review galore

Review · Ecommerce platforms

Big Cartel review

A low-cost storefront for independent sellers, with a useful free entry point and a clear ceiling as shops grow.

7.2/10Review Galore score

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

The bottom line

A budget-friendly storefront for sellers who can bring their own customers.

A small team does not need Big Cartel unless it wants its own online storefront. Gold is free, but its feature details are limited; Platinum, at $15 per month, lists the core shop features a growing seller may need.

Big Cartel supports physical and digital goods, print-on-demand, and in-person selling through its mobile app. It is not a marketplace, so sellers should be ready to attract their own visitors. Reddit users praise its visual design and simplicity, while one seller says they eventually outgrew it.

Good fit if

  • Independent artists and makers
  • Small shops on a tight budget
  • Sellers bringing their own traffic

Skip it if

  • Sellers relying on marketplace discovery
  • Teams needing published seat pricing
  • Growing shops needing extensive integrations
Big Cartel homepage
Big Cartel homepage, captured Nov 10, 2026

ScoresHow it rates

  • Features7
  • Ease of use8
  • Value for money8
  • Support5
  • User sentiment7

What works

  • Free Gold plan gives sellers a no-cost starting point
  • Platinum lists physical and digital product sales
  • Customizable storefront designs require no coding
  • Supports shipping labels and order tracking
  • Diamond includes abandoned cart recovery and priority human support

What doesn't

  • Gold's feature details are not listed
  • Annual billing rates are not published
  • Seat pricing for small teams is not published
  • Big Cartel does not bring marketplace discovery
  • Some growing-shop features require the $30 Diamond plan

01Who Big Cartel is for

Big Cartel is for independent sellers who want a storefront without paying for a large ecommerce platform. A solo maker or a small team of up to five can use it to list physical goods, digital files, or print-on-demand products, manage store details, and sell in person through the mobile app.

The job is straightforward: make a shop, add products, and handle sales and shipping. Store templates are customizable and require no coding, and sellers can import products from Shopify, Etsy, or Squarespace. Platinum is the clearest fit for a shop that needs custom domains, product sales, shipping labels, and order tracking. It costs $15 per month according to the pricing page.

This is a storefront, not a built-in audience. One Reddit commenter compared Big Cartel to opening your own store: sellers have control, but must drive customers themselves. If marketplace discovery is the main need, Big Cartel alone may not be enough.

02Big Cartel free plan and trial

Big Cartel's Gold plan costs $0 per month. The pricing page describes it as a free plan with limited features, but does not list the feature details. That makes Gold a low-risk way to look at the platform, but we would confirm the product, order, and storefront limits with Big Cartel before building a shop around it.

Platinum is the first paid plan with a feature list: it includes custom domains, physical and digital products, shipping labels and order tracking, and customizable shop design. The pricing page lists a 7-day free trial, then $15 per month. Diamond costs $30 per month and adds abandoned cart recovery, scheduled product drops, priority human support, and 7,000+ apps through Zapier.

The vendor lists monthly prices. An annual billing option appears, but its rates are not published.

03What a small team pays for Big Cartel

The pricing page lists Gold at $0 per month, Platinum at $15 per month, and Diamond at $30 per month. For one person, the advertised monthly plan price is the clearest figure: $15 for Platinum or $30 for Diamond. The same published plan prices apply as the reference point for a team of three or five, but Big Cartel does not publish whether team seats change the bill or how many users a plan allows. We can't give reliable per-seat totals without that information.

For a rough comparison only, dividing a $15 plan charge among three people would be $5 each, or $3 each among five; at $30, those figures are $10 and $6. Those are not confirmed per-seat prices, and the vendor does not say whether multiple team members can use an account.

No add-ons are listed in the pricing details. Annual rates are not published, even though an annual billing option appears. Ask Big Cartel about seat access and annual pricing before committing.

Full Big Cartel pricing breakdown →

04Getting started with Big Cartel

The listed setup path looks manageable for a small shop: choose a customizable storefront design, add products or import them from Shopify, Etsy, or Squarespace, then configure sales and shipping. Big Cartel says its templates require no coding. The feature list also covers digital goods, print-on-demand, discounts, scheduled product drops, shipping labels, and order tracking, depending on the plan.

The exact setup steps, time required, and learning resources are not published in the information available to buyers here. For day one, a seller should confirm which plan supports the needed product types and check how payment processing and shipping work for their orders. Specific payment methods are not listed.

Reddit users describe Big Cartel as visually appealing and simpler to start with, though that is personal feedback rather than a setup guarantee. Platinum lists product imports; Diamond lists 7,000+ apps through Zapier for shops that need more connections.

05When small teams outgrow Big Cartel

A shop may need to upgrade when it wants features that are listed only on Diamond, such as abandoned cart recovery, scheduled product drops, priority human support, or the Zapier app connections. The pricing page does not publish Gold's specific limits, product caps, or user limits, so sellers should check those before relying on the free plan. It also does not publish seat-based prices.

Another sign is a need for more discovery. Big Cartel gives sellers their own storefront; it does not put products in a marketplace search. One Reddit commenter described the tradeoff as having to drive your own customers, while Etsy can help shoppers find products there.

A Reddit seller said they moved to Shopify after outgrowing Big Cartel, after running a shop on both Big Cartel and Etsy. That is one seller's experience, not a universal point at which to switch. Consider another platform when your product, team, or traffic needs exceed what Big Cartel lists.

From the threadsWhat users say

Reddit feedback is mixed but generally positive about Big Cartel's simple feel and visual design. Sellers also point out that an independent storefront means finding your own customers, and one seller reports moving on after outgrowing the platform.

Visual appeal
I like the ease and visual design of Big cartel
r/Etsy · view thread
Simple early costs
big cartel keeps it simpler at first
r/EcommerceWebsite · view thread
Some sellers outgrow it
I recently switched from big cartel to Shopify as I outgrew the platform
r/Etsy · view thread

Questions people ask

What does Big Cartel do?

Big Cartel helps independent sellers build an online storefront, list products, and manage shop details such as shipping and payments. It supports physical and digital goods, print-on-demand, and in-person selling through its mobile app. Its listed features also include customizable templates, discounts, shipping labels, and order tracking.

Is Big Cartel free?

Yes. The pricing page lists Gold at $0 per month and describes it as a limited free plan. It does not list Gold's specific feature details or limits, so check with Big Cartel before depending on it for a particular shop size or product range.

How do I get paid on Big Cartel?

Big Cartel supports accepting payments, but the payment methods and payout timing are not published in the pricing details available here. Confirm supported processors, transaction costs, and payout schedules with Big Cartel before opening your shop.

Does Big Cartel support digital products?

Yes. The pricing page lists physical and digital products with Platinum, which costs $15 per month. Gold is described as limited, but its product details are not listed, so confirm whether the free plan covers the digital sales you need.

Can Big Cartel help customers find my shop?

Big Cartel provides a storefront, but it is not a marketplace with built-in product discovery. Sellers on Reddit say they need to direct their own customers to a Big Cartel shop. Plan to promote your store through your existing audience or other marketing channels.

Sources

  1. Big Cartel homepage
  2. Big Cartel pricing page
  3. Reddit: Can anyone tell me the benefits of using Etsy over Big cartel?
  4. Reddit: Choosing an e-commerce site
  5. Reddit: Etsy vs Personal Site (Big Cartel/Shopify)