review galore

Head-to-head · Payroll tools

Gusto vs When I Work

Gusto is for payroll and HR; When I Work is for hourly scheduling. Here’s what each costs a small team.

Gusto

6.8/10
VS

When I Work

6.2/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

It's a split decision.

For a small team that needs payroll, tax filings, and HR in one place, choose Gusto; its Simple plan starts at $49 monthly plus $6 per person. If your main problem is building hourly schedules and coordinating shifts, When I Work is far cheaper at $2.50 per user on Essentials. Neither has a free plan, though When I Work offers a 14-day trial. These tools solve different jobs, so a team needing both payroll and shift management should confirm a payroll connection before committing.

01Side by side

GustoWhen I Work
Free planNo free plan; trial availability isn't publishedNo free plan; 14-day trial
Cheapest paid planSimple: $49 monthly plus $6 per personEssentials: $2.50 per user monthly
Price per seat$6 per person, plus $49 base fee$2.50 per user on Essentials
Five-person monthly cost$79 on Simple$12.50 on Essentials
Setup timeVendor doesn't publish a typical setup timeVendor doesn't publish a typical setup time
Learning curvePayroll, HR, and benefits in one platformFocused on hourly scheduling and messaging
Small-team integrationsCheck payroll and accounting compatibilityCheck payroll and accounting compatibility
SupportReview support score: 4/10Review support score: 4/10

Choose Gusto if

  • Choose Gusto if you need payroll tax filings and payments.
  • Choose Gusto if HR, benefits, and contractor tools belong together.
  • Choose Gusto if payroll matters more than the lowest subscription.

Choose When I Work if

  • Choose When I Work if hourly scheduling is your main need.
  • Choose When I Work if shift messaging and swaps matter.
  • Choose When I Work if keeping monthly software costs low matters.

02What each costs a small team

Neither product has a free plan. When I Work offers a 14-day trial; Gusto doesn't publish trial availability. Gusto's entry Simple plan is $49 monthly plus $6 per person. That makes one employee $55, three $67, and five $79 per month. Its base fee matters most when your team is tiny.

When I Work Essentials costs $2.50 per user monthly: $2.50 for one, $7.50 for three, or $12.50 for five. Both vendors offer monthly billing; When I Work also offers annual billing, but its annual rate isn't published. Gusto's listed plans are month-to-month. These totals compare listed subscription charges only; they don't include taxes, add-ons, or outside benefit premiums.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a typical setup time, so we wouldn't promise a same-day launch. Gusto's payroll and tax-filing scope means a buyer should allow time to enter business and payroll details and review the relevant tax setup; benefits and HR needs can add configuration. When I Work's start-up work centers on employee availability and eligibility, locations, schedule templates, and messaging. Its auto-scheduling feature matches shifts to eligibility, availability, and preferences.

Day to day, Gusto is the payroll home, while When I Work is a scheduling and team-messaging workspace. Neither vendor publishes a formal learning-curve measure. When I Work is more focused; Gusto covers more functions, so how much there is to learn depends on which parts your team uses.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

On Gusto Simple, the pricing page lists unlimited payrolls, tax filings and payments, basic PTO policies, and holiday pay. Gusto's broader product also covers hiring, benefits, time tracking, and contractor payments, but its listed Simple inclusions don't promise all of those features. Time tracking and scheduling are listed with Plus, at $80 monthly plus $12 per person.

When I Work Essentials includes auto scheduling, multi-week and multi-location schedules, schedule templates, and team messaging. It's a better fit if the daily job is covering shifts, not running payroll. Time Tracking & Attendance is an add-on, and When I Work doesn't publish its price. Pro adds scheduling rules, role permissions, custom reporting, and time-zone toggles, so consider the upgrade only if those controls matter.

Questions people ask

Which is better for a small business?

It depends on the job you need done. Gusto is the better fit when payroll, tax filings, and HR are the priority. When I Work is a better fit when you mainly need hourly schedules, shift coordination, and team messaging. Their entry plans serve different needs, so compare the work your team needs covered.

How much does each cost for five people?

Gusto Simple comes to $79 monthly for five people: its $49 base fee plus $6 per person. When I Work Essentials comes to $12.50 monthly at $2.50 per user. Those totals reflect listed subscription prices and exclude any add-ons or other costs.

Do Gusto or When I Work have a free plan?

Neither lists a free plan. When I Work offers a 14-day free trial. Gusto doesn't publish trial availability, so ask Gusto whether a trial or other evaluation option is available before signing up.

Does When I Work Essentials include time tracking?

Time Tracking & Attendance is listed as an add-on, separate from the Essentials plan, and When I Work doesn't publish its price. Ask the vendor for the current add-on cost and confirm whether it covers the clock-in and attendance features your team needs.