We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick Buddy Punch.
For a small team that mainly needs time clocks, schedules, PTO, and payroll-ready timesheets, Buddy Punch is the clearer budget choice: its Starter plan has published per-user rates, plus a $19 monthly base fee. Choose Paycom if you need payroll and broader HR tools in one system, with employee self-service and dedicated service. Paycom’s price depends on workforce size and selected modules, so request a quote before comparing total costs.
01Side by side
| Buddy Punch | Paycom | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan; 14-day trial | No free plan; trial not published |
| Cheapest paid plan | Starter: $4.99/user/month annually | Custom quote; starting price unpublished |
| Price per seat | $4.99 annual or $5.99 monthly, plus base fee | Not published |
| Cost for five | $43.95/month equivalent, annual billing | Custom quote |
| Setup effort | Configure time clocks, locations, and schedules | Dedicated implementation team |
| Learning curve | Focused on time and attendance | Covers payroll and broader HR |
| Small-team integrations | Payroll connections and report exports | Single employee-data database |
| Support | Dedicated support on Advanced | Dedicated service team for clients |
Buddy Punch Choose Buddy Punch if
- Choose Buddy Punch if you need location-aware time clocks.
- Choose Buddy Punch if published per-user prices help you budget.
- Choose Buddy Punch if you need scheduling and PTO tracking.
Paycom Choose Paycom if
- Choose Paycom if you want payroll and HR in one system.
- Choose Paycom if employees should manage their own information.
- Choose Paycom if you want dedicated implementation and service.
02What each costs a small team
Neither product lists a free plan. Buddy Punch offers a 14-day trial; Paycom’s trial availability is not published. Buddy Punch Starter lists $4.99 per user monthly with annual billing or $5.99 with monthly billing, plus a $19 monthly base fee. With annual billing, one person works out to $23.99 per month equivalent, or $287.88 for a year. Three people cost $33.97 monthly equivalent, or $407.64 yearly; five cost $43.95 monthly equivalent, or $527.40 yearly. With monthly billing, five people cost $48.95 per month. Paycom’s pricing is customized by workforce size and selected modules. It does not publish a per-user rate or a total for one, three, or five people, so ask for a quote based on your headcount and required modules.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Buddy Punch’s core setup is centered on timekeeping: a small team needs to decide how employees punch in, which locations or groups to use, and whether to add schedules or PTO tracking. Its pricing page lists PIN and QR code punching, kiosk options on Pro, and GPS features. The vendor does not publish a setup timeframe for Starter or Pro, so ask how long configuration and employee onboarding typically take for your locations.
Paycom covers payroll and HR in one system, with employee-managed information and automated payroll workflows. It says clients receive a dedicated team for implementation, payroll processing, and ongoing support. That may help a small team that wants guided implementation, but Paycom does not publish a typical setup duration. Expect to clarify which modules are in scope and what your team must configure during the quote process.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Buddy Punch Starter includes GPS on punches, iOS and Android apps, unlimited free administrators, and one group. The pricing page lists the plan at $4.99 per user monthly with annual billing, plus the $19 monthly base fee. It is a focused starting point for recording attendance and turning punch data into timesheets. Scheduling is not included in Starter; the pricing page lists it as included with Pro, which also adds offline punching, basic geofencing, QR code and kiosk punching, and three groups. PTO tracking is part of Buddy Punch’s product capabilities.
Paycom does not list a low-cost self-serve tier. Its quote-based setup starts from a Core setup and is customized around workforce size and selected modules. Its product combines payroll automation, HR tools, employee self-service, time-off decisions, and employee data in one system. The vendor describes Beti as helping employees find and fix payroll errors before payroll runs. Ask which modules your quote includes, since module prices are not published.
Questions people ask
Who are Paycom’s main competitors?
Paycom combines payroll and HR software, while Buddy Punch is an alternative for teams focused on time clocks, attendance, schedules, and PTO. The right comparison depends on whether you need a broader HR and payroll system or mainly workforce time tracking. Paycom does not publish competitor comparisons in its pricing details.
How much does Buddy Punch cost per month?
Starter lists at $5.99 per user monthly with monthly billing, plus a $19 monthly base fee. Annual billing lowers the listed rate to $4.99 per user monthly, still with the $19 base fee. Pro and Advanced have higher per-user rates, and add-ons can change the bill.
Is Paycom an HRIS system?
Paycom combines HR and payroll tools with employee information in one database, and employees can manage their own information. That fits the core description of an HR information system. Ask Paycom which HR functions and modules are included in your quote, since its pricing is customized.
Is Paycom a legitimate company?
Paycom presents itself as a provider of HR and payroll software and says clients receive a dedicated service team. Those product details alone do not establish a company’s legal or financial standing. Before signing, review the contract, service terms, data handling, and company information directly with the vendor.