review galore

Head-to-head · Ecommerce platforms

Big Cartel vs Picsart

Pick Big Cartel for a storefront or Picsart for creative work. Their paid plans start at similar monthly prices, but they do different jobs.

Big Cartel

7.2/10
VS

Picsart

6.2/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

It's a split decision.

These tools solve different problems, so there isn’t one winner for every small team. Choose Big Cartel to set up a storefront and sell physical or digital goods; its Gold plan is free, and Platinum is $15/month. Choose Picsart for creating and editing images, video, and audio; Pro is $15/month or $10.50/month billed yearly. Neither vendor publishes a clear five-person seat total, so confirm team access and costs before budgeting.

01Side by side

Big CartelPicsart
Free planGold is free; listed features are limited and unspecifiedNo free plan
Cheapest paid planPlatinum: $15/monthPro: $10.50/month billed yearly
Price per seatPer-seat rate not publishedExtra Ultra seat price not published
Cost for fiveFive-person total not publishedExtra-seat cost not published
Setup effortNo-code templates; setup time not publishedCreative setup time not published
Learning curveNo-code storefront toolsAI models, workflows, and creative tools
Small-team integrationsImports Shopify, Etsy, Squarespace; print-on-demand providersPlugins for ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Cursor
SupportPriority human support on DiamondSupport details not published

Choose Big Cartel if

  • Choose Big Cartel if you need a no-code storefront.
  • Choose Big Cartel if Gold's limited free plan fits.
  • Choose Big Cartel if you sell physical or digital goods.

Choose Picsart if

  • Choose Picsart if your team creates images, video, or audio.
  • Choose Picsart if you need AI creative tools and workflows.
  • Choose Picsart if annual Pro billing suits your budget.

02What each costs a small team

Big Cartel's Gold plan is free, but the pricing page describes it as limited and doesn't list its feature details. Platinum is $15/month and Diamond is $30/month. The page shows monthly prices; annual rates aren't published. For one seller, Gold costs $0, or Platinum costs $15 if the shop needs custom domains, physical and digital products, shipping labels, order tracking, and customizable design.

Picsart has no free plan. Pro is $15/month, or $10.50/month billed yearly; Ultra is $75/month, or $60/month yearly. For one creative user, Pro is the lower-cost paid option. For a team of three to five, don't treat those prices as confirmed per-seat rates: Big Cartel doesn't publish seat pricing, and Picsart doesn't publish extra Ultra seat costs. Ask both vendors for a team quote and confirm Pro seat access before budgeting.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Big Cartel offers customizable storefront templates that don't require coding. A seller can create or import product listings, then configure store details such as shipping and payments. The vendor doesn't publish a setup-time estimate, so plan around the work involved in preparing products and store information rather than a promised launch time.

Picsart is a creative platform, not a store builder. Its tools cover image, video, and audio creation, with workflows that connect models, effects, and assets. A small team will need to choose which tools fit its creative tasks and how it wants to use them. Picsart doesn't publish a setup-time estimate either. Big Cartel's narrower storefront task may be easier to orient around; Picsart's broader set of creative tools may take more exploration. Neither vendor publishes a learning-time estimate.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Big Cartel's free Gold plan is a low-cost way to start, but the pricing page doesn't spell out its feature limits. Platinum, at $15/month, lists custom domains, physical and digital products, shipping labels, order tracking, and customizable shop design. The broader product offers product imports from Shopify, Etsy, or Squarespace, plus print-on-demand and in-person selling. The pricing page lists scheduled product drops and priority human support on Diamond, not Platinum.

Picsart's Pro plan lists 100 GB of cloud storage, bulk editing for up to 50 images, support for 3+ brand kits, and unlimited Flex.2 Klein image generations. The platform also lists background removal, creative assets, and AI tools for images, video, and audio. Ultra adds 300 GB per seat, bulk editing for up to 100 images, 10+ brand kits, and 200+ AI models. For budget-conscious teams, Pro is the lower-cost paid plan; Picsart doesn't list a free plan.

Questions people ask

Is Big Cartel a legit website?

Big Cartel is an online store builder for independent sellers. Its listed features include storefronts, product listings, shipping tools, and payment acceptance. That describes the platform, not the reliability of any particular shop using it. Before buying from a seller, check that shop's own shipping, return, and contact details.

Who is Shopify's biggest competitor?

There isn't one universal answer for every seller. Big Cartel is an option for independent sellers building a storefront, and it supports importing products from Shopify. Whether it fits better depends on the shop's needs and budget; compare the features and prices that matter to your business rather than relying on a single competitor ranking.

Does Big Cartel connect to Printify?

Big Cartel lists print-on-demand support through providers that print, pack, and ship custom designs. Its public feature details don't name Printify or confirm a direct connection. If you rely on Printify, ask Big Cartel whether the integration is direct, what setup it requires, and whether any extra fees apply.

Which is better, Etsy or Big Cartel?

They aren't the same kind of tool: Big Cartel is a storefront builder, and it lists the ability to import products from Etsy. Big Cartel may suit a seller who wants to build a separate shop; the best choice depends on where you sell and what features you need. Compare Etsy's current fees and terms before deciding.