We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A small team may not need to leave Big Cartel: its free plan and $15 starting price suit sellers who can bring their own customers. But Reddit users point to a real trade-off: a standalone shop gives you control, while marketplace discovery can bring shoppers to you. If your priority is a free start, digital sales, more selling channels, or room to grow, these alternatives are worth comparing. Check the total for your seats and required features before committing.
01Why people leave Big Cartel
You need help finding customers
Reddit commenters describe Big Cartel as a shop host: sellers have to drive traffic, unlike a marketplace where shoppers can search.
Your store has outgrown the platform
One Reddit seller said they switched to Shopify after outgrowing Big Cartel, while keeping both shops for different purposes.
You want a different cost balance
A Reddit commenter said Shopify fees can add up on small runs, while another seller weighed marketplace visibility against its charges.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Best for multichannel selling
ShopifyShopifyShopify suits small teams selling across channels or combining online and in-person sales. The listing includes a free plan and a $21 starting price; ask for the total with the staff seats and features you need. Reddit commenters call Shopify easy for newcomers, so it may be a simpler next step if you want managed commerce.
Trade-off: The starting price does not tell you the full cost for your team or add-ons.
7.7/10from
CHF 21/mofree plan - Best for digital products
PayhipPayhipPayhip is aimed at creators selling digital downloads and teams testing a product idea. It has a free plan and starts at $29, so confirm what the free tier includes before building around it. The listing describes a customizable store; it also flags that you should be comfortable bringing your own buyers.
Trade-off: It may not solve Big Cartel’s discovery problem: you still need to bring buyers.
8.0/10from
$29/mofree plan - Best for checkout tools
CartpandaCartpandaCartpanda may suit a pre-launch team selling digital products that wants checkout upsells. The listing includes a free plan and a $0.99 starting price. Before setup, check the plan details and fees against your order flow; the listing flags fees and storefront fit as potential limits.
Trade-off: Fees and storefront fit may be a concern; compare the full cost before choosing.
6.2/10from
$0.99/mofree plan - Best for digital sales
GumroadGumroadGumroad is aimed at creators selling digital downloads and small teams testing subscriptions. It has a free plan and no monthly fee, which can help a team avoid another fixed bill. The trade-off is sales-based fees, so estimate how those affect your business before choosing it over a storefront.
Trade-off: Sales-based fees can make costs less predictable as sales grow.
6.5/10from
Freefree plan - Best for indie shops
StorenvyStorenvyStorenvy fits indie sellers testing a small catalog or looking for a custom storefront. The listing includes a free plan and a $7.99 starting price. It also flags modest catalog limits and uncertain marketplace reach, so check whether the available plan fits your stock and customer-acquisition needs.
Trade-off: Catalog limits and marketplace reach may not suit a growing shop.
6.1/10from
$7.99/mofree plan - Best for store control
WooCommerceWooCommerceWooCommerce is a fit for teams already using WordPress or wanting control over their store. Its core platform is free, but the listing says owners choose a host and take on running costs. Reddit commenters describe WooCommerce as more complicated to build and maintain, so budget for setup work.
Trade-off: You own more setup and running costs than with a managed platform.
7.6/10from
Freefree plan - Best for growing stores
BigCommerceBigCommerceBigCommerce is worth a look for teams selling across markets or approaching $30,000 in annual sales. It starts at $29 and has no free plan, so it is a bigger commitment than a free option. Check the plan and sales-related costs against your needs before moving a small shop.
Trade-off: No free plan, and costs are tied partly to sales.
6.5/10from
$29/mo
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7.2 | $15/mo | Yes | Independent artists and makers | |
| 7.7 | CHF 21/mo | Yes | Small teams selling across channels | |
| 8.0 | $29/mo | Yes | Creators selling digital products | |
| 6.2 | $0.99/mo | Yes | Pre-launch sellers building a store | |
| 6.5 | Free | Yes | Creators selling digital products | |
| 6.1 | $7.99/mo | Yes | Indie sellers testing a small catalog | |
| 7.6 | Free | Yes | Teams that want store control | |
| 6.5 | $29/mo | No | B2B sellers with account pricing needs |
Questions people ask
Is Big Cartel a marketplace that brings in customers?
Reddit commenters describe Big Cartel as a shop host rather than a marketplace where shoppers search across sellers. That means a standalone shop may require you to bring your own traffic. If discovery is your main reason for leaving, confirm how each alternative helps shoppers find your products.
Which Big Cartel alternative has the lowest starting price?
Among these options, Cartpanda lists a $0.99 starting price, and it also has a free plan. That figure alone does not establish your total cost: check fees, included features, and the seats you need. Gumroad has no monthly fee, but its listing notes sales-based fees.
Which alternative is easiest for a small team to set up?
Reddit commenters describe Shopify as easy for people new to owning a website, while some say WooCommerce takes more work to build and maintain. Your setup will also depend on the store and products you need. Ask vendors what support and migration help are included before you switch.
