We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick Time Clock Wizard.
Most small teams should start with Time Clock Wizard: its free plan covers basic time tracking for unlimited users, and Pro costs $49.95 per month with annual billing for 1–10 users when you need scheduling and payroll reporting. Paycom is the better fit if you want payroll and broader HR in one system, employee self-service and a dedicated service team. Its quote-based price makes it hard to budget before a sales conversation.
01Side by side
| Paycom | Time Clock Wizard | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan | Free for unlimited users; basic time tracking |
| Cheapest paid plan | Custom quote; price not published | Value: $29.95/month annually, or $34.95 monthly |
| Price per seat | Per-seat price not published | Pro: $9.99/user at five, annual billing |
| Cost for five | Custom quote | Pro: $49.95 annual-billing equivalent; $54.95 monthly |
| Setup effort | Dedicated implementation team; timeline not published | Setup timeline not published |
| Learning curve | Broader HR and payroll scope | Focused timekeeping and scheduling tools |
| Integrations | Confirm needed connections with the vendor | Confirm needed connections with the vendor |
| Support | Dedicated ongoing service team | Value includes support; Enterprise adds priority support |
Paycom Choose Paycom if
- Choose Paycom if you want HR and payroll in one system.
- Choose Paycom if employees should manage their own HR information.
- Choose Paycom if you value dedicated implementation and ongoing support.
Time Clock Wizard Choose Time Clock Wizard if
- Choose Time Clock Wizard if you need free basic time tracking.
- Choose Time Clock Wizard if you need scheduling and payroll reports at a listed price.
- Choose Time Clock Wizard if you want time tracking for unlimited users.
02What each costs a small team
Time Clock Wizard has a free plan for unlimited users, but it covers basic employee time tracking. Its Value plan is the cheapest paid option: $29.95 per month when billed annually ($359.40 a year) or $34.95 month-to-month. For scheduling and payroll reporting, the relevant tier is Pro: teams of 1–10 pay $49.95 per month on annual billing ($599.40 a year) or $54.95 monthly.
For one person, Pro costs $49.95 or $54.95 total per month; for a five-person team, the same flat fee works out to $9.99 or $10.99 per person. Paycom has no free plan and sells a customized quote based on workforce size and selected modules. It doesn't publish a per-seat rate, so ask for a quote for your team and chosen modules before comparing totals.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline. Paycom offers a dedicated team for implementation, payroll processing and ongoing support. That can help when setting up HR and payroll workflows, but ask what implementation covers and whether it affects your quote. Paycom's single database means employee data changes populate throughout the software.
Time Clock Wizard centers on time tracking, with scheduling and payroll reporting on Pro. Setup involves getting your team's time tracking in place and configuring the schedules, pay rates and alerts you plan to use. The vendor doesn't publish how long that takes. The practical learning difference is scope: Paycom covers HR and payroll together, while Time Clock Wizard focuses on employee time, scheduling and related reports.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Time Clock Wizard's Free plan gives unlimited users basic employee time tracking. Value adds reporting and support, and costs $29.95 per month with annual billing or $34.95 month-to-month. For scheduling and payroll reporting, Pro supports up to 50 users; the listed price for 1–10 users is $49.95 per month annually or $54.95 monthly. Its listed features include scheduling, time and attendance tracking, payroll reports, alerts and expense reimbursements.
Paycom doesn't list a standard low-cost plan price: it customizes quotes by workforce size and selected modules. Its offering includes payroll automation with Beti, employee self-service, HR tools, time-off decisions and access to employee data through IWant. Since modules are selected for each customer, ask which features are included in your quote. Paycom's payroll automation is broader than Time Clock Wizard's payroll reporting, while Time Clock Wizard makes its basic time-tracking option free.
Questions people ask
Does Time Clock Wizard have a free plan?
Yes. Its Free plan includes unlimited users and basic employee time tracking. Paycom has no free plan. If your team needs scheduling and payroll reporting, Time Clock Wizard lists those features under Pro rather than its free tier.
Does Time Clock Wizard process payroll?
Time Clock Wizard includes payroll reporting and shows total hours and pay; it is not described as payroll processing. Paycom offers payroll automation, including Beti, which builds payroll and lets employees find and fix errors before payroll runs.
Is Paycom a good fit for a small business?
Paycom can fit a small business that needs HR and payroll together, employee-managed information, and a dedicated team for implementation and ongoing support. Pricing is customized, so request a quote for your workforce size and selected modules before deciding.
Which integrations should we check before buying?
Ask each vendor to confirm the specific connection you need, such as an accounting, POS or benefits system. Time Clock Wizard's listed plans focus on time, scheduling and payroll reports. Paycom customizes quotes by workforce size and modules, so request integration details in writing.