We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Choose Checkr if your small team needs background checks: Workforce Basic costs $29.99 per report, and a free Personal Profile is available for individuals—not business screening. Choose Paycom if you need payroll and HR in one system, employee self-service, and a dedicated implementation team. Paycom’s price is custom, so you’ll need a quote even for a small team. These tools solve different problems; the right choice depends on whether screening or HR and payroll is your priority.
01Side by side
| Checkr | Paycom | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Free Personal Profile; business screening costs per report. | No free plan. |
| Cheapest paid plan | Workforce Basic: $29.99 per report. | Custom quote; starting price isn't published. |
| Price per seat | Per report, not per seat. | Custom monthly quote; per-seat price isn't published. |
| Cost for a team of 5 | Five Basic reports: $149.95, one per person. | Quote required; five-person cost isn't published. |
| Setup effort | Setup time isn't published; applicant steps are guided. | Dedicated team handles implementation. |
| Learning curve | Not published. | Not published. |
| Small-team integrations | Enterprise lists 200+ ATS integrations. | Integration details aren't published. |
| Support | Dedicated support listed for Tenant Business/Partner. | Dedicated team provides ongoing support. |
Checkr Choose Checkr if
- Choose Checkr if you need per-report workforce screening.
- Choose Checkr if you want a listed price before ordering.
- Choose Checkr if applicants need guided screening steps.
Paycom Choose Paycom if
- Choose Paycom if you need payroll and HR together.
- Choose Paycom if employee self-service matters.
- Choose Paycom if you want dedicated implementation and ongoing support.
02What each costs a small team
Checkr’s free Personal Profile is for people sharing verified credentials, not a free business screening plan. For hiring, Workforce Basic is $29.99 per report; it includes an SSN trace, sex offender registry, global watchlist, and national criminal search. If one person needs one report, budget $29.99; five reports for five people cost $149.95 before applicable court or database fees. That’s report volume, not seat pricing. Paycom has no free plan or published starting amount. Its pricing page lists a customized monthly quote based on workforce size and selected modules, starting from a Core setup. One employee and a five-person team both need a quote; Paycom doesn’t publish a per-seat or five-person total. Ask which modules and implementation costs the quote includes.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline or a learning-curve rating, so ask for a realistic schedule before committing. Checkr’s applicant guidance walks people through screening steps and notifies businesses when results are ready. Your team still needs to choose a screening package that fits the role and decide how it will review results. Paycom says a dedicated team supports implementation, payroll processing, and ongoing service. Its single database lets employee data changes populate throughout the software, while employee self-service shifts information entry and management to staff. Paycom’s modules are selected to fit the organization, so ask which ones are included and what configuration your team must handle. For either vendor, confirm who owns setup tasks and what support continues after launch.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Checkr’s lowest-priced workforce option, Basic, is $29.99 per report. The pricing page lists an SSN trace, sex offender registry, global watchlist search, and national criminal search. It doesn’t include the identity verification and unlimited county criminal search listed with Workforce Essential at $59.99 per report. Workforce Complete costs $94.99 per report and adds unlimited state and federal criminal searches. A free Personal Profile is for sharing verified credentials; it isn’t a free employer screening package. Paycom doesn’t publish a low-cost tier or a module-by-module feature map with its quote. The company describes payroll automation, employee self-service, HR tools, time-off decisions, and AI access to employee data, but ask which of these are included in your Core setup and quote. Paycom’s published pricing is customized by workforce size and selected modules.
Questions people ask
Does Checkr actually do background checks?
Yes. Checkr sells workforce background-screening reports, including Workforce Basic at $29.99 per report. That package lists an SSN trace, sex offender registry, global watchlist, and national criminal search. Broader tiers add identity verification and county, state, or federal searches.
Is BackgroundChecks.com a legitimate company?
We can’t vouch for BackgroundChecks.com based on Checkr’s services. Before buying from any screening provider, confirm its legal business name, contact information, report sources, applicant consent process, dispute process, and full fees. Ask for those details in writing before submitting applicant information.
Does Paycom do background checks?
Paycom is described as HR and payroll software, with payroll automation, employee self-service, and HR tools. Background checks aren’t listed among its stated features. Ask Paycom whether it offers screening directly or through an integration, and whether that service adds a separate charge.
What is a red flag in a background check?
A record that doesn’t match an applicant’s identity or application is a reason to verify details, not to assume the report is conclusive. Checkr says human experts support report accuracy and compliance. Ask the screening provider how to dispute or correct a report before making a decision.