We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Choose Big Cartel if you want a focused storefront for physical or digital goods, and its limited free plan covers your needs. Its Platinum plan is $15 per month, but contributor limits aren’t published. Choose Squarespace if your team needs five contributors or a broader business site: Core supports unlimited contributors and costs €29.04 monthly, or €20.57 per month with annual billing. Squarespace has no free plan, and its listed prices include estimated VAT.
01Side by side
| Big Cartel | Squarespace | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Gold is free; features are limited and not detailed. | No free plan; 14-day free trial. |
| Cheapest paid plan | Platinum: $15 per month. | Basic: €13.31 annually billed; €18.15 monthly. |
| Price per seat | Contributor limit and per-seat price aren't published. | Basic allows two contributors; Core allows unlimited. |
| Cost for five | Platinum is $15 monthly; contributor limit isn't published. | Core: €29.04 monthly, or €20.57 annually billed. |
| Setup effort | Set up a store, products, shipping, and payments. | Build a site, then configure selling or business tools. |
| Learning curve | Review ease-of-use score: 8 out of 10. | Review ease-of-use score: 7.5 out of 10. |
| Integrations | Product imports; Diamond adds 7,000+ Zapier apps. | Selling, scheduling, invoicing, and membership tools. |
| Support | Diamond includes priority human support. | Support plan details aren't published. |
Big Cartel Choose Big Cartel if
- Choose Big Cartel if a limited free storefront is enough.
- Choose Big Cartel if you sell physical or digital goods.
- Choose Big Cartel if you want a focused store at $15 monthly.
Squarespace Choose Squarespace if
- Choose Squarespace if five or more people need contributor access.
- Choose Squarespace if your business needs more than a store.
- Choose Squarespace if built-in scheduling or memberships matter.
02What each costs a small team
Big Cartel’s Gold plan is free, but the pricing page describes it as limited and doesn’t detail its features. Platinum is $15 per month. For one person or a team of three to five, the shop price stays $15 if the plan supports the team; Big Cartel doesn’t publish contributor limits, so confirm that before committing. Squarespace has no free plan, but lists a 14-day trial. Basic costs €18.15 monthly, or €13.31 per month with annual billing, and allows two contributors. That works for one person, but not a team of three to five. Core allows unlimited contributors: €29.04 monthly, or €20.57 per month with annual billing. At five contributors, that’s about €5.81 or €4.11 per person monthly, respectively. Squarespace lists prices in euros, including estimated VAT; the currencies aren’t directly comparable.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither company publishes how long setup takes, so plan around the work your store or site needs rather than a promised launch time. Big Cartel’s setup centers on choosing a storefront design, adding products, and configuring details such as shipping and payments. Sellers can import products from Shopify, Etsy, or Squarespace. Day to day, it also supports shipping labels, order tracking, discounts, and scheduled product drops, depending on the plan.
Squarespace offers templates, a drag-and-drop editor, and an AI website builder. A small team can build a site and then configure its store, scheduling, or other business tools as needed. Its Basic plan allows two contributors; Core removes that contributor limit. Review scores rate Big Cartel’s ease of use at 8 and Squarespace’s at 7.5, but your learning curve will depend on how much of each platform you use.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Big Cartel’s free Gold plan may suit a seller testing a small storefront, but the pricing page doesn’t spell out its feature limits. Platinum, at $15 per month, lists custom domains, physical and digital products, shipping labels and tracking, and customizable shop design. It also supports print-on-demand and in-person sales through its mobile app. Diamond costs $30 monthly and adds abandoned cart recovery, scheduled product drops, priority human support, and 7,000+ apps through Zapier.
Squarespace Basic includes two contributors, 30 minutes of video hosting, and online-store and digital-content fees of 2% and 7%. Core costs more but allows unlimited contributors, provides five hours of video hosting, and lists a 0% online-store fee and 5% digital-content fee. Both plans also sit within a website builder with templates, selling tools, and business features. Advanced is the plan that lists 0% fees for both online stores and digital content.
Questions people ask
Is Big Cartel or Squarespace cheaper for one person?
Big Cartel has the lower entry point: its Gold plan is free, and Platinum costs $15 per month. Squarespace Basic starts at €13.31 per month with annual billing or €18.15 monthly. Those prices are in different currencies, so compare the actual converted cost before choosing.
Which is better for a team of five?
Squarespace Core explicitly allows unlimited contributors and costs €29.04 monthly, or €20.57 per month with annual billing. Big Cartel doesn’t publish contributor limits, so ask whether the plan you want supports five people before counting on it for a team.
Can I sell digital products on both platforms?
Yes. Big Cartel’s Platinum plan lists physical and digital products. Squarespace Basic and Core include digital-content selling, with listed fees of 7% and 5%, respectively. Advanced lists no digital-content fee.
Does either platform offer a free trial?
Big Cartel lists a seven-day free trial for its paid plans, alongside its free Gold plan. Squarespace has no free plan but lists a 14-day free trial. Check the relevant plan terms for trial details before signing up.