review galore

Head-to-head · Payroll tools

Paycom vs TimeClock Plus

A practical comparison of features, setup, support, and costs for teams watching every subscription.

Paycom

5.3/10
VS

TimeClock Plus

5.4/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

It's a split decision.

For a small team that wants payroll and HR in one system, Paycom is the closer fit: it offers employee self-service and automated payroll, with a dedicated implementation team. Choose TimeClock Plus if your main need is tracking shifts, leave, overtime, and payroll calculations, especially across clock types or locations. Neither vendor publishes a free plan or a starting price, so compare written quotes for your exact headcount, modules, and any hardware before deciding.

01Side by side

PaycomTimeClock Plus
Free planNo free plan listedNo free plan listed
Cheapest paid planCustom quote; starts from Core setupQuote-based; plan names unpublished
Price per seatNot publishedNot published
Cost for fiveAsk for a five-person quoteAsk for a five-person quote
Setup effortDedicated implementation teamClock options and rules to configure
Learning curveNot publishedNot published
Small-team integrationsIntegration details not publishedIntegration details not published
SupportDedicated ongoing support teamSupport model details not published

Choose Paycom if

  • Choose Paycom if you want HR and payroll together.
  • Choose Paycom if employee self-service matters.
  • Choose Paycom if you want a dedicated implementation team.

Choose TimeClock Plus if

  • Choose TimeClock Plus if time and attendance are your priority.
  • Choose TimeClock Plus if you need leave and overtime tracking.
  • Choose TimeClock Plus if you need on-site, mobile, or web clocks.

02What each costs a small team

Neither vendor lists a free plan. Paycom pricing is quote-based and customized by workforce size and selected modules; it starts from a Core setup. The vendor does not publish monthly or annual rates. For one person, that means requesting a quote rather than multiplying a public per-seat price. The same applies to a team of three to five: ask for the total and which modules it covers.

TimeClock Plus also uses quote-based pricing, and its monthly and annual terms are not published. There is no public starting price to calculate a one-person or five-person total. Ask both vendors for a written quote at your headcount, including any minimums, selected features, and clock hardware costs. That is the only reliable way to compare the small-team bill.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Paycom says clients get a dedicated team for implementation, payroll processing, and ongoing support. Its single database lets employee data changes populate throughout the software, while employees enter and manage their own HR and payroll information. The vendor does not publish a typical setup timeline, so ask how long implementation takes for your selected modules and who handles data entry.

TimeClock Plus offers on-site, mobile, and web clock options, plus hardware. A small team will need to decide how employees clock in and configure work rules such as breaks, leave, overtime, job codes, and pay rates. The vendor does not publish a typical launch time or learning-curve details. Ask what configuration and training are included in your quote.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Neither vendor publishes plan tiers that show which features come with its cheapest option, so get the feature list in writing before comparing quotes. Paycom's described tools cover payroll automation, employee self-service, HR data in one system, and time-off decisions. Beti builds payroll and lets employees find and fix errors before payroll runs. IWant answers questions about employee and applicant data, policies, and dashboards. The quote depends on workforce size and selected modules.

TimeClock Plus focuses on time and attendance: collecting punches, tracking hours, breaks, leave, exceptions, accruals, overtime, job codes, and pay rates, and calculating payroll. Employees can request time off for managers to review. Teams can combine on-site, mobile, and web clocks with hardware. Its K-12 tools also cover attendance, extra duty, and absence management. Ask which of these tools are included in the quote; the vendor does not publish a cheaper-plan feature breakdown.

Questions people ask

Who is Paycom's biggest competitor?

That depends on what a buyer needs, and we can’t identify a single biggest competitor from product features alone. TimeClock Plus is an alternative for teams focused on time and attendance. Paycom is broader, combining payroll and HR tools. Compare vendors against your required features, support needs, and written quote.

What is the Paycom controversy?

The question needs a specific allegation or event to answer accurately. We would not treat a general search phrase as proof of a controversy. Check credible reporting for the particular claim and look for Paycom’s response; for a buying decision, also ask the vendor about any concern that affects your team.

Is Paycom a good payroll system?

Paycom may suit a team seeking payroll automation alongside HR tools. Its Beti feature builds payroll and lets employees find and fix errors before payroll runs, while employee self-service keeps employee information in the system. Pricing is quote-based, so small teams should compare the full cost and included modules first.

Does Paycom track location when clocking in?

The location-tracking details are not published in the information available for this comparison. Ask Paycom whether its clock-in options collect GPS or other location data, when that data is captured, and what controls administrators and employees have. Get the answer in writing if location privacy is a deciding factor.