We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A small team needs payroll software if calculating pay, filing payroll taxes, or paying workers is eating into time you should spend running the business. Our first pick is Patriot Payroll for its $8.50 starting price; SurePayroll is another low-cost option, while QuickBooks Online Payroll makes sense if your books already run in QuickBooks. None of these picks is listed with a free payroll plan. And a starting price is not a reliable bill for a team of five: check base fees, per-person charges, and tax-filing costs before you commit.
Quick picksThe shortlist
Patriot PayrollPatriot PayrollBest for budget · $8.50/mo
SurePayrollSurePayrollBest for simple payroll · $20/mo
QuickBooks Online PayrollQuickBooks Online PayrollBest for QuickBooks · $25/mo
FingercheckFingercheckBest for hourly teams · $29/mo
GustoGustoBest for payroll and HR · $49/mo
OnPayOnPayBest for payroll filings · $55/mo
Toast PayrollToast PayrollBest for restaurants · $69/mo
Heartland PayrollHeartland PayrollBest for up to five · $89/mo
01Compared at a glance
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Trial |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7.2 | $8.50/mo | No | 30 days | |
| 7.0 | $20/mo | No | — | |
| 6.2 | $25/mo | No | 30 days | |
| 6.8 | $29/mo | No | — | |
| 6.8 | $49/mo | No | — | |
| 6.5 | $55/mo | No | 1 month | |
| 6.6 | $69/mo | No | — | |
| 6.0 | $89/mo | No | — |
02The picks, in detail
- Best for budget
Patriot PayrollPatriot PayrollPatriot Payroll has the lowest published starting price among our picks: $8.50. The listing calls it straightforward and says tax filing is available at a higher monthly price, so compare the two plan costs before choosing. For a 1–10-person team, ask whether the quoted price includes a base fee, how employee charges work, and what tax filing will add.
What works
- Unlimited payrolls
- Free direct deposit
- Employee portal and mobile app
What doesn't
- No free plan
- Worker fees apply on both plans
- Promotion ends after three months

- Best for simple payroll
SurePayrollSurePayrollSurePayroll starts at $20 and is aimed at small businesses with straightforward payroll, including employers who want automatic tax filing. That makes it a strong option to price-check if you want to keep payroll focused rather than buy a wider HR suite. The listing says to confirm your monthly price first; ask for a quote based on your actual headcount.
What works
- Unlimited payroll runs, including off-cycle runs
- Full Service files and deposits payroll taxes
- Free 2-day direct deposit on listed plans
What doesn't
- No free plan or published free trial
- Per-employee fees add up as teams grow
- Pricing page lists two prices for each core plan

- Best for QuickBooks
QuickBooks Online PayrollQuickBooks Online PayrollIf your team already uses QuickBooks, this option combines payroll with payroll tax filing and time tracking. The listed starting price is $25, but the listing warns that a base fee can make a small roster cost more. Ask for the total monthly amount for your number of employees, and confirm which tax-filing services are included at that price.
What works
- Unlimited payroll runs on listed plans
- Full-service payroll tax filing
- Payroll can sync with accounting records
What doesn't
- No free plan
- Base fee comes before per-employee charges
- Annual-billing prices are not published

- Best for hourly teams
FingercheckFingercheckFingercheck is built for hourly and deskless teams that want payroll alongside time clocks and scheduling. Its listed starting price is $29, with a monthly base fee plus a charge for every employee. That structure can add up even with a small roster, so get a written total for your headcount and ask which tools are included.
What works
- Payroll includes unlimited runs
- Multi-state tax calculation and filing
- Time tracking and scheduling options
What doesn't
- No free plan
- No free trial listed
- Per-employee fees add to base prices

- Best for payroll and HR
GustoGustoGusto combines payroll and HR and is positioned for small teams running one-state payroll or paying employees and contractors. The listed starting price is $49, but the listing says to budget for both the base fee and seats. Ask for the full price for your roster and confirm the plan covers the states and worker types you need.
What works
- Unlimited payrolls on Simple
- Tax filings and payments included
- Hiring, benefits, and time tools available
What doesn't
- No free plan
- Every plan has a base fee plus per-person charges
- Annual prices are not shown

- Best for payroll filings
OnPayOnPayOnPay is aimed at small teams that need payroll and filings, with options to add HR or time tracking. Its listed starting price is $55. The listing advises checking both price and tax-filing support before committing, so ask what filings are included, whether the monthly cost changes with headcount, and what support is available during a provider switch.
What works
- Federal, state, and local tax filings included
- Unlimited pay runs and schedules
- Can pay workers in any number of states
What doesn't
- No free plan
- One worker costs $55 monthly
- Annual pricing is not published

- Best for restaurants
Toast PayrollToast PayrollToast Payroll is the specialist pick for restaurants already using Toast, including new single-location restaurants that want connected labor tools. The listed starting price is $69, while existing customers may need a quote. If you run a restaurant, ask what your location and employee count would cost and whether your current Toast setup changes the price.
What works
- Payroll sits alongside Toast restaurant tools
- Remote clock-in and tip distribution are listed
- Eligible new locations can see a starting price
What doesn't
- No free plan or trial is listed
- Existing-customer pricing is by quote
- Per-employee fees raise the monthly bill

- Best for up to five
Heartland PayrollHeartland PayrollHeartland Payroll is listed for businesses with up to five employees that need payroll, HR, and tax administration. Its $89 starting price is a steep entry point for a very small team, but it may suit a buyer who wants those services together. Ask which tax tasks and HR features are included before comparing it with a lower-priced payroll plan.
What works
- Essentials covers 1–5 employees
- Processes payroll across multiple states
- Calculates and files payroll taxes electronically
What doesn't
- No free plan
- Essentials starts at $89 per month
- Annual pricing isn’t published

03How we chose
We ranked these tools for a team of 1–10, weighing published starting prices, small-team fit, tax support, and whether the offering is focused payroll or a broader workforce package. We looked for free payroll plans, but the picks here are listed with paid starting prices. A starting price is not the same as a total for several seats, so we flag base fees and per-employee charges when noted. We also consider plan limits, vendor documentation, and Reddit sentiment as checks on fit. We make no hands-on testing or benchmark claims.
04How to compare payroll costs for a few seats
Treat the advertised starting price as a question to investigate, not your final budget. Some vendors charge a base fee plus a per-employee amount; others may quote a custom price. Patriot Payroll starts at $8.50, but its listing says tax filing costs more. Fingercheck starts at $29 and notes a base fee plus every employee. Gusto starts at $49, with both the base fee and seats to budget for.
Ask each vendor for the monthly total at your current headcount, including tax filings, year-end tasks, and any required add-ons. Then ask what happens to the bill if you add one employee. The vendors listed here do not show a free payroll plan, so don’t mistake a $0 earned-wage-access service for a tool that runs payroll and files taxes.
05Check fit, setup, and the next stage
Choose for the way your team works, not the longest feature list. QuickBooks Online Payroll is a natural price check if your books already use QuickBooks. Fingercheck is aimed at hourly and deskless teams; Toast Payroll is aimed at restaurants already using Toast. If you need payroll and HR together, compare Gusto with the cost of a payroll-only plan plus any separate tools you need.
Before signing, ask how long setup usually takes, what payroll history or employee details you must provide, and whether the vendor helps with a provider change. Setup times are not published in the listings for these picks, so get the vendor’s estimate in writing. Revisit your choice when the team adds locations, worker types, or HR needs—and compare the new total, not just the starting price.
Questions people ask
Is there free payroll software for a small team?
None of the payroll picks here is listed with a free payroll plan; their published starting prices are paid. Some earned-wage-access services advertise a $0 employer option, but that is not the same as software that calculates payroll, pays workers, and files payroll taxes.
What does payroll software cost for five employees?
A five-person total is not published for these picks. Starting prices range from Patriot Payroll at $8.50 to Heartland Payroll at $89, but some listings note base fees or per-employee charges. Ask each vendor for a written monthly total for five employees, including tax filing.
Which payroll software is easiest to set up?
Setup effort is not published for the picks in this guide, so we can’t rank them reliably by setup time. Ask vendors what information and payroll records you must provide, whether they help transfer existing data, and how long setup typically takes for a team your size.
When should a small team switch payroll software?
Revisit your choice when the team adds employees, locations, or worker types, or when you need more HR, scheduling, or time-tracking support. Compare the new all-in price and ask whether your current plan supports those needs before renewing or switching.