review galore

Head-to-head · Payroll tools

Gusto vs SurePayroll

For a small team focused on payroll, SurePayroll starts cheaper. Gusto costs more but bundles broader HR tools on its platform.

Gusto

6.8/10
VS

SurePayroll

7.0/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick SurePayroll.

Choose SurePayroll if your main need is payroll and you want a lower starting price: its listed Full Service plan costs $29 monthly plus $7 per employee, though another listed price is $39 plus $7 per employee. Choose Gusto if you want payroll alongside broader HR features. Its Simple plan costs $49 monthly plus $6 per person. Neither has a free plan, and Gusto’s base fee makes it cost more for a five-person team.

01Side by side

GustoSurePayroll
Free planNo free planNo free plan
Cheapest paid planSimple: $49 monthly plus $6/personNo Tax Filing: $20 monthly plus $4/employee
Price per seat$6/person on Simple$4 or $7/employee
Cost for five$79/month on Simple$40 No Tax Filing; $64 Full Service
Setup effortSetup time not publishedSetup time not published
Learning curveNot publishedNot published
Small-team integrationsBroker integration; $6/eligible employee monthlyAccounting and timeclock integrations available
SupportPremium account support on PremiumCustomer support listed on No Tax Filing

Choose Gusto if

  • Choose Gusto if you want payroll and broader HR tools together.
  • Choose Gusto if you need multi-state payroll on Plus.
  • Choose Gusto if basic PTO policies and holiday pay matter.

Choose SurePayroll if

  • Choose SurePayroll if the lowest listed payroll price matters most.
  • Choose SurePayroll if you want Full Service tax filing and deposits.
  • Choose SurePayroll if you need W-2 and 1099 contractor support.

02What each costs a small team

Neither vendor lists a free plan. Gusto Simple is $49 per month plus $6 per person: that works out to $55 for one person, $67 for three and $79 for five. SurePayroll lists No Tax Filing at $20 per month plus $4 per employee, or $24 for one and $40 for five. The employer handles tax filing and deposits on that plan.

For tax handling, SurePayroll Full Service is listed at $29 per month plus $7 per employee: $36 for one or $64 for five. The pricing also lists alternate base prices of $39 for Full Service and $29 for No Tax Filing, so confirm your monthly quote. Gusto Plus starts at $80 plus $12 per person, and includes multi-state payroll. Prices are monthly; annual prices are not published.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes how long setup takes, so we would not plan around a specific number of hours or days. Both are payroll services, and you will need to decide who is paid and which payroll tasks the software handles. SurePayroll’s No Tax Filing plan leaves tax filing and deposits to the employer; Full Service handles payroll tax filing and deposits. Gusto Simple lists tax filings and payments as included.

For routine use, SurePayroll lists unlimited payroll runs, automatic scheduling and online access to payroll records. Gusto lists payroll automation and tax payments, with time tracking and scheduling on Plus rather than Simple. Neither vendor publishes a learning-curve estimate. Before choosing, confirm which plan fits your payroll schedule, tax responsibilities and employee setup; ask the vendor about any setup help or fees you need.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Gusto Simple includes unlimited payrolls, tax filings and payments, basic PTO policies and holiday pay. Gusto’s platform also offers hiring, benefits, time tracking and contractor management, but the pricing lists time tracking and scheduling on Plus, not Simple. Check which features are included in your chosen plan before budgeting for add-ons.

SurePayroll’s cheapest listed plan, No Tax Filing, includes unlimited payroll runs and customer support, but your business handles tax filing and deposits. Full Service adds tax filing and deposits, free two-day direct deposit, and support for W-2 employees and 1099 contractors. Both SurePayroll plans list per-employee charges, and its pricing also lists alternate base prices, so verify the amount before signing up. SurePayroll offers accounting software integration for $4.99 per month; timeclock integration starts at $5 per month plus $3 per employee.

Questions people ask

Does Gusto or SurePayroll have a free plan?

Neither vendor lists a free plan. Gusto Simple starts at $49 per month plus $6 per person. SurePayroll lists No Tax Filing at $20 per month plus $4 per employee, with alternate pricing also shown. Confirm SurePayroll’s current monthly price directly before choosing.

Is Gusto a good payroll service for a small team?

Gusto may suit a small team that wants payroll alongside HR tools. Its Simple plan lists unlimited payrolls, tax filings and payments, basic PTO policies and holiday pay. Its platform also offers hiring, benefits and contractor tools, but check which features are included in the plan you select.

Is Gusto cheaper than SurePayroll?

For a five-person team, Gusto Simple calculates to $79 per month. SurePayroll calculates to $40 for No Tax Filing or $64 for Full Service using its first listed prices. SurePayroll also lists alternate base prices, so check the quote and compare whether you need tax filing handled.

Does SurePayroll file payroll taxes?

Yes, on Full Service: SurePayroll lists payroll taxes filed and deposited, plus free two-day direct deposit. Its cheaper No Tax Filing plan leaves tax filing and deposits to the employer. The vendor also lists alternate Full Service base pricing, so confirm the current plan cost.