review galore

Head-to-head · Payroll tools

ADP Workforce Now vs QuickBooks Online Payroll

For most 1–10-person teams, QuickBooks is easier to price. ADP is better suited to businesses needing broader workforce solutions.

ADP Workforce Now

5.2/10
VS

QuickBooks Online Payroll

6.2/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick QuickBooks Online Payroll.

For a 1–10-person team, QuickBooks Online Payroll is the easier choice to budget for: its cheapest payroll plan lists a $50 monthly base plus $7 per employee. ADP Workforce Now may fit a growing business that needs broader HR and workforce solutions, but ADP doesn’t publish pricing, and its listed plans generally target 50 or more employees. If your team is small, get an ADP quote before investing time in a comparison.

01Side by side

ADP Workforce NowQuickBooks Online Payroll
Free planNo free plan; pricing requires a quoteNo free plan; 30-day trial listed
Cheapest paid planPrice not published$50 monthly base plus $7 per employee
Price per employeeNot published$7 monthly on the cheapest payroll plan
Five-person monthly costNot published$85 before any extra fees
Setup effortSetup time not publishedSetup time not published
Learning curveEase-of-use score: 4Ease-of-use score: 5
Accounting integrationsSpecific integrations not listedPayroll syncs with QuickBooks accounting
SupportReview support score: 5Review support score: 4

Choose ADP Workforce Now if

  • Choose ADP Workforce Now if your team is approaching midsize or larger.
  • Choose ADP Workforce Now if you need broader HR and workforce solutions.
  • Choose ADP Workforce Now if you’re willing to request custom pricing.

Choose QuickBooks Online Payroll if

  • Choose QuickBooks Online Payroll if you need published per-employee pricing.
  • Choose QuickBooks Online Payroll if your team already uses QuickBooks accounting.
  • Choose QuickBooks Online Payroll if you need payroll taxes and unlimited runs.

02What each costs a small team

Neither product lists a free plan. QuickBooks offers a 30-day trial; ADP’s listed pricing has no free trial. For a one-person team, QuickBooks Workforce Payroll comes to $57 monthly: a $50 base plus $7 per employee. For three people, it’s $71; for five, $85. The pricing lists an introductory $25 monthly base for three months, making those totals $32, $46 and $60 during that offer, before extra fees.

ADP doesn’t publish Workforce Now pricing, so we can’t calculate a one-person or five-person cost. Its listed plans generally target organizations with 50 to 999 or more employees, which makes it a tough fit to budget for a small team. Ask ADP for a quote that spells out per-employee charges, implementation costs and any add-ons.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline in the pricing details, so ask how long implementation takes and what your team must prepare. For ADP, confirm whether the quote includes setup and training, especially if you’re considering a product generally targeted at 50 or more employees.

QuickBooks brings payroll together with its accounting software and says payroll can sync with accounting records. Its payroll tools include time tracking, schedules and contractor payments, so a team using those features should ask which setup steps and plan charges apply. The listed ease-of-use scores are 4 for ADP and 5 for QuickBooks; they suggest QuickBooks may be easier to get started with, but neither score tells you how much setup your particular company needs. Get a walkthrough before committing.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

QuickBooks Workforce Payroll, the lowest-priced payroll plan, lists unlimited payroll runs and costs $50 monthly plus $7 per employee. QuickBooks describes its payroll offering as supporting payroll tax filing, Auto Payroll for salaried employees on direct deposit, and payroll syncing with accounting records. The available pricing doesn’t map every feature to a specific tier, so confirm what the base plan includes before signing up.

ADP’s homepage describes payroll and HR solutions across business sizes, plus time and attendance for small and midsized businesses. It lists workforce management for large businesses, talent solutions for midsized businesses, and benefits administration for midsized and large businesses. But ADP doesn’t publish Workforce Now pricing or seat limits, so ask which features are included in your quote.

QuickBooks lists additional-state filing at $12 per state monthly, included with Elite. Benefits administration and related services carry separate fees.

Questions people ask

Is ADP Workforce Now or QuickBooks cheaper for a small team?

QuickBooks is easier to price: its cheapest payroll plan is $50 monthly plus $7 per employee. Five people would cost $85 monthly before extra fees. ADP doesn’t publish Workforce Now pricing, so request a quote to compare the real cost.

How much is QuickBooks Online Payroll for five employees?

The listed Workforce Payroll price is a $50 monthly base plus $7 per employee. For five employees, that totals $85 monthly before any extra fees. The pricing lists a $25 monthly base for the first three months as an introductory offer.

Does ADP Workforce Now offer a free plan?

ADP’s listed Workforce Now pricing does not include a free plan or free trial. ADP doesn’t publish prices, so contact the vendor for a quote and ask whether setup or add-on services carry separate costs.

Does QuickBooks Online Payroll include a free trial?

Yes. QuickBooks lists a 30-day trial. Its cheapest payroll plan is priced at a $50 monthly base plus $7 per employee, with a listed introductory $25 monthly base for three months. Confirm the offer terms before subscribing.