We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A small team may not need to leave PayPal if it mainly sends or requests money. But if variable fees, account concerns, or checkout needs are getting in the way, a more focused payment tool may fit better. PayPal has a free plan, but the real cost depends on fees. We’d compare alternatives by what you sell: Square for broad selling tools, or a specialist for group collections, retail, donations, or crypto payments.
01Why people leave PayPal
Fees can be hard to predict
PayPal’s fees vary. One Reddit thread describes a seller disputing a refund and dispute fee after a $1,700 sale.
Account restrictions feel risky
Reddit users describe restricted accounts and difficult dispute outcomes. These are individual reports, not proof of how every case is handled.
International payments can be a hurdle
A Reddit thread asks for alternatives after trouble receiving international client payments and making KES withdrawals.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Small sellers
SquareSquareSquare has a free plan, and its listing says Square Free covers core selling tools. It suits small teams selling in person and online. The paid starting price and per-seat pricing are not published. Before switching, check processing fees, paid features, hardware costs, and which selling channels your setup needs.
Trade-off: Budget for processing, hardware, or paid features.
7.2/10from
Freefree plan - Groups and fundraisers
Cheddar UpCheddar UpCheddar Up is aimed at volunteer groups collecting dues and clubs running fundraisers or events, with forms alongside payments. The listing includes a free plan and a $15 starting price. Per-seat pricing and setup time are not published, so ask what the free plan includes and check transaction fees before sharing a payment link.
Trade-off: Best suited to group collections, not general retail.
6.5/10from
$15/mofree plan - Retail and restaurants
CloverCloverClover is built for small retail shops, restaurants needing POS hardware, and service businesses taking payments. Its listing shows a free plan and a $29.95 starting price. Per-seat pricing and setup time are not published. Get a full quote that includes devices, processing, and hardware before comparing it with PayPal.
Trade-off: Device, processing, and hardware costs need checking.
6.8/10from
$29.95/mofree plan - Churches and nonprofits
VancoVancoVanco is aimed at churches taking online giving, nonprofits collecting recurring donations, and teams needing in-person payments. The listing includes a $0 starting plan and a $54 starting price. Per-seat pricing and setup time are not published. Ask what the free plan covers and price processing fees and extras for your giving needs.
Trade-off: Processing fees and extras affect the real cost.
6.8/10from
$54/mofree plan - Crypto payments
HeleketHeleketHeleket is for businesses whose customers pay in crypto and teams using website or Telegram checkout. The listing shows a $0 plan with no monthly software fee. Per-seat pricing and setup time are not published. Check variable fees and trust concerns carefully, and choose it only if crypto payments suit your customers.
Trade-off: Crypto checkout is a narrow fit for many teams.
5.5/10from
Freefree plan - Merchant-account teams
Authorize.NetAuthorize.NetAuthorize.Net offers payment coverage across channels and eCheck payments for U.S. businesses, particularly those already using a merchant account. The listing starts at $25 per month plus transaction fees; a free plan is not listed. Per-seat pricing and setup time are not published. Compare the monthly fee and transaction costs with your current setup.
Trade-off: The $25 monthly starting price makes it paid-first.
6.2/10from
$25/mo
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.8 | $5/mo | Yes | Small shops accepting online payments | |
| 7.2 | Free | Yes | Small in-person sellers | |
| 6.5 | $15/mo | Yes | Volunteer groups collecting dues | |
| 6.8 | $29.95/mo | Yes | Small retail shops | |
| 6.8 | $54/mo | Yes | Churches starting online giving | |
| 5.5 | Free | Yes | Businesses adding crypto checkout | |
| 6.2 | $25/mo | No | Businesses already using a merchant account |
Questions people ask
What is the best alternative for PayPal?
For a small team that sells both in person and online, Square is a practical place to start: it has a free plan and covers core selling tools. Cheddar Up may suit group collections, while Clover is aimed at retail, restaurants, and service businesses. Compare transaction and hardware costs before choosing.
Who is PayPal’s biggest competitor?
There isn’t one best fit for every small team. Square is a broad option for selling in person and online; Clover focuses on POS use, while Authorize.Net suits businesses already using a merchant account. The right comparison depends on your sales channels, processing costs, and setup needs.
What do Americans use instead of PayPal?
For a small U.S. team, options include Square for in-person and online selling, Clover for POS, and Authorize.Net for businesses using a merchant account. Vanco focuses on churches and nonprofits. These tools serve different needs, so check payment methods and fees rather than picking by name alone.
