We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick SurePayroll.
If your 1–10 person team needs recurring payroll, SurePayroll is the easier budget choice to evaluate: it lists monthly base prices and per-employee fees, though some listings conflict. Choose Full Service if you want payroll taxes filed and deposited. Paychex is worth a quote if you also need broader HR, benefits, or PEO services. Neither vendor lists a free plan, and Paychex does not publish its monthly rates, so get a written quote before comparing total costs.
01Side by side
| SurePayroll | Paychex | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | None listed | None listed |
| Cheapest paid plan | No Tax Filing: $20/month listed | Basic: quote required |
| Price per seat | $4 or $7/employee, plus base | Not published |
| Five-person payroll | $40–$49 No Tax; $64–$74 Full Service | Quote required |
| Setup effort | Setup time not published | Setup time not published |
| Learning curve | Not published | Not published |
| Small-team integrations | Accounting add-on: $4.99/month | Add-on prices not published |
| Support | Customer support included | More than 7,600 support and HR professionals |
SurePayroll Choose SurePayroll if
- Choose SurePayroll if you want listed monthly prices.
- Choose SurePayroll if you need automatic tax filing.
- Choose SurePayroll if you want payroll for W-2s and 1099s.
Paychex Choose Paychex if
- Choose Paychex if you need payroll and broader HR services.
- Choose Paychex if benefits or PEO services are on your list.
- Choose Paychex if you want to discuss service options by quote.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor lists a free plan. SurePayroll’s No Tax Filing plan is listed at $20/month plus $4 per employee; another listing shows a $29 base. Full Service is listed at $29 plus $7 per employee, with another listing at $39 plus $7. These conflicting prices are worth confirming.
- For one employee, No Tax Filing works out to $24–$33/month; Full Service is $36–$46.
- For three employees, those totals are $32–$41 and $50–$60. For five, they are $40–$49 and $64–$74.
Those estimates use the listed base and per-employee fees, before add-ons or year-end forms. Paychex lists Basic, Foundations, Advanced, and Complete, but publishes no monthly rates or seat costs. Ask for a quote for your headcount and required services before comparing it with SurePayroll.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline, so we can’t promise how quickly a small team can start. Ask each for the steps, documents, and support included in onboarding, plus how they handle your tax jurisdictions and first payroll date.
SurePayroll’s listed tools include scheduled payroll, online paystubs and records, and unlimited payroll runs. Those features point to a focused payroll workflow, but the company does not publish a learning-curve rating. Paychex spans payroll, HR, time tracking, benefits, and PEO services, so ask which parts are included in the plan you’re quoted and what your team must configure.
For either service, get a clear explanation of who enters payroll and tax details, who approves each run, and where employees access their records. Those answers will tell you more about day-to-day effort than an unpublished setup estimate.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
SurePayroll’s cheapest listed option, No Tax Filing, includes unlimited payroll runs and customer support. Your business handles tax filing and deposits, so the lower base price means taking on that work. Full Service adds payroll tax calculation, filing, and deposits, plus free 2-day direct deposit. Both listings describe per-employee fees; confirm which base price applies.
Paychex’s Basic plan lists unlimited payroll processing, employee pay options, W-2 and 1099 year-end processing, and payroll tax filing. Its Foundations, Advanced, and Complete plans describe additional AI, HR, or service features, but monthly prices are not published. Paychex also offers HR guidance and PEO services, with benefits and compliance among the listed offerings; ask which services are in your quote.
For a small team that mainly needs payroll, compare SurePayroll Full Service with a Paychex quote that names the same tax and year-end tasks. Don’t assume broader platform options are included in Basic.
Questions people ask
Are SurePayroll and Paychex the same?
They are different payroll offerings. SurePayroll focuses on online payroll for small businesses and household employers, with tax filing available through Full Service. Paychex offers payroll alongside HR, compliance, benefits, and PEO services. If you’re asking about ownership or a connection between the companies, confirm that directly with the vendors.
What is the best payroll software for small businesses?
For a small business prioritizing a published price and payroll tax handling, SurePayroll Full Service is a practical place to start comparing. Paychex may suit a team that also wants HR, benefits, or PEO services. Compare written quotes against the tasks your team needs, not just the plan names.
How can I contact Paychex Flex customer service?
The Paychex information here lists more than 7,600 customer support and HR professionals but no specific phone number or contact route. Use Paychex’s official contact options and ask how support works for the plan you’re considering, including any separate charge for enhanced or premium support.
How much does Paychex payroll cost per month?
Paychex does not publish monthly or annual rates for its listed plans; its pricing page directs businesses to request a quote. Ask for the full monthly cost for your headcount, including any seat costs, overages, and add-ons. SurePayroll’s listed prices vary, so confirm those directly too.