We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick Square.
Choose Square if your small team needs a point-of-sale system, an online site, and tools for items, bookings, or invoices at no monthly cost. Choose PayPal if you mainly need online checkout, transfers, or in-person and QR payments without a monthly account fee. Both charge transaction fees on payments. Square’s paid plan prices are not published, while PayPal lists a $5-a-month paid option; those are not equivalent feature bundles.
01Side by side
| Square | PayPal | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Free POS app, online site, item library, invoicing, booking | No monthly account fee; transaction fees apply |
| Cheapest paid plan | Square Plus price is not published | Payments Advanced: $5 per month |
| Price per seat | No per-seat price listed | No per-seat price listed |
| Cost for a team of 5 | $0 monthly on Free; processing fees may apply | $0 monthly account fee; transaction fees apply |
| Setup effort | Setup time is not published | Setup time is not published |
| Learning curve | Review ease score: 7/10 | Review ease score: 6/10 |
| Integrations for small teams | Connects with hundreds of business apps | Checkout, transfers, and payment options |
| Support | Premium lists 24/7 priority phone support | Support terms are not published |
Square Choose Square if
- Choose Square if you need in-person POS and online selling tools.
- Choose Square if your team needs item, booking, or invoicing tools.
- Choose Square if app connections and business operations tools matter.
PayPal Choose PayPal if
- Choose PayPal if you mainly need online checkout and transfers.
- Choose PayPal if you want no monthly account maintenance fee.
- Choose PayPal if Pay in 4 or Pay Monthly fits your customers.
02What each costs a small team
Square Free costs $0 per month for one person or a team of five. The plan includes a POS app, online site, item library, invoicing, and booking; processing fees and paid add-ons can add costs. Square doesn’t publish monthly prices for Plus or Premium, so ask Square for a quote before budgeting for those tiers.
PayPal Business Account has no monthly maintenance fee, whether one person or five use it, but transaction fees apply. Its listed rates include 3.49% + $0.49 for PayPal Checkout and 2.29% + $0.09 for in-person or QR transactions. PayPal Payments Advanced is the cheapest listed paid option at $5 monthly, or $60 yearly, for one person or five; it also has transaction fees. Neither product lists a per-seat rate.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither company publishes a time estimate for setup, so plan around the configuration your selling process needs. With Square, that may mean setting up the POS app, item library, online site, invoices, or booking. Teams adding paid tools may also need to configure scheduling, attendance, or loyalty features.
PayPal’s setup depends on which payment option you choose: its business account lists checkout, card payments, and in-person or QR transactions, while additional products carry separate fees. PayPal also offers transfers and customer pay-over-time options. In either case, confirm payment methods and transaction costs before rolling the tool out to staff.
Our review scores give Square a 7/10 for ease of use and PayPal a 6/10. These scores are a guide, not a setup-time estimate.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Square Free is the more complete starting point if your team needs selling tools, not just payment acceptance. Its listed features include a POS app, online site, item library, invoicing, booking, and checking and savings accounts. Square also describes team management, marketing, cash flow tools, app connections, and Square AI across its business offering; check which features require a paid tier before relying on them.
PayPal’s business account has no monthly maintenance fee and lists PayPal Checkout, Venmo, card-payment options, and in-person or QR transactions, each with applicable processing fees. Payflow Link also has no monthly fee and lists a $0.10 transaction fee. The business account is a fit for accepting payments, while some additional processing products have monthly fees. PayPal’s consumer-facing services also include transfers and eligible pay-over-time options. It is not a POS-and-business-tools bundle like Square Free.
Questions people ask
Are Square and Venmo the same?
No. Square is a point-of-sale and business tools platform. Venmo is a payment option listed with PayPal Checkout for businesses. The published pricing lists PayPal Checkout and Venmo at 3.49% + $0.49, but that does not make the two products the same.
How much is the PayPal transaction fee for $3,000?
It depends on the payment type. At PayPal Checkout’s listed 3.49% + $0.49 rate, a $3,000 transaction would cost $105.19. At the listed 2.29% + $0.09 in-person or QR rate, it would cost $68.79. Confirm which rate applies to your transaction.
Who is PayPal’s biggest competitor?
There is no source-backed ranking here that identifies PayPal’s single biggest competitor. For a small business comparing payment tools, Square is one alternative: it offers a free POS app and online site, while PayPal focuses on checkout, transfers, and payment options.
Can Square accept PayPal payments?
Square’s listed features cover in-person and online payments, but they don’t specify PayPal as an accepted payment method. The available information does not confirm compatibility. Ask Square whether your checkout or POS setup can accept PayPal before choosing it.