We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
If your team just needs to watch a few public websites, UptimeRobot may still be enough: its listing includes a free plan and starts at $9. But a Reddit user says a legacy plan moved from $8 to $34 for similar service, and other users describe false alerts. For a small team choosing a replacement, Prometheus and Zabbix avoid software fees but require technical upkeep. Grafana and New Relic offer broader observability, while PagerDuty handles incident response. Check seat and usage costs before choosing.
01Why people leave UptimeRobot
A legacy plan got much more expensive
One long-time customer on Reddit reported being moved from $8 to $34 for similar service. That is one customer’s account, but it’s a reason to check your renewal terms.
False alerts can disrupt on-call
Reddit users report false positives with heartbeat and HTTP checks. Other commenters report reliable alerts, and one says checking page text helped catch application errors.
Website checks may not be enough
A Reddit commenter says UptimeRobot works well for websites but recommends an RMM for servers and internal infrastructure. Teams wanting broader monitoring may need another tool.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Best for technical teams
PrometheusPrometheusPrometheus is a fit if your team can instrument its own services and wants to avoid per-seat software fees. Its software costs $0, and the listing includes a free plan. The trade is setup and query work: your team needs the skills to run it. Its listed price does not establish hosting costs or a total for your team.
Trade-off:
8.0/10from
Freefree plan - Best for self-hosting
ZabbixZabbixZabbix offers a free plan and broad infrastructure monitoring, which can suit a budget-conscious team willing to host its own software. The listing starts at no published price, not a paid seat rate. Plan for setup and ongoing upkeep; the source does not give a three-seat cost, so ask about hosting and support before comparing bills.
Trade-off:
7.8/10from
Freefree plan - Best for telemetry
GrafanaGrafanaGrafana has a free starting tier and suits teams combining several telemetry signals or configuring their own dashboards. Its listing starts at $19, but that figure alone does not show what a few seats or your usage will cost. Expect a learning curve, and check usage charges before moving more monitoring into it.
Trade-off:
7.4/10from
$19/mofree plan - Best for app observability
New RelicNew RelicNew Relic may suit a small team that wants to centralize observability and investigate application incidents. The listing includes a free plan and starts at $10. That starting price is not a three-seat total, and the listing flags seat and data costs as items to check before committing.
Trade-off:
7.2/10from
$10/mofree plan - Best for app monitoring
Scout APMScout APMScout APM is a small-team option for monitoring production apps, with a free plan and a listed starting price of $19. The listing warns about transaction and log limits, so check whether your workload fits. It focuses on application monitoring rather than being a like-for-like website uptime replacement.
Trade-off:
7.2/10from
$19/mofree plan - Best for on-call
PagerDutyPagerDutyPagerDuty makes sense if the bigger gap is managing on-call rotations and escalation, rather than checking whether a website responds. It has a free plan for a small on-call setup and starts at $21. The listed price does not give a total for your seats; check paid costs before adding the team.
Trade-off:
7.0/10from
$21/mofree plan
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7.2 | €9/mo | Yes | Small teams monitoring public websites | |
| 8.0 | Free | Yes | Technical teams on tight budgets | |
| 7.8 | Free | Yes | Budget-conscious infrastructure teams | |
| 7.4 | $19/mo | Yes | Teams combining several telemetry signals | |
| 7.2 | $10/mo | Yes | Small teams centralizing observability | |
| 7.2 | $19/mo | Yes | Small teams monitoring production apps | |
| 7.0 | $21/mo | Yes | Teams with regular on-call rotations |
Questions people ask
Which UptimeRobot alternative is free?
Prometheus has a free plan and $0 software cost, but your team needs the skills to run and query it. Zabbix also has a free plan and is self-hosted, so allow for setup and upkeep. Free software does not mean the work of operating it disappears.
What should a small team budget for a few seats?
The listed starting prices are $19 for Grafana, $10 for New Relic and $21 for PagerDuty; they do not establish a total for a few seats. Ask each vendor for a quote based on your team size and expected usage. For New Relic, check both seat and data costs.
Can another tool help with false alerts?
Some Reddit users describe false positives from UptimeRobot heartbeat or HTTP checks, while others report reliable alerts. One commenter says checking for text on a page helped catch application errors. If you switch tools, ask how checks are configured and how alert conditions can be tuned.
