review galore

Head-to-head · HR software

When I Work vs When to Work

For a small team, compare When I Work’s low per-user price with When to Work’s flat rate for up to 10 employees.

When I Work

6.2/10
VS

When to Work

7.0/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

It's a split decision.

A small team that wants scheduling plus team messaging at the lowest per-user price should consider When I Work: Essentials lists at $2.50 per user monthly, but time tracking costs extra and its price isn’t published. When to Work suits teams that prefer one flat subscription covering up to 10 employees: its listed monthly price is $28. Neither has a free plan. When I Work offers a 14-day trial; When to Work offers 30 days.

01Side by side

When I WorkWhen to Work
Free planNo free plan; 14-day free trialNo free plan; 30-day free trial
Cheapest paid planEssentials: $2.50 per user monthlyUp to 10 employees: $28 monthly
Price per seat$2.50 per user monthlyNo per-seat rate; introductory annual average $17.08 monthly
Cost for five$12.50 monthly, before time-tracking add-on$28 monthly, up to 10 employees
Setup effortSetup time not published; configure schedules and locationsSetup time not published; configure schedules and availability
Learning curveNot published; evaluate scheduling controls your team needsNot published; evaluate schedule views your team prefers
IntegrationsIntegration details not published; ask about your toolsIntegration details not published; ask about your tools
SupportReview support score: 4Review support score: 5

Choose When I Work if

  • Choose When I Work if per-user monthly pricing suits your budget.
  • Choose When I Work if team messaging belongs in your scheduling tool.
  • Choose When I Work if multi-location scheduling and templates matter.

Choose When to Work if

  • Choose When to Work if one flat price covers your team.
  • Choose When to Work if you need up to 10 employee accounts.
  • Choose When to Work if a 30-day trial helps your evaluation.

02What each costs a small team

Neither tool has a free plan. When I Work offers a 14-day trial, while When to Work offers 30 days.

When I Work’s pricing lists Essentials at $2.50 per user per month. That’s $2.50 for one person, $7.50 for three, and $12.50 for five. The plan includes scheduling and team messaging. Time Tracking & Attendance is an add-on, and its price isn’t published; ask the vendor for a quote if you need it.

When to Work lists a $28 monthly subscription for up to 10 employees, so one, three, or five employees still cost $28 monthly. Introductory annual pricing is $205 per year, or $17.08 per month; the listed standard rates are $38 monthly or $273 yearly.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes how long setup takes, so plan around your schedule complexity and the information you need to enter. For either tool, collect staff availability, time-off needs, and shift requirements before building the first schedule.

When I Work lists schedule templates, multi-week and multi-location scheduling, and auto scheduling based on eligibility, availability, and preferences. Its Essentials plan also includes team messaging. Teams considering time tracking should check the add-on price before deciding what to configure.

When to Work lists reusable templates, drag-and-drop scheduling, and employee tools for availability, shift trades, and time-off requests. Managers can use schedule views and coverage monitoring. Its pricing lists computer and mobile access. Learning-curve details aren’t published for either product, so compare the workflows with the way your team builds and shares schedules.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

When I Work’s cheapest plan is Essentials. The pricing page lists auto scheduling, multi-week and multi-location scheduling, schedule templates, and team messaging. That makes it a fit to consider if your team wants scheduling and staff communication together. Time Tracking & Attendance is a separate add-on, and the vendor doesn’t publish its price. Advanced controls such as scheduling rules, role permissions, and custom reporting are listed under Pro, not Essentials.

When to Work lists one subscription for teams with up to 10 employees. Its product features include drag-and-drop schedules, AutoFill, reusable templates, and spreadsheet-style, calendar, and multi-location views. Staff can set availability, trade shifts, and request time off for manager oversight. The product also lists alerts and coverage monitoring. The listed subscription includes computer and mobile access; check with the vendor if you need details about specific features or integrations.

Questions people ask

Do you have to pay for When to Work?

Yes, after its 30-day free trial. The listed subscription for up to 10 employees is $28 monthly, with introductory annual pricing of $205 per year. When to Work does not list a free plan.

Which is better, When I Work or When to Work?

When I Work has the lower listed starting price per user and includes team messaging in Essentials. When to Work charges a flat $28 monthly for up to 10 employees and offers a longer trial. The better fit depends on whether you prefer per-user pricing or a flat rate.

What is the best employee scheduling software for a small team?

There isn’t one best choice for every team. Compare the tools’ scheduling workflows and prices: When I Work Essentials lists at $2.50 per user monthly, while When to Work lists $28 monthly for up to 10 employees. Check the time-tracking add-on cost if you’re considering When I Work.

Who owns When to Work?

The pricing information does not identify When to Work’s owner. For current ownership details, check the company’s About or legal information, or ask the vendor directly.