We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick OnPay.
For a small team watching monthly costs, we’d start with OnPay: its payroll plan lists a $49 base fee plus $6 per worker, and includes tax filings and unlimited pay runs. Paycom may suit teams wanting employee self-service, payroll automation, and a dedicated implementation team, but it doesn’t publish a standard price. Neither lists a free plan. Ask Paycom for a quote before comparing the full cost, and check which modules it includes.
01Side by side
| OnPay | Paycom | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan; one-month trial | No free plan; trial not published |
| Cheapest paid plan | Payroll Essentials: $49 base + $6/worker | Custom quote; price not published |
| Price per seat | $6/worker, plus $49 monthly base | Not published; ask for a quote |
| Cost for five workers | $79/month for payroll | Custom quote; total not published |
| Setup effort | Free data migration; setup time not published | Dedicated implementation team; timing not published |
| Learning curve | Review score: 7/10 for ease | Review score: 4.5/10 for ease |
| Small-team integrations | Accounting, 401(k), HR, and compliance tools | Integration options not published |
| Support | Live HR help by phone, chat, and email | Dedicated team for implementation and ongoing support |
OnPay Choose OnPay if
- Choose OnPay if you need published payroll pricing.
- Choose OnPay if tax filings across states matter.
- Choose OnPay if you want accounting and 401(k) connections.
Paycom Choose Paycom if
- Choose Paycom if you want employee-entered HR and payroll data.
- Choose Paycom if you want Beti to flag payroll errors.
- Choose Paycom if a dedicated implementation team matters.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor lists a free plan. OnPay offers a one-month free trial; Paycom’s trial terms are not published. The OnPay pricing page lists Payroll Essentials at $49 per month plus $6 per worker, with monthly pricing and no published annual rate. That makes one worker $55 per month and three workers $67. For five workers, budget $79 per month for payroll. These figures are the base plan, not optional HR, time-tracking, or benefit costs.
Paycom uses custom quotes based on workforce size and selected modules. It doesn’t publish a per-worker rate or a price for a one-person or five-person team. Ask for a quote that spells out the modules, implementation, and ongoing fees before comparing it with OnPay’s payroll price.
03Setup and day-to-day use
OnPay says it includes free data migration for businesses switching providers, and lists customizable onboarding workflows, eSignature templates, and personnel management tools. It doesn’t publish how long setup takes, so ask what information your team must provide and when payroll can start. Its listed live HR guidance is available by phone, chat, and email.
Paycom says clients get a dedicated team for implementation, payroll processing, and ongoing support. It doesn’t publish a standard setup timeline, so ask who handles your data, configuration, and first payroll run. For daily work, Paycom’s employee self-service lets staff manage their own HR and payroll information. Its Beti tool lets employees review payroll and find or fix errors before a run. Review scores favor OnPay for ease of use, but neither vendor publishes a learning-time estimate.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
OnPay’s published Payroll Essentials plan includes W-2s, 1099s, year-end filings, unlimited pay runs and schedules, federal, state, and local tax filings, and workers in any number of states. It also automates payroll calculations and payments. Those are useful basics for a small team that needs payroll and tax work handled in one service.
HR and time tracking have separate listed prices: HR is $15 base plus $2 per worker; HR + Time Tracking is $21 base plus $4 per worker. Bundled HR is $71 base plus $1 per worker, while Bundled HR + Time Tracking is $81 base plus $4 per worker. Benefits integration and administration are listed as free, but plan premiums cost extra.
Paycom’s quote is customized around the selected modules, starting from a Core setup. Its feature set includes payroll automation, employee self-service, time-off decisions, and a single database. Module-specific prices aren’t published, so confirm what the quote includes.
Questions people ask
Does OnPay have a free plan?
No. The pricing page lists no free plan, but does list a one-month free trial. Payroll Essentials costs $49 per month plus $6 per worker after that. Ask OnPay what the trial includes and when billing begins.
Does Paycom have a free plan?
Paycom does not list a free plan. Its pricing is quote-based, and its trial terms are not published. Ask its sales team whether a trial is available and what modules or services a quote covers.
How much does Paycom cost for five employees?
Paycom does not publish a standard five-employee price. Its quote is customized by workforce size and selected modules. Request a quote for your headcount and confirm the included modules and ongoing costs before comparing it with OnPay.
Does Paycom do background checks?
Background checks are not listed among Paycom’s described features or priced modules. Ask Paycom whether it offers background checks directly or through an integration, and whether that service carries an additional charge.