We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Small teams may not need an identity platform at all if a few separate logins do the job. authentik makes more sense when you want centralized SSO and access control and can handle self-hosting. Its listing shows a free plan and a $0.02 starting figure. Among these alternatives, listed starting prices run from $3 for OneLogin to $35 for Auth0, which also has a free plan. Those figures don’t establish a total for 1–10 seats, so ask for a quote and setup details.
01Why people leave authentik
More tool than a small stack needs
One Reddit thread questioned whether SSO was overkill for five to seven services. Other commenters said shared logins improved convenience, so needs vary.
Setup and app fit take work
A commenter on r/selfhosted described authentik as tricky at first but adaptable across apps with different auth methods. Another preferred simpler configuration.
Self-hosting adds maintenance
If your team wants managed identity rather than another system to run, a hosted option may be a better fit; compare onboarding and support before switching.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Customer app logins
Auth0Auth0Auth0 fits small teams building customer-facing apps that need several login methods, rather than teams mainly looking for self-hosted workforce SSO. It has a free plan and lists a $35 starting price. The listing doesn’t establish what 1–10 seats would cost or how much setup help is included, so ask about app integrations and expected costs before scaling.
Trade-off: Its listed strengths are customer logins, not a low-cost self-hosted SSO setup.
6.8/10from
$35/mofree plan - Workforce SSO
OneLoginOneLoginOneLogin is a practical managed option for small teams consolidating workforce logins, especially businesses using Active Directory. It covers SSO and MFA and lists a $3 starting price, but has no free plan. The starting figure isn’t a total for a few seats; ask how pricing scales and what setup support is available for your apps.
Trade-off: No free plan, and seat costs can add up.
7.4/10from
$3/mo - Broad app integrations
OktaOktaOkta may suit a team that values a broad identity toolkit, many app integrations, and room to grow into identity governance. The pricing page lists a $6 starting price, annual billing, and no free plan. That figure doesn’t establish a 1–10-seat total, so ask for a quote and confirm the setup effort for your app mix.
Trade-off: Annual billing and no free plan make it harder to try cheaply.
6.8/10from
$6/mo - Access reviews
LumosLumosLumos is worth considering if your small team’s real need is access reviews or managing many identity types, including AI agents. It has no listed free plan, and pricing is custom, so it’s difficult to judge against a self-hosted free option on a tight budget. Ask for a quote and a clear explanation of setup and ongoing administration.
Trade-off: Custom pricing and no listed free plan limit budget certainty.
5.5/10from
Custom - Privileged access
OpalOpalOpal is a more specialized option for teams that need access reviews, privileged-access policies, or visibility into infrastructure and AI-agent access. It lists a $20 starting price and has no free way to start. The listed price doesn’t give a total for a few seats, so ask about minimums, onboarding, and whether it covers your specific access needs.
Trade-off: No free plan; its focus may be broader than a small team needs.
6.5/10from
$20/mo - Education identity needs
RapidIdentityRapidIdentityRapidIdentity is a niche option for small schools or colleges that need to manage digital access and sync identity data. It may fit better than a general-purpose tool when education workflows are the priority, but pricing and setup details require a vendor conversation. Ask for a quote sized to your team and a walkthrough of the work needed to connect your systems.
Trade-off: Not a general small-business pick; budget and setup need a vendor conversation.
5.0/10from
Custom
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7.5 | $0.02/mo | Yes | Self-hosting small teams | |
| 6.8 | $35/mo | Yes | Teams building customer-facing apps | |
| 7.4 | $3/mo | No | Small teams consolidating workforce logins | |
| 6.8 | $6/mo | No | Teams standardizing employee sign-in | |
| 5.5 | Custom | No | Teams managing many identity types | |
| 6.5 | $20/mo | No | Teams governing AI-agent access | |
| 5.0 | Custom | No | Schools managing digital access |
Questions people ask
What is replacing SAML?
There isn’t one replacement that fits every team. In this shortlist, Auth0 is positioned for apps needing several login methods, while OneLogin and Okta focus on workforce SSO. Check which protocols your apps support before choosing a provider; the wrong fit can leave you maintaining separate login paths.
What are some alternatives to Authelia?
For managed identity, this shortlist includes OneLogin, Okta, and Auth0, each aimed at different needs and budgets. A commenter on r/selfhosted described using Authelia with OIDC and LDAP, and noted that the right choice depends on the services being protected. Check protocol and app compatibility before switching.
Is Okta open-source?
Check Okta’s licensing and source-code documentation before treating it as an open-source option. Its listed buying details are a $6 starting price, annual billing, and no free plan. If open-source software is a firm requirement, confirm that point directly before comparing cost or setup.
