanup or AI headshots.
- A lower listed subscription price matters more than predictable pack costs.
02What each costs a small team
Topaz Photo has no free plan listed. Its pricing page lists $39/month, with unlimited local and cloud image rendering and limited commercial use for organizations under $1 million in annual revenue. Magic Studio lists a free tier with 40 AI generations, limited-resolution watermarked downloads, and one image at a time. Its PRO plan is $14.99 monthly or $4.99 per month billed yearly. For one person, that is $39 for Topaz or $14.99 for Magic PRO on monthly billing, before any Magic photo pack. The photo-pack price is not published, and Magic Eraser editing requires a pack. Assuming each person needs a separate subscription, three to five Topaz users cost $117–$195/month. Three to five Magic PRO users cost $44.97–$74.95/month, plus photo packs. Neither vendor publishes seat pricing for these plans.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes an estimate for setup time. Topaz Photo offers local and cloud rendering, so a team should decide which workflow fits its machines and internet access before rolling it out. The Photo plan includes unlimited rendering, but its listing does not describe team-seat management. Magic Studio is available on its website and iOS and Android apps, making it a lighter starting point for simple edits or headshots. Its team-headshot feature lets teams invite members and manage progress and downloads from one dashboard; confirm seat and pack costs before inviting a group. The review ease scores are 6/10 for Topaz and 7/10 for Magic Eraser, suggesting Magic may be easier for quick jobs. Topaz’s dedicated enhancement tools may take more learning if staff need to choose among models and adjustments.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Topaz Photo at $39/month is the lower-priced listed Topaz plan for photographers who need local and cloud tools. It includes unlimited image rendering, photo models, and cloud access to Wonder 1. The app’s listed tools include denoising, sharpening, upscaling, face recovery, dust and scratch removal, and lighting adjustments. The plan has limited commercial use for organizations under $1 million in annual revenue.
Magic Studio’s free tier includes 40 AI generations, limited-resolution downloads with watermarks, and one image at a time. PRO adds unlimited generations, high-resolution downloads without watermarks, and bulk editing for select tools. But don’t assume the free allowance covers Magic Eraser: the homepage says editing is available after purchasing a photo pack, and the eraser itself does not use credits. Magic also offers AI headshots, personal models, and team headshot management. Ask the vendor what packs cost before budgeting for a team.
Questions people ask
Does Topaz Photo AI or Magic Eraser have a free plan?
Topaz Photo has no free plan listed. Magic Studio lists a free tier with 40 AI generations, limited-resolution watermarked downloads, and one image at a time. However, Magic Eraser editing is available after buying a photo pack, and the pack price is not published; the eraser itself does not use credits.
Which is cheaper for a small team?
Magic PRO has the lower listed subscription price: $14.99 monthly or $4.99 per month billed yearly, compared with Topaz Photo at $39/month. But Magic photo packs are required for editing and their cost is not published. For five separate subscriptions, Magic PRO is $74.95/month before packs; Topaz is $195/month.
Can a team share one account or subscription?
Magic Studio says teams can invite members and manage headshot progress and downloads from one dashboard. That does not establish whether one subscription or photo pack covers everyone, so ask about team pricing and seat rules. Topaz Studio Pro lists seat management, but its price is not published; Topaz Photo does not specify seat handling.
Which tool is better for regular photography work?
Topaz Photo is the clearer fit for regular enhancement work: its $39/month plan includes unlimited local and cloud rendering, plus tools for denoising, sharpening, upscaling, and other corrections. Magic Eraser suits occasional distraction removal or headshots, but the required photo-pack price is not published.