We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick OnTheClock.
Choose OnTheClock if your 1–10-person team mainly needs time tracking, schedules, PTO and a clear starting price: five people cost $25 monthly before payroll. Adding payroll brings that listed total to $95 monthly for five paid employees. Choose Paycom if you want payroll and broader HR in one system, employee self-service and a dedicated implementation and support team, and can get a custom quote first. Neither has a published free plan, and Paycom’s price must be confirmed directly.
01Side by side
| OnTheClock | Paycom | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan | No free plan |
| Cheapest paid plan | $4/employee monthly, plus $5 base | Custom quote; starting price not published |
| Price per seat | $4 monthly per employee for time and PTO | Not published; quote depends on workforce and modules |
| Cost for a team of 5 | $25/month for time tracking and PTO | Custom quote required |
| Setup effort | Configure time, schedules, PTO and payroll integrations | Dedicated implementation team; timeline not published |
| Learning curve | 7/10 ease-of-use review score | 4.5/10 ease-of-use review score |
| Integrations a small team needs | Payroll integrations included with time plan | Confirm needed modules and integrations in quote |
| Support | 5/10 support review score | Dedicated ongoing support team |
OnTheClock Choose OnTheClock if
- Choose OnTheClock if you need time tracking, schedules and PTO.
- Choose OnTheClock if you want a published starting price.
- Choose OnTheClock if payroll integrations suit your existing setup.
Paycom Choose Paycom if
- Choose Paycom if you want payroll and HR in one system.
- Choose Paycom if employee self-service is a priority.
- Choose Paycom if dedicated implementation and ongoing support matter.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor lists a free plan. OnTheClock’s lowest published option is Employee Time Tracking, Scheduling & PTO Management at $4 per employee monthly, plus a $5 monthly base fee. That makes one person $9/month ($108/year), three $17/month ($204/year), and five $25/month ($300/year). The listed price is monthly; no annual price is listed. If you add OnTheClock Payroll, the added charge is $6 per paid employee monthly plus a $40 base: time tracking plus payroll totals $55/month for one paid employee or $95/month for five.
Paycom publishes no starting price or per-seat rate. Its price is a custom quote based on workforce size and selected modules, so ask for both a one-person and a five-person quote, including the modules and any implementation fees. A five-person budget cannot be calculated from its published pricing.
03Setup and day-to-day use
OnTheClock does not publish a setup timeline. A small team will need to configure employee access, schedules, PTO rules and balances, clock-in methods and location controls, then connect payroll if it uses the payroll add-on. Ask whether employee and PTO data can be imported, and what your team must prepare before switching.
Paycom describes a dedicated team for implementation, payroll processing and ongoing support, but does not publish an implementation timeline. Ask how long setup usually takes for your selected modules and who handles data entry and employee training. For day-to-day learning, the review ease-of-use scores are 7/10 for OnTheClock and 4.5/10 for Paycom. Those ratings are directional, not a promise for your staff; Paycom’s wider HR and payroll scope may also mean more choices to configure.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
OnTheClock’s $4-per-employee time plan includes time tracking, scheduling, PTO management, GPS, geofencing, location controls and payroll integrations, plus the $5 monthly base fee. Employees can clock in from phones, desktops, tablets or kiosks. Managers can review and approve timecards, and the product includes scheduling reminders and PTO requests. Payroll is an added charge: its listed plan adds direct deposit, unlimited payroll runs, tax filing and compliance, and W-2s and 1099s.
Paycom’s price starts with a customized Core setup, with modules selected to fit the organization. Its payroll and HR features include Beti payroll automation, employee self-service, time-off decisions and access to employee data through IWant. The vendor lists Talent Acquisition, Time and Labor Management, Talent Management and HR Management as additional modules, but does not publish their prices. Ask which modules are included in your quote and whether they cover your must-haves before comparing totals.
Questions people ask
Who is Paycom's biggest competitor?
There is no single answer without a measure, such as revenue, customer count or deals won. For a small-team buying decision, compare providers on payroll, HR modules, time tracking, employee self-service, implementation and the full written quote rather than relying on a broad competitor label.
What is the Paycom controversy?
Check current, reputable reporting and court or regulator records before treating an allegation as established. Complaints, lawsuits and official findings are not interchangeable. If a specific concern affects your buying decision, ask Paycom for a direct response and review the contract and applicable policies.
Which is better, Paycom or ADP?
The right choice depends on your needs and each provider’s quote. Paycom offers payroll and HR tools in one system, but its pricing is customized. Ask both vendors for quotes with the same employee count, modules, implementation details and support terms so you can compare like for like.
Is Paycom a good payroll system?
Paycom may suit a team looking for payroll automation alongside HR tools, employee self-service and dedicated service. Its price depends on workforce size and selected modules, so small teams should request a detailed quote and confirm implementation, support and the modules needed for payroll.