We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
For a small team that needs payroll across multiple states, OnPay is the better fit: its $49 base plan includes multi-state payroll, tax filings, and year-end forms. Choose Gusto if you want basic PTO and holiday pay in the cheapest plan, or expect to add time tracking and scheduling with Plus. Both charge $49 plus $6 per person monthly at the entry level, and neither offers a free plan. OnPay also lists a one-month free trial.
01Side by side
| OnPay | Gusto | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan; one-month free trial | No free plan |
| Cheapest paid plan | $49 base + $6/worker monthly | $49 base + $6/person monthly |
| Price per seat | $6 per worker, plus base fee | $6 per person, plus base fee |
| Cost for five | $79/month | $79/month |
| Setup effort | Free data migration; setup time not published | Setup time not published |
| Learning curve | No published learning-curve measure | No published learning-curve measure |
| Small-team integrations | Accounting, 401(k), HR, and compliance tools | Time tracking syncs hours with payroll |
| Support | Live HR support by phone, chat, and email | Premium support on Premium; entry-plan details not published |
OnPay Choose OnPay if
- Choose OnPay if you run payroll in multiple states.
- Choose OnPay if free data migration matters.
- Choose OnPay if you want live HR support by phone, chat, or email.
Gusto Choose Gusto if
- Choose Gusto if basic PTO and holiday pay belong in your entry plan.
- Choose Gusto if you want time tracking and scheduling in Plus.
- Choose Gusto if contractor invoice management in Plus fits your workflow.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor offers a free plan. OnPay lists a one-month free trial; Gusto’s pricing page doesn’t list a free trial. Both entry plans cost $49 per month plus $6 per worker or person, with month-to-month billing listed for Gusto and no annual rate published for either.
For one person, that comes to $55 per month on either plan. For a three-person team, expect $67; for five people, $79. These totals use the listed base fee and per-person charge, before benefits or other add-ons. OnPay’s payroll price includes tax filings and year-end forms. Gusto Simple includes tax filings and payments. If you need more than payroll, compare the add-ons: OnPay lists HR at $15 base plus $2 per worker, while Gusto Plus costs $80 base plus $12 per person.
03Setup and day-to-day use
OnPay says it provides free data migration for businesses switching providers. The time needed to migrate or get payroll running isn’t published, so ask how long your records, tax details, and pay schedules will take to configure. Gusto’s pricing page doesn’t publish a setup timeline either.
Both services automate payroll calculations, tax filings, and payments. Your setup work will still include entering employee and pay details and choosing the payroll schedule and relevant tax settings. OnPay lists live HR support by phone, chat, and email; Gusto’s Premium plan lists HR guidance and tools, but support details for Simple aren’t published.
Neither vendor publishes a learning-curve measure. Gusto describes onboarding checklists and digital signatures for hiring, while OnPay lists customizable onboarding workflows and eSignature templates. Those tools help with employee onboarding, not necessarily the initial software setup.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
OnPay’s $49-base Payroll Essentials plan includes unlimited pay runs and schedules, W-2s and 1099s, year-end filings, and federal, state, and local tax filings. It also includes payroll in any number of states. That makes the entry plan useful for a small team with workers across state lines.
Gusto Simple costs the same $49 base plus $6 per person. Its listed features include unlimited monthly payrolls, tax filings and payments, basic PTO policies, and holiday pay. The plan is described for small teams running payroll in one state. Multi-state payroll, time tracking, scheduling, and contractor invoice management are listed with Plus, at $80 base plus $12 per person monthly.
Both products cover core payroll. OnPay’s listed extras include benefits administration and time tracking as add-ons; Gusto also offers benefits and time tracking, with some features and fees depending on plan or add-on. Check the specific add-on price before budgeting.
Questions people ask
Is OnPay cheaper than Gusto for a small team?
Not at the entry level. Both list a $49 monthly base fee plus $6 per worker or person. That works out to $55 for one person, $67 for three, and $79 for five, before add-ons or benefits premiums.
Which is better for multi-state payroll?
OnPay includes payroll in any number of states with Payroll Essentials, alongside federal, state, and local tax filings. Gusto lists multi-state payroll with Plus, not Simple. Compare the full Plus cost if your team needs Gusto.
Does OnPay or Gusto have a free plan?
Neither vendor lists a free plan. OnPay lists a one-month free trial. Gusto’s pricing page doesn’t list a free trial, so ask Gusto whether a trial or demo is available before signing up.
Which service includes time tracking in its cheaper plan?
Neither entry plan lists time tracking as included. OnPay offers it through add-ons, including HR + Time Tracking at $21 base plus $4 per worker. Gusto lists time tracking and scheduling with Plus, priced at $80 base plus $12 per person monthly.