review galore

Head-to-head · Payroll tools

QuickBooks Online Payroll vs Paychex

QuickBooks publishes per-employee pricing and connects to its accounting tools. Paychex bundles payroll and HR, but requires a quote.

QuickBooks Online Payroll

6.2/10
VS

Paychex

5.0/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick QuickBooks Online Payroll.

For a small team that wants a known bill and uses QuickBooks accounting, choose QuickBooks Online Payroll: its listed Workforce Payroll price is $50 monthly plus $7 per employee. That’s $85 monthly for five employees before add-ons. Paychex may suit teams looking for broader payroll and HR services with human support, but it doesn’t publish plan prices, so you’ll need a quote to compare the real cost. Neither offers a free plan.

01Side by side

QuickBooks Online PayrollPaychex
Free planNo free planNo free plan
Cheapest employee payroll plan$50/month plus $7 per employeeQuote required
Price per employee$7/month, plus base feeNot published
Five-employee monthly cost$85 before add-onsQuote required
Setup effortSetup time not publishedSetup time not published
Learning curveEase score: 5Ease score: 5
Small-team accounting connectionSyncs with QuickBooks accountingConnection details not published
SupportSupport details not publishedLists 7,600+ support and HR professionals

Choose QuickBooks Online Payroll if

  • Choose QuickBooks Online Payroll if you already use QuickBooks accounting.
  • Choose QuickBooks Online Payroll if you need a published monthly price.
  • Choose QuickBooks Online Payroll if $85 monthly fits five employees.

Choose Paychex if

  • Choose Paychex if you want payroll and HR services together.
  • Choose Paychex if access to human support matters to your team.
  • Choose Paychex if you’re willing to request a custom quote.

02What each costs a small team

Neither vendor offers a free plan. QuickBooks Workforce Payroll, its listed employee-payroll plan, costs $50 per month plus $7 per employee. That works out to $57 monthly for one employee, $71 for three, and $85 for five, before add-ons. The pricing page lists an introductory base price of $25 per month for three months; with the same per-employee fees, that would make those totals $32, $46, and $60 during the offer.

Paychex lists Basic, Foundations, Advanced, and Complete payroll plans, but asks businesses to request pricing. Monthly rates, per-employee charges, and overage costs aren’t published. That means we can’t give you a reliable one-person or five-person total for Paychex. Ask for a quote covering your employee count, tax filing, and any time-tracking or HR services you need.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a standard setup time, so plan to ask what onboarding involves before choosing. For either service, be ready to confirm how you’ll enter employee details, set up pay options, and handle payroll tax filing. QuickBooks also offers time tracking and schedules, while Paychex lists time and attendance tools; ask whether those are included in your quote or priced separately.

The review scores give both products an ease-of-use score of 5, so there’s no clear winner on learning curve from those ratings. QuickBooks may be a more natural fit if your team already works in QuickBooks accounting, since payroll syncs with those records. Paychex has payroll, HR, and compliance offerings in its Flex platform. Before signing, ask each vendor for a walkthrough of a regular pay run and a list of setup tasks your team must handle.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

QuickBooks Workforce Payroll lists unlimited payroll runs and a $7 monthly charge per employee, on top of its base fee. QuickBooks describes its payroll service as full-service, including payroll tax filing. Its broader payroll tools include contractor payments, time tracking, schedules, and Auto Payroll for salaried employees on direct deposit. Benefits and HR support carry separate fees or are tied to higher tiers: Premium lists up to five automated HR workflows, while Elite lists unlimited workflow configurations and tax penalty protection up to $25,000 per year.

Paychex Basic lists unlimited payroll processing, employee pay options, W-2 and 1099 year-end processing, and payroll tax filing. The other named payroll plans add descriptions such as AI and HR features, enhanced service, or premium services, but their prices aren’t published. Paychex also offers HR Pro and HR PEO options for teams seeking added HR guidance, benefits, or compliance services. Ask which features are included in your quote and which cost extra.

Questions people ask

Does QuickBooks also do payroll?

Yes. QuickBooks offers payroll plans with unlimited payroll runs, and its payroll service includes tax filing. Its broader tools include time tracking and contractor payments. The Workforce Payroll plan lists a $50 monthly base fee plus $7 per employee.

Which is cheaper, QuickBooks or Paychex?

QuickBooks is easier to budget for from its published prices: $50 monthly plus $7 per employee on Workforce Payroll. Paychex asks businesses to request pricing and doesn’t publish its monthly or per-employee rates. Get a Paychex quote to compare your actual costs.

Does Paychex have a free payroll plan?

Paychex does not list a free plan. Its pricing page lists several payroll and HR options and directs businesses to request pricing. Ask whether your quote includes tax filing, time and attendance, and any HR services your team needs.

Can Paychex connect with QuickBooks accounting?

QuickBooks says its payroll syncs with its accounting records. Paychex’s listed materials don’t specify a QuickBooks accounting connection. If you need that workflow, ask Paychex which accounting integrations are available and whether they’re included in your plan.