We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A team of 1–10 may not need Workday’s broad HR-and-finance scope. If your main need is shift scheduling, a free plan from Sling or Connecteam may be enough to start. If you need broader HR coverage or international hiring, compare BambooHR, Rippling, or Deel—but check what a few seats actually cost. Workday doesn’t publish pricing, so ask for a quote and confirm implementation expectations before committing.
01Why people leave Workday
Hard to use as an applicant
In one Reddit thread, applicants complained about confusing forms, repeated data entry, and having to create a separate account for each employer.
Rigid workflows and dependencies
A commenter described Workday as inflexible and date-driven, with dependencies that made the system difficult to navigate.
Too much system for a small team
Workday covers HR and finance, but a small team focused on scheduling or basic HR may prefer a narrower tool with a free starting point.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Best for teams of 10
ConnecteamConnecteamConnecteam is built for teams of up to 10 and has a free plan, making it a practical first stop if Workday feels oversized. Its listed starting price is $29, but the paid hubs and extra controls can add complexity. The available details don’t specify setup effort or the cost for your exact needs, so ask for both before upgrading.
Trade-off: Paid hubs and extra controls add complexity.
7.6/10from
$29/mofree plan - Best free scheduler
SlingSlingSling suits small teams that mainly need hourly shift scheduling, and it offers a free plan. Its listed starting price is $1.70; paid plans add time tracking and reporting by seat. That can keep the starting point modest, but ask how many seats the price covers and what setup help is available before you roll it out.
Trade-off: It focuses on scheduling, not connected HR and finance.
7.4/10from
$1.70/mofree plan - Best for shift teams
When I WorkWhen I WorkWhen I Work covers shift scheduling, multiple locations, and shift messaging, with a listed starting price of $2.50. It may suit a small hourly team that doesn’t need Workday’s broader scope. Time tracking costs extra, and its add-on price isn’t listed here, so request a quote for your team size and ask what setup involves.
Trade-off: Time tracking is an add-on; check its price.
6.2/10from
$2.50/mo - Best for growing HR
BambooHRBambooHRBambooHR is aimed at growing teams that want centralized HR, hiring, and onboarding. Its listed starting price is $10.25, but a flat monthly minimum can make it costly for very small teams. Ask the vendor for the minimum bill and a quote for your headcount; confirm what implementation support and setup work are included.
Trade-off: A flat monthly minimum may price out tiny teams.
6.2/10from
$10.25/mo - Best for connected tools
RipplingRipplingRippling is for teams consolidating workforce tools and managing global workers. The listed starting price is $8, but small teams need a custom quote, so don’t assume that figure is your total for a few seats. Ask what your chosen tools cost together, what the contract requires, and what setup support is included.
Trade-off: Custom pricing and contract details need close review.
6.0/10from
$8/mo - Best for global hiring
DeelDeelDeel is aimed at teams hiring across countries or paying international contractors, with a listed starting price of $14. There’s no free plan, and employer-of-record costs can add up quickly. It’s a more focused option than Workday for cross-border needs, but ask for a quote covering your worker types and confirm setup expectations.
Trade-off: No free plan; EOR costs can add up.
6.3/10from
$14/mo
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4.5 | Custom | No | Organizations combining HR and finance | |
| 7.6 | $29/mo | Yes | Teams of up to 10 | |
| 7.4 | $1.70/mo | Yes | Small teams scheduling hourly shifts | |
| 6.2 | $2.50/mo | No | Hourly teams scheduling shifts | |
| 6.2 | $10.25/mo | No | Growing teams centralizing HR | |
| 6.0 | $8/mo | No | Teams consolidating workforce tools | |
| 6.3 | $14/mo | No | Teams hiring across countries |
Questions people ask
Is Workday a competitor of ServiceNow?
Workday’s listed strengths are HR, finance, connected business workflows, and budgeting and forecasts. Whether that competes with ServiceNow depends on the specific workflow you need. Compare the products against your requirements rather than treating them as direct substitutes by default.
What are five workforce management options for small teams?
For a small team comparing these alternatives, consider Connecteam, Sling, and When I Work for scheduling and time tracking. Rippling and UKG Pro are broader workforce options, but Rippling needs a custom quote and UKG Pro’s pricing isn’t published. Match the shortlist to your team’s main job to be done.
Is Workday an ERP or a CRM?
Workday’s stated use cases here center on HR and finance, including connected workflows and planning budgets and forecasts. The listed information doesn’t establish a CRM role. If you’re comparing software categories, ask the vendor which specific functions and workflows are included in your proposed package.
