review galore

Head-to-head · Network security

Zscaler Zero Trust Exchange vs Cisco Umbrella

Cisco Umbrella offers a 14-day trial; Zscaler lists a 500-user minimum. Neither vendor publishes prices, so get a quote before budgeting.

Zscaler Zero Trust Exchange

4.8/10
VS

Cisco Umbrella

6.0/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick Cisco Umbrella.

For a small team, Cisco Umbrella is the more practical first evaluation: its listed DNS Security and SIG plans include a 14-day trial. That does not make it free long term or prove it is cheaper; prices aren't published. Zscaler has broad listed zero-trust coverage, but its Essentials offer carries a 500-user minimum and no published price. We’d shortlist Cisco for a 1–10-person team, then request a written quote and verify setup requirements before committing.

01Side by side

Zscaler Zero Trust ExchangeCisco Umbrella
Free planNo free plan listed14-day free trial
Cheapest paid planEssentials Platform; price unpublishedDNS Security Essentials; price unpublished
Price per seatNot publishedNot published
Cost for a team of 5Not publishedNot published
Setup effortNot publishedNot published
Learning curveNot publishedNot published
Integrations a small team needsSpecific integrations not publishedSpecific integrations not published
SupportSupport terms not publishedSupport terms not published

Choose Zscaler Zero Trust Exchange if

  • Choose Zscaler if your organization can meet the 500-user minimum.
  • Choose Zscaler if you need its listed private-access features.
  • Choose Zscaler if you need listed coverage for users, workloads, and AI.

Choose Cisco Umbrella if

  • Choose Cisco Umbrella if a 14-day trial helps evaluate fit.
  • Choose Cisco Umbrella if DNS Security Essentials matches your security scope.
  • Choose Cisco Umbrella if SIG plans’ listed sandbox limits fit your needs.

02What each costs a small team

Neither vendor lists a free ongoing plan. Cisco Umbrella lists a 14-day free trial for its DNS Security and SIG plans; Zscaler lists no free plan. For one person, Zscaler’s Essentials Platform lists ZPA Standard at one user per 20 subscribed users and sets a 500-user minimum, so it is not a one-seat offer. Cisco’s DNS Security Essentials is available to evaluate through the trial, but its paid price and seat minimum aren’t published.

For a team of three to five, neither vendor publishes a total we can calculate. Ask both for a written quote covering five users, billing term, minimum commitment, and required products. Zscaler lists additional paid add-ons, but not their prices. Cisco lists DNS Security and SIG tiers, also without prices. The trial makes Cisco easier to evaluate, not confirmed cheaper.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline or a step-by-step estimate for a small team. Before choosing, ask what configuration help is included, what your team must do, and whether onboarding costs extra.

Zscaler’s Essentials listing includes App Connectors and App Segments, so ask what your team must configure for the private apps it wants to protect. The listing sets limits of up to 20 App Connectors and 10 App Segments. Cisco lists DNS Security and Secure Internet Gateway (SIG) plans; ask which fits your use case and what setup each requires. Its pricing listing doesn’t describe the implementation steps.

Learning-curve details aren’t published for either product. A small team should request a demo using its actual users, apps, and security needs, then confirm who will manage changes day to day. Don’t assume a trial alone shows the full setup workload.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Zscaler’s Essentials Platform lists ZPA Standard at one user per 20 subscribed users, with a 500-user minimum. It also lists up to 20 App Connectors, 10 App Segments, 1 GB of workload traffic per user per month, and 100 MB of Cyber Isolation per user. Those limits describe the Essentials offer; Zscaler’s broader platform lists higher allowances and additional coverage, but the price is not published.

Cisco lists DNS Security Essentials and DNS Security Advantage, but the published plan details don’t specify their features beyond a 14-day trial. For SIG Essentials, Cisco lists 500 file-inspection sandbox samples per day; SIG Advantage lists unlimited samples, and both list a 14-day trial. Cisco’s homepage describes broader security capabilities, but doesn’t describe Umbrella by name. Confirm with Cisco which features belong to the Umbrella plan you’re quoted, and whether a trial includes them.

Questions people ask

Is Zscaler getting acquired?

Zscaler describes Zero Trust Exchange as the foundation of its unified cybersecurity platform, but that is not an announcement about an acquisition. The platform description alone does not establish whether a deal is underway or completed. Check Zscaler’s official announcements and relevant regulatory filings for current status.

What is the new name for Cisco Umbrella?

Cisco’s homepage presents broader networking and security offerings, but doesn’t identify Umbrella as a renamed product. Its plan listings still use the Cisco Umbrella name. Ask Cisco whether the specific DNS Security or SIG product you’re considering is the current offering for your needs.

What is the difference between ZPA and ZIA?

Zscaler’s Essentials listing names ZPA Standard and ZPA Platform, but the product details here don’t define ZIA or compare the two. Ask Zscaler which product covers your use case, what each plan includes, and whether either requires a minimum user commitment.

Which should a small team choose?

Cisco Umbrella is the easier first evaluation because its listed DNS Security and SIG plans include a 14-day trial. Zscaler’s Essentials offer has a 500-user minimum. Since neither vendor publishes prices, request quotes before deciding which fits your budget.