We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A small team may not need to replace QuickBooks Online Payroll if its tax filing and time-tracking fit the budget. But a base fee can sting with just a few employees, and Reddit users report migration and access problems. SurePayroll starts at $20, while Gusto starts at $49; exact costs for a few seats aren’t listed. The $0 options here are earned-wage or employee benefits, not full payroll replacements. Ask vendors about setup and migration before switching.
01Why people leave QuickBooks Online Payroll
Base fees hit small rosters
QuickBooks Online Payroll starts at $25, and its summary flags the base fee as costly for small teams.
Migration can mean manual work
In one Reddit thread, a user said moving from Desktop Payroll meant re-entering data; commenters also described conversions going wrong.
Payroll access can be unreliable
One Reddit thread describes a user unable to reach the payroll section when trying to run payroll.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Straightforward small payroll
SurePayrollSurePayrollSurePayroll is the clearest lower-priced payroll alternative here: it starts at $20 and is described as a fit for straightforward small-business payroll, with automatic tax filing. The listed price is a starting point, not a quote for your exact headcount. Ask whether it covers your state and how it handles moving payroll records from QuickBooks.
Trade-off: Confirm the monthly price and migration support before switching.
7.0/10from
$20/mo - Payroll plus HR
GustoGustoGusto suits teams that want payroll and HR together, including those paying employees and contractors. The pricing starts at $49, but seat costs can add up; the exact total for a few people isn’t listed. Ask for a quote based on your headcount and state, plus the steps and support available for transferring payroll data.
Trade-off: Budget for the base fee and seats; support reports are uneven.
6.8/10from
$49/mo - Payroll and benefits
JustworksJustworksJustworks is worth comparing if your small team wants payroll, HR, and benefits administration under one roof. Its listed starting price is $8, but the exact cost for your team isn’t stated here. Ask what the base fee covers, how benefits renewals affect the bill, and what onboarding help is available before you leave QuickBooks.
Trade-off: Check the base fee and benefit renewal costs.
6.5/10from
$8/mo - Payroll tax filing
PaychexPaychexPaychex offers payroll and HR coverage and is listed as an option for employers needing payroll tax filing. Its price isn’t published, so a small team can’t compare its real cost from a starting rate. Request a quote for your headcount and ask about onboarding, tax filing, and any minimum fees before making a change.
Trade-off: You’ll need a quote to judge whether it fits your budget.
5.0/10from
Custom - Healthcare payroll
ViventiumViventiumViventium is aimed at healthcare and post-acute care providers, with payroll, HR, and scheduling together. For a small healthcare team, that focus may matter more than choosing a general payroll tool. Pricing is custom, and setup is unclear, so ask for a quote and a concrete onboarding plan before comparing it with QuickBooks.
Trade-off: Custom pricing and unclear setup make budgeting harder.
5.8/10from
Custom - Earned-wage access
DailyPayDailyPayDailyPay is not a payroll replacement: it adds earned-wage access for workers and depends on an employer’s existing payroll and HCM setup. Its standard option is listed at $0, which may help if you want this benefit without replacing payroll. Ask whether your current system can support it and what employer setup requires.
Trade-off: It depends on employer setup and existing payroll or HCM.
6.8/10from
Freefree plan - Deskless-team benefits
ZayZoonZayZoonZayZoon is also an add-on, not a payroll replacement. It is listed at $0 monthly for employers and focuses on pay access and perks for deskless teams. That may be useful if you want a benefit rather than a new payroll platform. Check employee fees and paycheck deductions, and ask how it works with your payroll system.
Trade-off: Weigh fees and paycheck deductions; it doesn’t replace payroll.
6.2/10from
Freefree plan
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.2 | $25/mo | No | Small teams already using QuickBooks | |
| 7.0 | $20/mo | No | Small businesses with straightforward payroll | |
| 6.8 | $49/mo | No | Small teams running one-state payroll | |
| 6.5 | $8/mo | No | Small teams consolidating payroll and HR | |
| 5.0 | Custom | No | Teams wanting payroll and HR together | |
| 5.8 | Custom | No | Healthcare and post-acute care providers | |
| 6.8 | Free | Yes | Employers adding an earned-wage benefit | |
| 6.2 | Free | Yes | Deskless teams offering employee benefits |
Questions people ask
What is the cheapest QuickBooks Online Payroll alternative?
SurePayroll has the lowest listed starting price among the payroll options here: $20. That is a starting price, not a confirmed total for your team. Ask the vendor for the monthly cost at your headcount and whether automatic tax filing is included for your situation.
Are there free alternatives to QuickBooks Online Payroll?
DailyPay lists a $0 standard option, and ZayZoon lists $0 monthly pricing for employers. Both are earned-wage or employee-benefit options, not full payroll replacements. ZayZoon has fees and paycheck deductions to weigh, and DailyPay depends on employer setup and an existing payroll or HCM system.
How hard is it to switch from QuickBooks Online Payroll?
Setup and migration depend on the vendor, so ask what records they can transfer and what your team must enter manually. Reddit users report frustration with QuickBooks Desktop-to-Online migration, including manual re-entry and conversions going wrong. Get the new provider’s onboarding steps before choosing a switch date.
