We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
These tools solve different problems, so a small team should choose based on its need. Consider Cisco Umbrella if you want DNS-layer security or secure internet access and can get a quote for the right plan. OpenStack fits teams that need to manage cloud infrastructure and have the technical capacity to run it. Its core software is free to download and self-host, but that does not make operating it cost-free. Neither tool has a published per-seat price or a reliable five-person total here.
01Side by side
| Cisco Umbrella | OpenStack | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan; listed plans include a 14-day trial | Core software is free to download and self-host |
| Cheapest paid plan | DNS Security Essentials; price not published | No paid plan listed for core software |
| Price per seat | Not published | Not published |
| Cost for a team of 5 | Not published; request a quote | Software is free; operating costs vary |
| Setup effort | Setup effort is unclear | Requires technical time to operate |
| Learning curve | Review ease-of-use score: 5 | Review ease-of-use score: 3 |
| Integrations a small team needs | Specific integrations not published | Manage resources through APIs or a dashboard |
| Support | Review support score: 6 | Review support score: 4 |
Cisco Umbrella Choose Cisco Umbrella if
- Choose Cisco Umbrella if DNS-layer security is your priority.
- Choose Cisco Umbrella if you need secure internet access.
- Choose Cisco Umbrella if you can get pricing from Cisco.
OpenStack Choose OpenStack if
- Choose OpenStack if you need to manage cloud infrastructure.
- Choose OpenStack if free, self-hosted core software fits.
- Choose OpenStack if your team can handle technical operations.
02What each costs a small team
Cisco Umbrella has no free plan listed, but its plans include a 14-day free trial. Cisco lists DNS Security Essentials as the entry option for DNS-layer security and SIG Essentials for secure internet access; prices for both are not published. The monthly and annual billing prices are also not published, so we can’t calculate a one-person or three-to-five-person bill. Ask Cisco for a quote that specifies seats, billing term, and any required add-ons.
OpenStack’s core software is free to download and self-host. There’s no paid plan or per-seat price listed for it, but a team still needs to account for the technical time involved in running it. The software price for one person or five people is zero; the total operating cost is not published. Don’t treat that as a complete five-person cost.
03Setup and day-to-day use
The time to get Cisco Umbrella running is not published, and the available details don’t establish a specific setup process. Its review rates ease of use at 5, but that score alone won’t tell a small team how much configuration or administration it needs. Before buying, ask Cisco what setup involves for the plan you’re considering and who will manage it.
OpenStack is a set of software components for managing cloud infrastructure. Per its description, teams manage compute, storage, and networking through APIs or a dashboard, and can deploy on-premises, in public clouds, or at the edge. The setup time is not published. Its review gives ease of use a score of 3 and notes that the real cost is technical time to run it. A small team should plan for someone to own that operation; the exact staffing and configuration needs depend on its deployment.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
For Cisco Umbrella, the entry plan names indicate two starting points: DNS Security Essentials for DNS-layer security and SIG Essentials for secure internet access. SIG Essentials includes 500 file-inspection sandbox samples per day, and both listed plans include a 14-day trial. DNS Security Advantage and SIG Advantage are also listed; SIG Advantage includes unlimited file-inspection sandbox samples. Prices for these plans are not published. Cisco’s homepage describes broader security capabilities, but does not identify Umbrella by name, so don’t assume those homepage capabilities are included in an Umbrella plan without asking Cisco.
OpenStack’s free core software manages pools of compute, storage, and networking resources. Teams can use APIs or a dashboard, and additional components provide orchestration beyond standard infrastructure-as-a-service functions. It supports on-premises, public-cloud, and edge deployments. The core is free to download and self-host, but operating it takes technical time. The available pricing details don’t identify paid tiers, so confirm any support or service needs before choosing it.
Questions people ask
What does Cisco Umbrella cost?
Cisco’s listed DNS Security and SIG plans have no published monthly or annual prices. The plans include a 14-day free trial, but that is not a permanent free plan. Ask Cisco for a quote covering the specific plan, number of seats, and billing term your team needs.
Is Cisco Umbrella being discontinued?
Cisco’s homepage does not name Umbrella, so it does not confirm the product’s current status. The listed pricing information includes Umbrella plan names, but that alone doesn’t establish whether the service is being discontinued. Check Cisco’s current product catalog or ask Cisco sales for confirmation.
Is Cisco Umbrella a DNS?
Cisco lists DNS Security Essentials and DNS Security Advantage for teams needing DNS-layer security. Those plan names indicate a security offering that works at the DNS layer; they don’t describe DNS itself. Ask Cisco which plan fits your network and what it covers.
What is the difference between Cisco Umbrella and Cisco Secure Access?
The available plan details identify Umbrella options for DNS security and secure internet access, but don’t establish how those offerings differ from Cisco Secure Access. Ask Cisco to map the products, features, and licensing to your use case before choosing or budgeting.