review galore

Simpler and cheaper options · 6 options

WatchGuard Firebox alternatives

A practical shortlist for small teams weighing a self-managed firewall, lighter DNS filtering or a different security platform.

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Most teams with 1–10 people need a network firewall, but may not need WatchGuard’s broader set of security services and administration tools. WatchGuard does not publish a small-team price, and Reddit users warn that licensing matters to keeping a Firebox useful. Start with the free options if you can manage your own setup; listed starting prices range from $2.325 for NextDNS to $18 for ZeroTier, though neither replaces a full firewall. Check billing terms and limits before budgeting.

01Why people leave WatchGuard Firebox

Licensing adds an ongoing cost

One r/msp commenter warns that a Firebox loses usefulness when its license expires; subscription services add an ongoing cost to track.

Small-team pricing is unclear

A commenter called WatchGuard expensive compared with SonicWall and Fortinet; WatchGuard does not publish a small-team price.

IKEv2 may hit a connection limit

One Reddit user reports IKEv2 failures when requests exceed the ISP’s MTU; commenters discuss switching VPN methods, including SSL.

02The alternatives, ranked by fit

  1. Business firewall

    OPNsense Business Edition

    OPNsense Business Edition is a close fit if you want a business firewall without paying by teammate: its listed starting price is $11.08 per firewall installation. It suits teams managing their own firewall and consultants deploying client firewalls. You’ll manage the firewall yourself and can choose selective firmware updates. Ask the vendor about deployment support, billing terms and whether a free option fits your needs.

    Trade-off: You take on firewall management; the listed price is per installation.

    7.2/10
    from
    €11.08/mo
  2. Flexible firewall

    pfSense Plus

    pfSense Plus has a free plan and a listed starting price of $10.75. It fits teams managing their own network, including those that need site-to-cloud connections. A Reddit user in an r/msp thread says they use pfSense for many clients with around 15 or fewer employees. Expect to make setup and upgrade choices yourself; check the vendor’s pricing terms before comparing costs.

    Trade-off: Setup and upgrade choices take care; it’s for teams willing to manage their network.

    6.8/10
    from
    $10.75/mo
    free plan
  3. Small-team VPN alternative

    ZeroTier

    ZeroTier is worth considering if your main need is connecting remote devices, not replacing a full gateway firewall. It has a free plan and a listed starting price of $18, with a best-fit limit of up to 10 devices. That device-based limit may suit a very small team, but count devices rather than seats and confirm the plan’s terms before adopting it.

    Trade-off: It’s a VPN alternative, not a full firewall replacement.

    7.5/10
    from
    $18/mo
    free plan
  4. DNS threat blocking

    NextDNS

    NextDNS offers a free plan and a listed starting price of $2.325, making it a low-cost option if DNS-level threat blocking is the main goal. It is not a substitute for a complete network firewall. The business package starts at a 50-employee tier, so a small team should check whether the free plan meets its needs before treating the entry price as a business budget.

    Trade-off: DNS filtering covers less than a full firewall; business pricing starts at 50 employees.

    7.6/10
    from
    CA$2.33/mo
    free plan
  5. Dedicated gateway

    Check Point Quantum Security Gateways

    Check Point Quantum Security Gateways suit teams that specifically need dedicated gateway hardware for a hybrid environment. The product covers a broad security scope, but the vendor does not publish a public price or free plan, so it is hard to compare against WatchGuard on a small-team budget. Ask for a quote that includes the hardware and the security features your team needs.

    Trade-off: No public price or free plan makes budgeting difficult.

    5.8/10
    from
    Custom
  6. Cloud security platform

    Zscaler Cloud IPS

    Zscaler Cloud IPS may suit a team looking beyond a single gateway and seeking protection for non-web protocols within a wider security platform. Cloud IPS is available through Firewall Advanced, but product details and pricing are hard to assess publicly. Ask the vendor which package includes the protection you need and what the total cost would be for your team.

    Trade-off: Pricing and product details are hard to assess.

    5.0/10
    from
    Custom

03Side by side

ToolScoreFromFree planBest for
WatchGuard Firebox (current)6.8CustomNoSMBs needing managed firewall security
OPNsense Business Edition7.2€11.08/moNoTeams managing a business firewall
pfSense Plus6.8$10.75/moYesTeams managing their own network
ZeroTier7.5$18/moYesSmall teams with up to 10 devices
NextDNS7.6CA$2.33/moYesFamilies filtering multiple devices
Check Point Quantum Security Gateways5.8CustomNoTeams securing hybrid environments
Zscaler Cloud IPS5.0CustomNoTeams buying a wider security platform

Questions people ask

Does WatchGuard publish Firebox pricing for small teams?

WatchGuard does not publish a small-team price in the available pricing summary. A Reddit commenter also warns that licensing matters because a Firebox may lose usefulness when its license expires. Ask WatchGuard or a reseller for a quote that spells out hardware, subscriptions and renewal costs.

What is the cheapest alternative for a small team?

NextDNS has a listed starting price of $2.325 and a free plan, but it provides DNS-level threat blocking, not a full firewall. For a self-managed business firewall, OPNsense Business Edition lists a starting price of $11.08 per firewall installation. Check billing terms and feature limits with the vendor before comparing totals.

Is WatchGuard Firebox IKEv2 VPN reliable?

A Reddit user reports intermittent IKEv2 failures when connection requests exceed the ISP’s MTU, and says WatchGuard support described a hardware limitation involving packet fragmentation. Commenters discuss other VPN methods, including SSL. If IKEv2 is essential, ask WatchGuard to confirm support for your network conditions before buying.