We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick Gusto.
For a 1–10-person team focused on payroll and basic HR, Gusto is the lower-cost pick: its Simple plan starts at $49 plus $6 per person monthly. QuickBooks Workforce Payroll starts at $50 plus $7 per employee, but offers a 30-day free trial and connects payroll with QuickBooks accounting. Choose Gusto for the lower ongoing bill and basic PTO; choose QuickBooks if its accounting connection matters more. Neither has a free plan, and setup-time estimates aren’t published.
01Side by side
| Gusto | QuickBooks Online Payroll | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan; trial terms not listed | No free plan; 30-day free trial |
| Cheapest paid plan | Simple: $49 base plus $6 per person | Workforce Payroll: $50 base plus $7 per employee |
| Price per seat | $6 per person monthly, plus base fee | $7 per employee monthly, plus base fee |
| Cost for five | $79 monthly at listed rates | $85 monthly at listed rates |
| Setup effort | Setup-time estimate not published | Setup-time estimate not published |
| Learning curve | Ease-of-use score: 7 | Ease-of-use score: 5 |
| Accounting connection | QuickBooks connection details not published | Payroll syncs with QuickBooks accounting |
| Support | Score 4; review notes uneven support | Score 4 |
Gusto Choose Gusto if
- Choose Gusto if lower monthly payroll costs matter.
- Choose Gusto if basic PTO belongs in your payroll plan.
- Choose Gusto if you want payroll and HR tools under one roof.
QuickBooks Online Payroll Choose QuickBooks Online Payroll if
- Choose QuickBooks if payroll should sync with QuickBooks accounting.
- Choose QuickBooks if you want a 30-day free trial.
- Choose QuickBooks if you need its listed HR workflow or tax-protection tiers.
02What each costs a small team
Neither service has a free plan. QuickBooks lists a 30-day free trial; Gusto’s free-trial terms aren’t listed. Gusto Simple costs $49 monthly plus $6 per person, while QuickBooks Workforce Payroll costs $50 monthly plus $7 per employee. At those rates, one person costs $55 with Gusto or $57 with QuickBooks. For three people, it’s $67 versus $71; for five, $79 versus $85. QuickBooks advertises a $25 monthly base for the first three months, plus its $7-per-employee charge, making five people $60 monthly during that offer. Gusto says its plans are month-to-month. QuickBooks lists monthly prices; annual-billing prices aren’t published. QuickBooks charges $12 monthly per additional state, while Gusto’s state tax registration pricing varies by state.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate, so we wouldn’t budget around a promised number of hours. Ask each vendor what it needs for tax setup and employee onboarding before your first payroll. Gusto Simple covers payroll, tax filings and payments, and basic PTO. QuickBooks describes full-service payroll and Auto Payroll for salaried employees on direct deposit. Its Payroll AI prepares a pay run for approval and can collect time and attendance data. Gusto lists time tracking and scheduling on Plus, not Simple. Reviews score ease of use at 7 for Gusto and 5 for QuickBooks, which points to a possible learning-curve advantage for Gusto, not a guarantee about setup time. Before choosing, confirm that the service and plan fit your payroll needs, including your number of states and whether you pay contractors.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Gusto Simple includes unlimited payrolls, tax filings and payments, basic PTO policies, and holiday pay. QuickBooks Workforce Payroll lists unlimited payroll runs and describes its service as full-service payroll with tax filing. QuickBooks also describes Auto Payroll for salaried employees on direct deposit; confirm with the vendor which functions apply to your selected plan. Gusto’s higher tiers add more tools: Plus lists time tracking, scheduling, multi-state payroll, and contractor invoice management. Premium adds HR guidance and compliance tools. On QuickBooks, Premium lists up to five automated HR workflows; Elite adds unlimited workflow configurations and up to $25,000 per year in tax penalty protection. QuickBooks says benefits, 401(k), insurance, and workers’ compensation carry separate fees. Gusto lists health insurance with no administration fee, though premiums apply, and 401(k) pricing varies by plan. The entry plans are payroll-first rather than complete HR and benefits bundles.
Questions people ask
Is Gusto a good payroll service?
Gusto is worth considering if you want payroll, tax filings, payments, and basic PTO in its Simple plan. It also offers higher-tier HR tools, time tracking, and benefits. Its listed price is lower than QuickBooks Workforce Payroll for one to five people, though support reviews are uneven.
What are the four types of payroll?
Payroll can be discussed in different ways, but neither Gusto nor QuickBooks presents its plans as four payroll types. Their listed offerings focus on running payroll, tax filing, employee or contractor payments, and optional HR or time tools. Ask an accountant which categories apply to your business.
How does Gusto integrate with QuickBooks?
QuickBooks says its payroll syncs with QuickBooks accounting. Gusto’s listed product details don’t specify the scope of a QuickBooks connection. Before buying, ask Gusto whether the connection syncs payroll entries, tax information, and corrections, and whether it is available on your chosen plan.
What are people replacing QuickBooks with?
Gusto is one option to compare if you’re moving payroll away from QuickBooks: its Simple plan costs less at listed rates for small teams. But QuickBooks payroll connects with QuickBooks accounting, so check what you rely on before switching. Ask vendors about migration and accounting-record transfer.