We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Choose Buddy Punch if your team needs GPS punches, payroll-ready timesheets, and attendance tools for people working across locations. Choose When I Work if scheduling and team messaging matter most and you can confirm the added cost of time tracking. For five people, Buddy Punch Starter is $48.95 per month before add-ons; When I Work Essentials is $12.50 before its separately priced time-tracking add-on. Neither vendor lists a free plan, and both offer a 14-day trial.
01Side by side
| Buddy Punch | When I Work | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan; 14-day trial | No free plan; 14-day trial |
| Cheapest paid plan | Starter: $4.99 annual; $5.99 monthly | Essentials: $2.50 monthly |
| Price per seat | Starter, plus $19 monthly base fee | Essentials; time tracking costs extra |
| Cost for five | $48.95/month, before add-ons | $12.50/month, before time tracking |
| Setup effort | Setup time not published | Setup time not published |
| Learning curve | Training details not published | Training details not published |
| Small-team integrations | Payroll export or connection; specifics not listed | API access on Premium; other details not listed |
| Support | Dedicated support on Advanced | Support terms not published |
Buddy Punch Choose Buddy Punch if
- Choose Buddy Punch if GPS punches matter across job sites.
- Choose Buddy Punch if payroll-ready timesheets are a priority.
- Choose Buddy Punch if you need PTO and attendance tracking.
When I Work Choose When I Work if
- Choose When I Work if scheduling and messaging come first.
- Choose When I Work if you need multi-location schedules.
- Choose When I Work if you can confirm time-tracking add-on costs.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor lists a free plan; both offer a 14-day trial. Buddy Punch Starter is $5.99 per user monthly, plus a $19 monthly base fee. That makes one seat $24.99/month, three seats $36.97, and five seats $48.95. With annual billing, the listed $4.99/user/month rate plus the base fee works out to $287.88 for one seat or $527.40 for five over 12 months. When I Work Essentials is $2.50/user/month: $2.50 for one seat, $7.50 for three, and $12.50 for five. Annual rates aren't published. Essentials doesn't include the separately priced Time Tracking & Attendance add-on, and When I Work doesn't publish that price. Ask for a quote before comparing the full cost of a working time clock.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate, so we wouldn't budget a specific number of hours based on the pricing pages alone. The setup work depends on what you need to configure. For Buddy Punch, that may include employees, groups, locations, punch methods, and any GPS or geofencing rules your team needs. Its Starter plan includes one group; Pro lists three groups and scheduling. For When I Work, expect to set up employees, locations, schedules, and shift rules that match how you staff the week. Its plans list schedule templates, multi-location scheduling, and team messaging on Essentials, with scheduling rules and role permissions on Pro. Before choosing, check whether your current payroll process connects to Buddy Punch and get When I Work's time-tracking add-on price. Those details affect both setup and daily routines.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Buddy Punch Starter focuses on clocking and attendance. The plan lists GPS on punches, iOS and Android apps, unlimited free administrators, and one group. Its timesheets come from punch data, with reports to export or payroll software to connect. Scheduling costs an extra $1 per user monthly unless you move to Pro, which includes it. Basic geofencing and offline punching are also listed on Pro, not Starter.
When I Work Essentials centers on scheduling and communication. It lists auto scheduling, multi-week and multi-location schedules, templates, and team messaging. Its Time Tracking & Attendance tool is a separate add-on, and the vendor doesn't publish its price. So Essentials' low seat price isn't the full cost if your team needs a time clock. Pro adds scheduling rules, role permissions, custom reporting, and time-zone toggling. For a small team, the practical split is time-clock-first versus schedule-first.
Questions people ask
What is the best time card app?
It depends on what your team needs the app to do. Buddy Punch is the closer fit if you need GPS punches and timesheets built from clock-in data. When I Work Essentials focuses on schedules and messaging; time tracking is a separately priced add-on. Get that add-on price before comparing total costs.
Is it clock in or punch in?
Both phrases refer to recording the start of a work shift. Buddy Punch calls its feature clocking in and out, while the plan details also refer to punches. When comparing tools, check how employees will record time and whether the plan includes the clock-in methods your team needs.
Can Buddy Punch track your location?
Yes. Buddy Punch Starter lists GPS on punches. The pricing page lists Real-Time GPS as a $2 per user monthly add-on, included with Advanced. Pro lists basic geofencing, while Starter does not list it as an included feature. Check the plan details against your location-tracking needs.
Is When I Work app legit?
When I Work is workforce management software for hourly teams, with scheduling, time tracking, and team messaging among its listed tools. It offers a 14-day trial and lists Essentials at $2.50 per user monthly. Its time-tracking add-on price isn't published, so ask the vendor for the full cost before signing up.