We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick Big Cartel.
We’d choose Big Cartel for a small team that wants a low-cost storefront: its Gold plan is free, and Platinum is $15 per month. BigCommerce is a better fit when you need its broader B2B, global-selling, or checkout tools and can budget for Core at $29 per month billed annually, or $39 month to month. Neither vendor publishes seat-based pricing, so a five-person team should confirm user access and any limits before committing.
01Side by side
| Big Cartel | BigCommerce | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Gold is free; features are limited | No free plan; 15-day trial |
| Cheapest paid plan | Platinum: $15 monthly | Core: $29 annually, $39 monthly |
| Price per seat | Seat-based pricing not published | Seat-based pricing not published |
| Cost for five | $15 monthly on Platinum; seat limits unlisted | $29 or $39 monthly on Core; seat limits unlisted |
| Setup effort | Customizable storefront templates; no coding required | Drag-and-drop editor, plus API and code access |
| Learning curve | Review ease-of-use score: 8/10 | Review ease-of-use score: 6/10 |
| Small-team integrations | Shopify, Etsy, Squarespace imports; Zapier on Diamond | API and code access; integration count not published |
| Support | Priority human support on Diamond | 24/7 chat and email on Core |
Big Cartel Choose Big Cartel if
- Choose Big Cartel if a free storefront matters most.
- Choose Big Cartel if $15 monthly is your paid-plan ceiling.
- Choose Big Cartel if you want templates without coding.
BigCommerce Choose BigCommerce if
- Choose BigCommerce if you need B2B selling tools.
- Choose BigCommerce if you need multiple languages and currencies.
- Choose BigCommerce if 24/7 Core chat and email support matters.
02What each costs a small team
Big Cartel’s pricing page lists Gold at $0, but calls its features limited and doesn’t detail them. Platinum costs $15 per month; the listed plan includes a 7-day free trial. That’s the same listed plan price whether one person or a team of five uses the store, but seat limits and per-seat charges aren’t published.
BigCommerce has no free plan and lists a 15-day trial. Core costs $39 month to month, or $29 per month billed annually. That is also the listed plan price for one person or five; seat pricing isn’t published. For a team of three to five, the difference is clear: Big Cartel Platinum is $15 monthly, while BigCommerce Core is $39 monthly or $29 with annual billing. BigCommerce Core also has a 2.0% fee on eligible open-provider order GMV.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a typical setup time, so we wouldn’t promise a store will be ready in a particular number of hours. Big Cartel offers customizable templates and says no coding is required. You’ll still need to add products and set up store details such as shipping and payments. Its product tools support physical and digital goods, and listings can be imported from Shopify, Etsy, or Squarespace.
BigCommerce offers a visual drag-and-drop storefront editor, with custom components and API and code access for teams that want them. Its checkout and sales-channel tools give a small team more to configure and consider. The platform supports payments, B2B features, and global storefronts, but confirm which features your chosen plan covers. Big Cartel’s review ease-of-use score is 8/10, compared with 6/10 for BigCommerce; those scores suggest a simpler start with Big Cartel, not a setup-time guarantee.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Big Cartel Gold is free, but the pricing page doesn’t spell out its feature limits. Platinum, at $15 monthly, lists custom domains, physical and digital products, shipping labels and order tracking, and customizable shop design. The platform also describes print-on-demand, in-person selling through its mobile app, discounts, and scheduled product drops. Check which of those are available on the plan you’re considering; Diamond is the tier that lists scheduled drops, abandoned-cart recovery, priority human support, and 7,000+ apps through Zapier.
BigCommerce Core lists up to $30,000 in trailing-12-month GMV before automatic upgrade to Growth, up to four inventory locations, and 24/7 chat and email support. The platform describes tools for checkout, B2B sales, and global storefronts, but the pricing details don’t map every platform feature to Core. Ask the vendor which features your plan includes. Core also lists a 2.0% fee on eligible open-provider order GMV.
Questions people ask
Is BigCommerce the same as Shopify?
No. BigCommerce and Shopify are separate ecommerce platforms. Big Cartel’s product details say sellers can import products from Shopify, Etsy, or Squarespace; BigCommerce is described as its own platform for building and managing online stores. Compare their current plan limits and fees before choosing.
Does BigCommerce require coding?
BigCommerce lists a visual drag-and-drop storefront editor, along with custom components and API and code access. That means coding access is available, but the vendor doesn’t state that every store needs coding. Ask BigCommerce whether your planned design and integrations require developer work.
What does BigCommerce cost for a team of five?
Core is listed at $39 per month, or $29 per month billed annually. The listed plan price doesn’t change based on team size, but BigCommerce doesn’t publish seat-based pricing or seat limits here. Confirm user access and any extra charges with the vendor.
When might a small shop outgrow Big Cartel?
Consider moving when your shop needs features not listed on your current Big Cartel plan, or when its sales and operational needs call for broader tools. Diamond lists abandoned-cart recovery, scheduled product drops, and priority human support. Compare those needs with BigCommerce’s plan limits and fees before switching.