review galore

Head-to-head · Payroll tools

Payroll4Free vs QuickBooks Online Payroll

For a tiny team watching every dollar, Payroll4Free wins on price. QuickBooks costs more but connects payroll with accounting.

Payroll4Free

6.0/10
VS

QuickBooks Online Payroll

6.2/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

It's a split decision.

Choose Payroll4Free if your business pays nine or fewer employees monthly and its listed payroll features cover your needs: the basic service is free. Choose QuickBooks Online Payroll if you want payroll connected to QuickBooks accounting or need its broader payroll and HR options. Its entry plan lists a $50 monthly base plus $7 per employee, so five people cost $85 monthly before any offer. Setup time and support terms aren’t published; ask both vendors before committing.

01Side by side

Payroll4FreeQuickBooks Online Payroll
Free planFree basic service for up to nine employeesNo free plan; 30-day trial listed
Cheapest paid planPaid-service prices aren’t published$50 monthly base, plus $7 per employee
Price per seatNo per-seat charge on eligible free service$7 per employee, plus monthly base
Cost for five$0 monthly for eligible basic service$85 monthly at listed base pricing
Setup effortSetup time and requirements aren’t publishedSetup time and requirements aren’t published
Learning curveEase-of-use score is low; details aren’t publishedEase-of-use score is modest; details aren’t published
Small-team integrationsPayroll features listed; integrations aren’t publishedPayroll syncs with QuickBooks accounting
SupportSupport score is low; terms aren’t publishedSupport score is modest; terms aren’t published

Choose Payroll4Free if

  • Choose Payroll4Free if you pay nine or fewer employees monthly.
  • Choose Payroll4Free if free basic payroll is your main priority.
  • Choose Payroll4Free if paper checks or direct deposit fit your workflow.

Choose QuickBooks Online Payroll if

  • Choose QuickBooks Online Payroll if you want payroll synced with QuickBooks accounting.
  • Choose QuickBooks Online Payroll if you need its listed HR workflows.
  • Choose QuickBooks Online Payroll if tax penalty protection matters to your team.

02What each costs a small team

Payroll4Free’s basic service costs $0 monthly for businesses paying nine or fewer employees monthly. That covers the listed basic payroll service; the vendor identifies PTS and DDS as recurring services but doesn’t publish their prices or terms. Ask whether either is needed for your setup.

QuickBooks Workforce Payroll lists a $50 monthly base plus $7 per employee. That works out to $57 for one person, $71 for three, and $85 for five, before any offer. Its listed introductory offer lowers the base to $25 monthly for three months: $32, $46, and $60 for those team sizes. The vendor also lists a 30-day trial. Payroll4Free is the clear price pick for an eligible small team; QuickBooks costs more but links payroll with accounting.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate or a step-by-step onboarding requirement in the available pricing details. Before signing up, ask what information you’ll need to provide, how payroll tax setup works, and whether help is available during your first pay run. For Payroll4Free, also confirm whether the free basic service covers your preferred payment method and any recurring services you need.

The day-to-day choice depends on how much you want in one system. Payroll4Free lists employee and contractor payroll, tax calculations, vacation tracking, reporting, payment options, and an employee portal. QuickBooks describes payroll alongside cloud-based accounting, with payroll records syncing to accounting. That connection could suit a team already using QuickBooks, but check which accounting subscription or setup is required. Learning-curve details aren’t published, so ask for a walkthrough before choosing.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Payroll4Free’s basic free service lists payroll for employees and contractors, tax calculations, vacation tracking, detailed reporting, direct deposit or paper checks, and an employee portal. It’s a useful set of basics for a team within the nine-employee limit. The vendor doesn’t publish the price or requirements for its recurring PTS and DDS services, so confirm whether you’d need either one.

QuickBooks Workforce Payroll’s entry plan lists unlimited payroll runs and a $7-per-employee monthly charge on top of its base fee. QuickBooks describes its broader payroll product as supporting tax filing, Auto Payroll for salaried employees on direct deposit, time tracking, contractor payments, and benefits and HR tools. Don’t assume every feature is included in the entry plan: Premium lists up to five automated HR workflows, while Elite lists unlimited workflow configurations and tax penalty protection up to $25,000 per year. Additional-state filing is listed at $12 monthly per state, included with Elite.

Questions people ask

What are some alternatives to QuickBooks for small businesses with payroll?

Payroll4Free is one option for businesses paying nine or fewer employees monthly; its basic service is free and lists employee and contractor payroll. Gusto is another name small businesses may compare, but check its current pricing and included features against your payroll needs before deciding.

Does QuickBooks Online include payroll?

QuickBooks offers payroll as a paid product connected to its cloud-based accounting tools. The listed Workforce Payroll plan costs $50 monthly plus $7 per employee, with unlimited payroll runs. Check which accounting subscription is needed for the connection, since the vendor doesn’t publish that requirement in the listed pricing details.

What is better for payroll, Gusto or QuickBooks?

It depends on what your team needs, and current Gusto pricing and features should be checked directly with its vendor. QuickBooks lists payroll that syncs with its accounting records, with a $50 monthly base plus $7 per employee on its entry plan. Compare total cost, tax filing, and support terms.

What are the best payroll systems for a small team?

Start with the number of employees, total monthly cost, tax filing needs, and whether payroll should connect to your accounting system. Payroll4Free offers free basic service for businesses paying up to nine employees monthly. QuickBooks lists payroll with accounting sync, but its entry plan charges a base fee plus a per-employee fee.