review galore

Simpler and cheaper options · 6 options

INKY alternatives

Compare email security and private email options by price, team fit and what to clarify before you switch.

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

A 1–10-person team may not need to replace INKY if its email protection works and the contract fits. But INKY’s price isn’t published, so small buyers can’t compare costs without talking to sales. Reddit users cite concern about the Kaseya acquisition, support and billing, though some say their experience with the product remains positive. Our picks include security tools for business email and lower-cost private email services—but hosted email is not a like-for-like replacement for an INKY security layer.

01Why people leave INKY

Uncertainty after the acquisition

Some MSPs reconsidered after Kaseya acquired INKY; other users say their experience with the product has remained positive.

Support and billing concerns

Reddit users describe worries about support responsiveness, contract terms and billing friction; ask for renewal and downgrade terms in writing.

Hard to judge the price

INKY’s price is not published, so a small team needs a quote to compare per-seat cost and minimum commitments.

02The alternatives, ranked by fit

  1. Small-team email security

    Proofpoint Essentials

    Proofpoint Essentials is the clearest price-led security comparison here: the listed starting price for a new small team is $2.75 per user monthly, or $13.75 monthly for five users. There’s no free plan listed. Compare its protection and setup requirements with your INKY configuration, and ask about contract terms and any minimum seats before switching.

    Trade-off: No free plan is listed, and the starting price may not cover every team’s needs.

    6.3/10
    from
    $1.65/mo
  2. SaaS email protection

    Avanan

    Avanan is worth considering if your team relies on SaaS email and wants phishing protection plus post-delivery cleanup. The vendor doesn’t publish pricing or seat limits, so there’s no reliable small-team total to compare with INKY. Ask for a quote for your exact seat count, along with setup steps and any minimum commitment, before evaluating it further.

    Trade-off: Unpublished pricing and seat limits make budgeting difficult.

    6.6/10
    from
    Custom
  3. Sensitive email controls

    Virtru

    Virtru may suit a small team that needs post-send access controls for sensitive email in Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace. It has no free plan, and the listed price is $119 per month with an annual commitment; the covered seat count isn’t published. Ask the vendor how many users that price includes and what setup involves.

    Trade-off: The annual commitment is a sizable fixed cost for a small team.

    6.5/10
    from
    $119/mo
  4. Healthcare email security

    Paubox

    Paubox is a more relevant comparison than a general tool if your team emails patient data and uses Google Workspace or Microsoft 365. It offers inbound email protection, but the vendor doesn’t publish pricing, so you can’t calculate a few-seat total from the listed information. Ask for a quote and confirm setup requirements for your email environment.

    Trade-off: Unpublished pricing makes it hard to assess affordability before contacting sales.

    6.3/10
    from
    Custom
  5. Low-cost private email

    Mailfence

    Mailfence is a budget-friendly option if your real need is private email hosting, not an added security layer for an existing inbox. Its listing includes a free plan and a starting price of $2.50, and it supports teams of up to five, custom domains, OpenPGP and shared tools. Confirm what the free plan includes and how domain setup works.

    Trade-off: Private email hosting is not a like-for-like replacement for INKY protection.

    7.0/10
    from
    €2.50/mo
    free plan
  6. Free private email

    Tuta

    Tuta offers a free personal plan, but that isn’t the same as free business coverage. Business seats start at €6 per user per month when billed annually, so five seats work out to €30 monthly on that basis. It includes private email, calendars and contacts; ask about business setup and whether it fits your existing email workflow.

    Trade-off: The free plan is personal, and business pricing requires annual billing.

    6.9/10
    from
    €3/mo
    free plan

03Side by side

ToolScoreFromFree planBest for
INKY (current)6.3CustomNoTeams protecting Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace
Proofpoint Essentials6.3$1.65/moNoSmall teams securing business email
Avanan6.6CustomNoTeams relying on SaaS email
Virtru6.5$119/moNoSmall teams handling sensitive email
Paubox6.3CustomNoHealthcare teams emailing patient data
Mailfence7.0€2.50/moYesTeams of up to five
Tuta6.9€3/moYesSmall teams prioritizing private email

Questions people ask

Is INKY a good fit for a team of 1–10?

It can be if your team needs protection for Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace, user coaching, and inbound and outbound coverage. But INKY’s price isn’t published, so a small team can’t judge the value from a list price. Ask for a quote, seat minimums and contract terms before deciding.

What is the cheapest INKY alternative?

Among these picks, Mailfence lists a free plan and a starting price of $2.50, while Tuta has a free personal plan and business seats from €6 per user monthly with annual billing. Neither is a direct replacement for an email-security layer, so check whether hosted private email meets your actual need.

What should we ask before switching from INKY?

Request a written quote for your seat count and confirm minimum commitments, renewal terms, price holds, support terms and whether you can downgrade mid-contract. Also ask about setup and alert routing for your email environment. Reddit users raise concerns about billing and support, while some report a positive product experience.