review galore

Review · Subscription billing

Cratejoy review

A useful home for subscription-box sellers, but marketplace fees can take a meaningful cut as orders grow.

6.8/10Review Galore score

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

The bottom line

Worth considering for a box business that values built-in marketplace reach over lower fees.

Cratejoy is a marketplace for shoppers and a subscription-selling platform for creators. For a small seller, its draw is combining a marketplace listing with tools for recurring orders; there is no free plan, and fees sit on top of the subscription price.

We’d consider it for a new or small box business that wants to reach shoppers without building every subscription feature itself. Sellers focused on keeping fees low, or teams that need clearly published seat limits and onboarding details, should ask questions before signing up.

Good fit if

  • Subscription-box sellers seeking marketplace reach
  • Small teams starting recurring shipments
  • Sellers who want a custom website

Skip it if

  • Businesses that need a free plan
  • Sellers prioritizing the lowest transaction fees
  • Teams needing published seat limits
Cratejoy homepage
Cratejoy homepage, captured Nov 10, 2026

ScoresHow it rates

  • Features8
  • Ease of use6
  • Value for money6
  • Support6
  • User sentiment6

What works

  • Marketplace listing is included with Essentials
  • Marketplace Only includes daily and monthly view figures
  • Essentials includes a custom website and responsive templates
  • Advanced adds TaxJar, dunning, referrals and priority support
  • Supports 138 currencies across listed plans

What doesn't

  • No free plan is listed
  • All plans add transaction fees
  • Marketplace Only adds a 15% referral fee on every order and renewal
  • Essentials and Advanced charge 15% on Marketplace orders
  • Seat limits and setup time are not published

01Who Cratejoy is for

Cratejoy is for businesses selling subscription boxes, not a general-purpose tool for a small team’s recurring software bills. It combines a shopping marketplace for boxes, gifts and products with seller tools for building a subscription business. A one-to-ten-person team can use it to put a box in front of marketplace shoppers, manage recurring sales and, on Essentials or Advanced, run a custom website.

The cheapest plan, Marketplace Only, is aimed at existing subscription-box sellers. Essentials is the more relevant entry point for a new business that needs a website as well as a free Marketplace listing. The pricing page lists 30,000+ unique views daily and 4 million views monthly for Marketplace Only, but those figures are marketplace-wide, not a promise of traffic for any one seller. It makes most sense if built-in discovery matters more to you than avoiding referral fees. If your only need is a checkout or billing tool, Cratejoy may be more platform than you need.

02Cratejoy free plan and trial

Cratejoy does not list a free plan, and a free trial is not listed on the pricing page. The cheapest way in is Sell on the Marketplace Only: $29 per month, or $24.99 per month when billed yearly. That plan is for existing subscription-box sellers and includes a Marketplace presence, rather than a free way to test the platform.

The low monthly price is not the whole cost. All plans list a 1.25% + $0.10 transaction fee, and Marketplace Only adds a 15% referral fee on every order and renewal. If you are weighing Cratejoy against building your own site or subscription setup, ask the vendor whether there is a demo or any trial access before committing. The pricing page does not list either.

03What a small team pays for Cratejoy

The plans are priced per month, not per seat; the pricing page does not list seat-based rates. For one person, Marketplace Only is $29 monthly or $24.99 per month on the yearly rate. Essentials is $79 monthly or $59 yearly, and Advanced is $199 monthly or $159 yearly. The yearly figures are monthly equivalents: that works out to $299.88, $708 or $1,908 billed per year, respectively.

For a three-person team, those listed prices work out to $9.67/$8.33 per person monthly on Marketplace Only, $26.33/$19.67 on Essentials, or $66.33/$53 on Advanced, using monthly/yearly rates. For five people, the same calculation is $5.80/$5, $15.80/$11.80, or $39.80/$31.80 per person. These are just the plan price divided across the team, not published seat costs.

Budget extra for 1.25% + $0.10 per transaction. Marketplace Only also charges 15% on every order and renewal; Essentials and Advanced charge 15% on Marketplace orders.

04Getting started with Cratejoy

Cratejoy does not publish a setup-time estimate or a detailed list of onboarding steps on its pricing page, so we would not assume it is a same-day setup. A seller will need to get the box and subscription offer ready, decide whether to use a Cratejoy website, and work out shipping and renewals. Essentials lists a custom website, responsive templates, and advanced renewal and shipping features; Advanced adds dunning and TaxJar integration.

The plan descriptions do not specify which third-party integrations are available beyond TaxJar on Advanced. Ask the vendor about payment, shipping, tax and storefront connections that matter to your business before choosing a plan. A Reddit seller praised the ready-made backend for handling details such as addresses, couponing, recurring payments, cancellations and shipments. Another commenter argued those pieces can be built with common web tools. That disagreement is a useful reminder: the learning curve depends partly on whether you want a packaged system or control over your own setup.

05When small teams outgrow Cratejoy

The first pressure point is cost, not seats: Cratejoy does not list per-seat pricing, but transaction and referral fees rise with sales. Marketplace Only takes a 15% referral fee on every order and renewal, while Essentials and Advanced charge 15% on Marketplace orders. A seller whose volume grows may want to compare those charges with the value of marketplace discovery and the cost of running a separate system.

The next reason to upgrade is feature need. Essentials adds a custom website and advanced renewal and shipping features; Advanced adds TaxJar, advanced dunning, a referral app and priority support. If you need those, the jump from Essentials to Advanced is $120 more per month at monthly billing, or $100 more per month at the yearly rate.

Reddit sellers disagree on whether Cratejoy’s ready-made backend is worth its fees: one praised its built-in subscription features, while other commenters favored building with their own tools. A Reddit buyer also described a seller failing to ship and waiting for support. If your business needs tighter control over fulfillment, costs or support response, ask how Cratejoy handles those cases before scaling on it.

From the threadsWhat users say

Reddit sentiment is mixed: some sellers value the ready-made subscription backend, while others question the fees or prefer building their own setup. A buyer’s account of an unshipped order also raises a practical reminder to vet marketplace sellers and understand the support process.

Ready-made backend
You won't believe all the little things they've thought about and already coded into theiy system until you try to find someone to build something for you
r/Entrepreneur · view thread
Fee concerns
an extra 1.5% that cratejoy charges could be more than $5k
r/Entrepreneur · view thread
Build-it-yourself option
WordPress, woocommerce, Stripe. Seems easiest way to go
r/Entrepreneur · view thread
Seller fulfillment risk
they wanted me to wait before they did anything because they believed the seller was still going to ship it
r/SubscriptionBoxes · view thread

Questions people ask

Is Cratejoy a legitimate company?

Cratejoy operates a marketplace for subscription boxes and a platform for sellers. Its homepage says purchase protection is included. Still, marketplace purchases depend on individual sellers: one Reddit buyer reported a box that was charged but not shipped and described waiting for support. Check a seller’s track record and the protection terms before ordering.

Does Cratejoy have a free plan or trial?

The pricing page does not list a free plan or free trial. The least expensive listed option is Sell on the Marketplace Only, at $29 per month or $24.99 per month when billed yearly. It also has transaction and referral fees, so include those in your cost estimate.

How much does Cratejoy cost for a small team?

The plans are listed as monthly prices, not per-seat prices. Marketplace Only costs $29 monthly or $24.99 per month at the yearly rate; Essentials costs $79 or $59; Advanced costs $199 or $159. All plans add a 1.25% + $0.10 transaction fee, with additional Marketplace referral fees depending on the plan.

What does Cratejoy’s Marketplace Only plan include?

Marketplace Only is aimed at existing subscription-box sellers. The pricing page lists access to 1,500+ Marketplace merchants, 30,000+ unique views daily, 4 million views monthly and support for 138 currencies. It does not list a custom website on this plan, and it charges a 15% referral fee on every order and renewal.

Which Cratejoy plan includes a website?

Essentials and Advanced list a custom website and responsive templates. Essentials also includes a free Marketplace listing and advanced renewal and shipping features. Advanced includes everything in Essentials, plus native TaxJar integration, advanced dunning, a referral app and priority support. Compare the extra features with the higher plan price and Marketplace fees.

Sources

  1. Cratejoy homepage
  2. Cratejoy pricing page
  3. Reddit: Anyone use CrateJoy for their box subscription service?
  4. Reddit: Sub-box website solutions - Wordpress, Shopify, Cratejoy, Other?
  5. Reddit: Warning about cratejoy